Valdiviola wrote:I would like to take this opportunity to suggest that the community has a discussion about how we 'scorinate' future world cups...
...three of our four semi-finalists failed to so much as post a roster before the world cup, or post any RP in the thread as far as I can tell, and yet have managed to knock out fully fleshed out teams with histories and back stories abound! Two of those teams have now ceased to exist.
Almost half the teams to make the knockout stages failed to post rosters/RPs whilst a number of teams failed to progress who even had a story arc going across multiple competitions with recurring characters!
While not catching the CTE'd teams until earlier is regrettable, and disqualifying those teams in accordance with NSS guidelines would have assisted in this manner...
The rest of what happened is simply the name of the game. Each tournament host, for any sport, is charged with determining the balance between the "three R's" - rank, RP bonus, and randomness - and every tournament the desired effect of these factors may be different. While future hosts can look at the results of this tournament and try to set up the technical details so that results are less random, I would also caution against any future hosts overreacting to this batch of results.
Whilst I enjoy the randomness of the sport, we surely need to do more to reward the efforts of the community that get involved going forward - I have no idea how this would be done, I should add.
The efforts of players who got involved were rewarded - with a greater chance of winning. No one is guaranteed, nor entitled to, a better result simply because they RPed. As I mentioned, future hosts - including players who have been around much longer and/or more consistently, and therefore do have an idea of how this would be done - may choose to adjust the technical details of scorination, but the degree of randomness will always remain.
And randomness is a good thing - it allows for the element of surprise, for active newer nations to get a shot at entering the top of their respective sports, for back-and-forth rivalries to develop. In the long run, the teams who participate more frequently and with higher quality achieve will achieve the better results.