The Algonquian Nations Whaling Party was making its way back towards land after an unproductive hunting expedition, when the ocean waves appeared to be suddenly and unusually high. There was no wind, and no sign in the skies of any incoming weather. In fact, the sky was clear and the sun was setting, and it was generally a calm and beautiful night.
Unlike more advanced nations, the hunting party did not have instruments and electronic depth finders. The most they permitted themselves were outboard motors and binoculars, small concessions to modernity in the midst of their traditional lifestyle. Points of land, stars, the position of the sun, prevailing currents, and location of islands was enough to give them a reading on their position.
"People, look at this!' a warrior who was keeping watch at the stern suddenly yelled. "You seeing this?," he added.
Behind the boat, and several nautical miles away, a large rocky plateau had risen above the sea level. It wasn't marked on any chart they'd made, and wasn't a known landmark.
The whalers watched in amazement, as the plateau appeared to become more visible, even as the current grew stronger and carried them further away. Qiye, the head of the hunting party and captain of the vessel, turned off the motor and came around back to look. He picked up his binoculars and stared at what seemed like forever at the object on the horizon.
He finally spoke up.
"Our ancestors told the story of an island nation that sank beneath the waves many years ago, before our grandfathers were born. That's where it was," he said, all while staring out at sea. Then he turned to his hunting party.
"We need to get back to the People, and let them know what we have seen."
He returned to the cabin, pushed the boat full throttle, and headed towards the Algonquian homeland.
That evening, the World News Service announced the sudden existence of the island. It was now just a matter of time until the island gave up its mysteries.