SETA High Court [SETA Members Only]

[Romextly]

"So you are saying that Isaanistan is no longer except for Somalia?"

"To a degree yes, but our goal is still to reestablish/reclaim enemy territory and hand it over to the isaani government"

"Are you claiming that the Isaani government is in exile?

[New Antarcticania]

"To a degree yes, but our goal is still to reestablish/reclaim enemy territory and hand it over to the isaani government"

"Are you claiming that the Isaani government is in exile?

"No, we still believed that isaanistan is a country and not in exile"

[Romextly]

"Are you claiming that the Isaani government is in exile?

"No, we still believed that isaanistan is a country and not in exile"

"Then why are you trying to 'reestablish/reclaim enemy territory and hand it over to the isaani government'"?

[New Antarcticania]

"Although we still state that isaanistan is still s county, this does not ignore the fact the the republic of rayane is inciting rebellions inside insaanistan. And this does not ignore the fact that isaanistan has lost more than half of their territory"

[Romextly]

"Although we still state that isaanistan is still s county, this does not ignore the fact the the republic of rayane is inciting rebellions inside insaanistan. And this does not ignore the fact that isaanistan has lost more than half of their territory"

"So you call them rebels?"

[New Antarcticania]

"Although we still state that isaanistan is still s county, this does not ignore the fact the the republic of rayane is inciting rebellions inside insaanistan. And this does not ignore the fact that isaanistan has lost more than half of their territory"

"So you call them rebels?"

We belive that the factions founding was not caused by rayane infulance, rather than president mustafa's demise"

[Romextly]

"So you call them rebels?"

We belive that the factions founding was not caused by rayane infulance, rather than president mustafa's demise"

"Yet, we do not call ISIS, even though they have pronounced that they are a state, do we?"

[New Antarcticania]

We belive that the factions founding was not caused by rayane infulance, rather than president mustafa's demise"

"Yet, we do not call ISIS, even though they have pronounced that they are a state, do we?"

"Isis is not a country, its a terrorist organization, a terrible one at that"

[Romextly]

"Yet, we do not call ISIS, even though they have pronounced that they are a state, do we?"

"Isis is not a country, its a terrorist organization, a terrible one at that"

"But they still claim to be a state, like these rebels."

[New Antarcticania]

"Isis is not a country, its a terrorist organization, a terrible one at that"

"But they still claim to be a state, like these rebels."

"ISIS is always on the move, from one place to another. Unlike a state"

[South Cayriya]

Shall we move onto Langenia now?

[Langenia]

Shall we move onto Langenia now?

OOC: What did I do?

[South Cayriya]

Shall we move onto Langenia now?

OOC: What did I do?

you used nuclear weapons

violation of article 51 of the geneva conventions 1977

[Langenia]

OOC: What did I do?

you used nuclear weapons

violation of article 51 of the geneva conventions 1977

"We are not signatory to the 1977 Geneva Convention. Also, we didn't use it against civilians. Finally, our nuclear weapons were small, controlled explosions like those created by a Davy Crockett nuke. The radiation doesn't get far. And we didn't fire many."

[New Antarcticania]

OOC: What did I do?

you used nuclear weapons

Then why are we obliged to follow the same article?

[South Cayriya]

you used nuclear weapons

violation of article 51 of the geneva conventions 1977

OOC: We are not signatory to the 1977 Geneva Convention. Also, we didn't use it against civilians. Finally, our nuclear weapons were small, controlled explosions like those created by a Davy Crockett nuke. The radiation doesn't get far. And we didn't fire many.

Then where did you launch it?

[Langenia]

OOC: We are not signatory to the 1977 Geneva Convention. Also, we didn't use it against civilians. Finally, our nuclear weapons were small, controlled explosions like those created by a Davy Crockett nuke. The radiation doesn't get far. And we didn't fire many.

Then where did you launch it?

"At some fields or valleys where I assume there was a large concentration of communist Insaani soldiers."

[South Cayriya]

Then where did you launch it?

OOC: At some fields or valleys where I assume there was a large concentration of communist Insaani soldiers.

OOC: then that would be fine.

[New Antarcticania]

"Yes"

The Treaty on the Prohibition of Nuclear Weapons (TPNW), or the Nuclear Weapon Ban Treaty, is the first legally binding international agreement to comprehensively prohibit nuclear weapons with the ultimate goal being their total elimination.

You have clearly violated this treaty.

So uhh, why do I get a violation for this for this when langleia is also launching nukes?

[Langenia]

The Treaty on the Prohibition of Nuclear Weapons (TPNW), or the Nuclear Weapon Ban Treaty, is the first legally binding international agreement to comprehensively prohibit nuclear weapons with the ultimate goal being their total elimination.

You have clearly violated this treaty.

So uhh, why do I get a violation for this for this when langleia is also launching nukes?

OOC: South Cayriya, as long as the nation did not sign the TPNW, they are not breaking any laws. He is not violating any treaty.

[South Cayriya]

The Treaty on the Prohibition of Nuclear Weapons (TPNW), or the Nuclear Weapon Ban Treaty, is the first legally binding international agreement to comprehensively prohibit nuclear weapons with the ultimate goal being their total elimination.

You have clearly violated this treaty.

So uhh, why do I get a violation for this for this when langleia is also launching nukes?

Because you launched it at civilians

[Langenia]

-snip-

[South Cayriya]

So uhh, why do I get a violation for this for this when langleia is also launching nukes?

OOC: South Cayriya, as long as the nation did not sign the TPNW, they are not breaking any laws. He is not violating any treaty.

He is committing a war crime by targeting civilians with a nuclear bomb. The TPNW did not even go into effect yet, not even IRL.

[Langenia]

OOC: South Cayriya, as long as the nation did not sign the TPNW, they are not breaking any laws. He is not violating any treaty.

He is committing a war crime by targeting civilians with a nuclear bomb. The TPNW did not even go into effect yet, not even IRL.

"Yeah, targeting civilians is wrong, but just using nukes isn't as long as you don't sign the TPNW."

[New Antarcticania]

OOC: South Cayriya, as long as the nation did not sign the TPNW, they are not breaking any laws. He is not violating any treaty.

He is committing a war crime by targeting civilians with a nuclear bomb. The TPNW did not even go into effect yet, not even IRL.

I think the effect thing means "effective until"