The Tolkien RP Group [P2TM RP Group]

[Dain II Ironfoot]

I'm wondering if there would be any interest in a modified reboot of a previous RP of mine: http://forum.nationstates.net/viewtopic.php?f=31&t=284312&p=18929224&hilit=Lord+of+the+Rings#p18929224

I guess some changes should be made to it and i could use some help with that though.

[The Starlight]

Hello, Krugmar!

Sup Starlight, only just noticed this and had to join. I just love Tolkien's Dwarves, and Orthanc.

Of course, who could you not?

[The Starlight]

I'm wondering if there would be any interest in a modified reboot of a previous RP of mine: http://forum.nationstates.net/viewtopic.php?f=31&t=284312&p=18929224&hilit=Lord+of+the+Rings#p18929224

I guess some changes should be made to it and i could use some help with that though.

Wait a sec, you're Limborg?

[G-Tech Corporation]

I'm wondering if there would be any interest in a modified reboot of a previous RP of mine: http://forum.nationstates.net/viewtopic.php?f=31&t=284312&p=18929224&hilit=Lord+of+the+Rings#p18929224

I guess some changes should be made to it and i could use some help with that though.

Wait a sec, you're Limborg?

More importantly, Dan.

[The Starlight]

Wait a sec, you're Limborg?

More importantly, Dan.

HE'S BACK!!!!!!!!!!

[Osnil]

More importantly, Dan.

HE'S BACK!!!!!!!!!!

So, is this a good thing? Or should we let Her* deal with it?
*Her, of course, meaning Shelob.

[Prusslandia]

Dan hath returned. Ready yourselves, the dwarves march upon us.

[Osnil]

Dan hath returned. Ready yourselves, the dwarves march upon us.

Release the Krakken-wait-that's Pirates of the Carribean.

[Dain II Ironfoot]

I'm wondering if there would be any interest in a modified reboot of a previous RP of mine: http://forum.nationstates.net/viewtopic.php?f=31&t=284312&p=18929224&hilit=Lord+of+the+Rings#p18929224

I guess some changes should be made to it and i could use some help with that though.

Wait a sec, you're Limborg?

Yup

Wait a sec, you're Limborg?

More importantly, Dan.

That was even before i had Limborg
Just made me realize, this should really become my period nation, i changed too many times.

More importantly, Dan.

HE'S BACK!!!!!!!!!!

Dan hath returned. Ready yourselves, the dwarves march upon us.

Now don't get too excited

[The Starlight]

Wait a sec, you're Limborg?

Yup

More importantly, Dan.

That was even before i had Limborg
Just made me realize, this should really become my period nation, i changed too many times.

HE'S BACK!!!!!!!!!!

Dan hath returned. Ready yourselves, the dwarves march upon us.

Now don't get too excited

Anyway, Naught but Ashes is kinda like that but sure, we could do a reboot of that. Looking at it, we should probably have multiple adventures going on at the same time to allow for more players.

[The Starlight]

Oh, and were you not able to restore your old account? Because you can do that, you know.

[Dain II Ironfoot]

(Image)

Anyway, Naught but Ashes is kinda like that but sure, we could do a reboot of that. Looking at it, we should probably have multiple adventures going on at the same time to allow for more players.

I see yes, i'll try to see what i can come up with in the next couple of days.

Oh, and were you not able to restore your old account? Because you can do that, you know.

I know, i just figured it was time for a new account

Anyhow, you all have any ideas for what those adventures could be?
Last time i had the following (as far as i can remember):
Harondor (small scale war between Gondor and Harad/Umbar/Mordor)
Khazad-Dûm (small scale war between Dwarves and Orcs and Balrog)
Gundabad (small scale war between Dwarves and Orcs)
Entwives (A small story which would allow the ents to be on the good side once the real war started)
Angmar (A small scale war between Orcs/Mordor and Elves/Men)

Anyhow, we could also add some small stories that could lead to having more troops once the real war of the ring would start. Think of a story that would involve the Dwarves of the West, the Dwarves of the East and Rhûn. By those three it would mainly be a story that would lead to the Dwarves of the East (clans could make different decisions ofcourse) joining good or evil, or staying neutral ofcourse. Simular stories could be made within Harad, Gondor, the lands of Arnor ect.

[Escalan Corps-Star Island]

(Image)

Anyway, Naught but Ashes is kinda like that but sure, we could do a reboot of that. Looking at it, we should probably have multiple adventures going on at the same time to allow for more players.

I see yes, i'll try to see what i can come up with in the next couple of days.

Oh, and were you not able to restore your old account? Because you can do that, you know.

I know, i just figured it was time for a new account

Anyhow, you all have any ideas for what those adventures could be?
Last time i had the following (as far as i can remember):
Harondor (small scale war between Gondor and Harad/Umbar/Mordor)
Khazad-Dûm (small scale war between Dwarves and Orcs and Balrog)
Gundabad (small scale war between Dwarves and Orcs)
Entwives (A small story which would allow the ents to be on the good side once the real war started)
Angmar (A small scale war between Orcs/Mordor and Elves/Men)

Anyhow, we could also add some small stories that could lead to having more troops once the real war of the ring would start. Think of a story that would involve the Dwarves of the West, the Dwarves of the East and Rhûn. By those three it would mainly be a story that would lead to the Dwarves of the East (clans could make different decisions ofcourse) joining good or evil, or staying neutral ofcourse. Simular stories could be made within Harad, Gondor, the lands of Arnor ect.

The King Under the Mountain has returned.
Nice to see you're still alive.

[The Starlight]

The King Under the Mountain has returned.
Nice to see you're still alive.

The Lord of Silver Fountains,
The King of carven stone,
Shall come into his own.
And the bells shall ring in gladness at the Mountain King's return,
But all shall fail in sadness and the lake will shine and burn.

[Prusslandia]

The King Under the Mountain has returned.
Nice to see you're still alive.

The Lord of Silver Fountains,
The King of carven stone,
Shall come into his own.
And the bells shall ring in gladness at the Mountain King's return,
But all shall fail in sadness and the lake will shine and burn.

I, Melkor, don't get a song ?

[The Industrial States of Columbia]

The Lord of Silver Fountains,
The King of carven stone,
Shall come into his own.
And the bells shall ring in gladness at the Mountain King's return,
But all shall fail in sadness and the lake will shine and burn.

I, Melkor, don't get a song ?

You made your own song, oh great one...

[Prusslandia]

I, Melkor, don't get a song ?

You made your own song, oh great one...

Then sing my song, skald.

[The Industrial States of Columbia]

You made your own song, oh great one...

Then sing my song, skald.

But I am of the darkness made light. The sun that rises to the setting of all others. Lisch inexorable...

[Maltropia]

Hey, I fixed the Rammas Echor just in time for the Siege of Minas Tirith and didn't get a song, but you don't see me complaining.

[The Starlight]

Hey, I fixed the Rammas Echor just in time for the Siege of Minas Tirith and didn't get a song, but you don't see me complaining.

And a whole lot of good that did.
Tell me, then why did the Battle of Pelennor Fields happen, hmm?

[Dain II Ironfoot]

I see yes, i'll try to see what i can come up with in the next couple of days.


I know, i just figured it was time for a new account

Anyhow, you all have any ideas for what those adventures could be?
Last time i had the following (as far as i can remember):
Harondor (small scale war between Gondor and Harad/Umbar/Mordor)
Khazad-Dûm (small scale war between Dwarves and Orcs and Balrog)
Gundabad (small scale war between Dwarves and Orcs)
Entwives (A small story which would allow the ents to be on the good side once the real war started)
Angmar (A small scale war between Orcs/Mordor and Elves/Men)

Anyhow, we could also add some small stories that could lead to having more troops once the real war of the ring would start. Think of a story that would involve the Dwarves of the West, the Dwarves of the East and Rhûn. By those three it would mainly be a story that would lead to the Dwarves of the East (clans could make different decisions ofcourse) joining good or evil, or staying neutral ofcourse. Simular stories could be made within Harad, Gondor, the lands of Arnor ect.

The King Under the Mountain has returned.
Nice to see you're still alive.

Ofcourse i am, being dead seems so boring

[Maltropia]

Hey, I fixed the Rammas Echor just in time for the Siege of Minas Tirith and didn't get a song, but you don't see me complaining.

And a whole lot of good that did.
Tell me, then why did the Battle of Pelennor Fields happen, hmm?

Because a certain Mithrandir didn't appreciate my efforts to protect the richest farmlands west of Anduin is why.

[The Starlight]

And a whole lot of good that did.
Tell me, then why did the Battle of Pelennor Fields happen, hmm?

Because a certain Mithrandir didn't appreciate my efforts to protect the richest farmlands west of Anduin is why.

Money isn't everything, Ingold.
In the words of Theoden-King: "Crops can be re-sown, homes re-built. Within these walls... we will outlast them."

[Maltropia]

Because a certain Mithrandir didn't appreciate my efforts to protect the richest farmlands west of Anduin is why.

Money isn't everything, Ingold.
In the words of Theoden-King: "Crops can be re-sown, homes re-built. Within these walls... we will outlast them."

Richest as in most fertile. If they get burned and covered in blood, you're not going to be growing anything there for a while. Also we did totally outlast them behind the Rammas so I consider this dispute over.

[Great Franconia and Verana]

So, I was scrolling through the thread and saw a debate idea. Glorfindel? Are the Lords of Gondolin and Rivendell once in the same?

Imo yes, they are. They both possess the same features and they are both alluded to as being incredibly powerful, with a full paragraph of text to describe Glorfindels power in the "Fellowship of the Ring." It is also their feats that would be looked at. Glorfindel 2.0 was able to ride openly against the Nazgul, and was on the White Council. He had an immense presence in both the seen and unseen worlds, ans it was said that he was one of the greatest elf lords of the Third Age. He was "One of the mighty of the first born, and an elf Lord of a house of Princes." And that's not even mentioning the various quotes, hints and other facts in Tolkien's other writings, including this:

". . . At any rate what at first sight may seem the simplest solution must be abandoned: sc. that we have merely a reduplication of names, and that Glorfindel of Gondolin and Glorfindel of Rivendell were different persons. This repetition of so striking a name, though possible, would not be credible… Also it may be found that acceptance of the identity of Glorfindel of old and of the Third Age will actually explain what is said of him and improve the story. . ."