SaintB wrote:G-Tech Corporation wrote:
Hmm, a few things.
1) IIRC, gunpowder was never used at Helm's Deep. In this canon the forces there were much smaller, and easily overrun by the forces of Saruman.
2) It doesn't seem that there was a difference made between Uruks and Uruk-Hai of Saruman by Tolkien,
3) Saruman isn't (yet, or necessarily ever) a traitor in the eyes of Sauron, so having him strung up for associating with Saruman's symbols doesn't really make sense.
Perhaps after he was passed over in favor of one of his rivals, Lagurz simply deserted with a portion of the forces that were loyal to him?
1. I'll edit that to broken.
2. I don't think there is a functional difference but there is a cultural rivalry between the Isengard and Mordor Uruks. I was going by things read in the IC and in another App (Delsola's) I just figured Uruk-hai (which would be Orc-men translated from black speech) was a way that Isengard Uruks differentiated themselves.
3. I never meant for that to be actual. Just the reasoning used by Naga and the other Mordor Uruks to justify stringing up Lagûrz. Basically the reason is because screw Isengard, but there is also Delsola's faction The Legion of the White Hand that is sort of in defiance of Sauron's orders too. I can try to write that more clearly?
3. Hmm, still, that's not the sort of logic that would mean the Uruks superiors would allow them to execute another commander. The Legion isn't in open rebellion iirc, just they will be if they ever get posted. As it stands, the Uruks of Isengard are well integrated into Sauron's army, so I'm just not entirely sure where the "screw Isengard" vibe comes from. They were successful allies in the war after all.
Also, to those who are running Good: is anyone planning to oppose my forces in northern Eriadoe? There's a host nearing the Trollshaws, so I figure I should check if anyone is planning to post before I actively send forces near Imladris.





