Constructively rate the above nation's flag (8)

[Colligny]

Wow. Artistic. I love it, could go with a bit of simplifying though, 8/10.

[Laka Strolistandiler]

10/10. Looks VERY epic, with a simple yet very memorable and meaningful design. Love it

[Berhakonia]

Eh it looks kinda MS-painty, it's not a terrible flag, it just doesn't look natural.

[Filipinn]

Eh it looks kinda MS-painty, it's not a terrible flag, it just doesn't look natural.

6.5/10. I do like the logo-or-ensign-or-whatever-that-is emblem on the flag, but can you make the field part longer?

[Sherechia]

7.5/10 as a flag it gets the job done, plus I like the color combination and cross design, Though that's all I'm going to give since there are better flags out there, still, pretty good.

[Lescaaris]

8/10, simplistic and realistic, something I could remember if it were a nation in this world. The words on the flag may just be 1-2 symbols, but they are unique enough, and at least it's not that one time Libya had a green-only flag. I don't know what else to say.

[Pivnichia]

Your flag is recognizable, can be seen from afar, has enough contrast and a nice design. I don't really like the symbol on the left and the symbol on the right, but that's probably since I don't really know what they are supposed to represent. Also I'm not a fan of black and yellow (as ironic as it may sound considering my flag is very dark blue and gold).

Without my dislike of black and yellow: 9/10
With my dislike of black and yellow: 7.8/10

[SkalVinos]

It's really good and distinctive. Unfortunately, I usually play on mobile so the image quality is often shot to hell. *laugh* The compass design is different from most compass designs I've seen, which tend to be thicker and with letters signifying the cardinal directions. This gold and thin compass design is plain novel—even if I have a hard time seeing it because bloody mobile. Oh, and have I told you about how simple the whole flag design is? Because it's really gosh darn simple while still being good. Hard to determine from a distance though.

The triochromatic color design isn't half bad (although I'm pretty sure that black is supposed to be dark purple... or is that just an AHA thing? sorry, didn't read the sig), but it's rather uninteresting. Easy to color though. You also use the or-argent combo on the vertical fess, which sometimes tend to be blinding and garish, but the skewed ratio made it look a lot better.

All in all, objectively speaking, 4 out of 5.

[Imperial Rifta]

I like the colors, they blend really well. As for the flower, it blends in well. Everything complements the other features, creating a well designed flag. The only problem is, is that it looks like a banner, and I think it should, be flipped to look like a flag. It’s unique though.

8/10

[Colligny]

Too complex, but i like the symbol.
5/10

[Roegerland]

9/10

Love the design, it's nice and simple but also tells you what you need to know. Normally I would recoil from red directly next to blue but it's fairly minor here so it sort of gets away with it.

[Guama]

8/10 — Nice, clean design. Good colors. Pleasant to look at. My sole issue (and it's just personal preference) is the white bar. Understandable why it's there but perhaps some modification needed.

[SkalVinos]

The flag honestly looks like a combination of Liberia's and Cuba's. Not very original, but easy to draw and remember. That said, it's also rather undistinctive given said unoriginality, and I would have probably gotten it mixed up with the actual Cuban flag. Two out of five.

I apologize if I come off as too harsh in my judgement, but I stand by what I've said.

[Tremulo]

Very distinct colors, decent contrast, not too bright or garish, distinct shape, and easily recognizable. Can't find much on meaning, but it works well enough.

I'd say you've done an excellent job!

[Antwerp Free State]

Interesting design, though might look better with a brighter shade of yellow. 8/10

[Free Rosabell]

It looks generic but I like that it's easy to identify and understand properly. The lion on the left, symbolizes strength and pride. It's simple yet nice

[Waldoven]

Honestly, the fact that the red isn't perfectly equal the the black is slightly annoying. I like the twin keys. It is original. It is simple. It is unique. Weirdly I actually prefer if the red bar at the bottom was gone. It is an okay flag though. Nice and simple. 7/10

[Salzcovia]

9.8/10. Great colors and symbols, but the symbol inside of the smaller circle looks strange.

[Colligny]

I like it, But the pink's too Bright. 8/10.

[Tsaivao]

4/10 - It feels so unbalanced with the massive white field and the two stripes (which for some reason are on the sinister side?). Doing away with the stripes or the canton would make it better, or moving the stripes somewhere else. Right now it just feels very asymmetric.

BN: Please rate this flag:

[Royal Sirenia]

7/10. The design work is good but I feel the shapes take up too much of the flag.

[Aenglide]

Well, I don't like the ripple and obviously its a colonial flag with a coat of arms which aren't great but i'm not judging it if its the style of nation (colony perhaps) you are going for. 7/10

[Sherechia]

It uses the somewhat common cross design but I have to say I really like that color combination of blue, green and white, as a flag it gets the job done, I haven't mistaken you for someone else. Overal 8.0/10.

[Feudalist America]

It is a quite plain and basic design. Not that there's anything wrong with it, but the symbolism is very hard to find. The symbols are well unknown to me, and the color scheme really only tells me about the purity and sacrifice of the nation.

Overall, I'd say 6/10, since it can convey meaning quite well, but -4 because the symbolism is quite unintelligible concerning the symbols.

[Roegerland]

4/10

There are lines of uneven thickness, the starry cantons seem to be stretched and slightly distorted and with the crown, seems to be overcrowded. I think it would be better to select 1 or 2 elements of the design and come up with something simpler/more plain (but that's just my opinion)