Constructively rate the above nation's flag (8)

[Dod Nersialand]

Lose the ripple.

The triangle should be in a different place, or just go, as now it creates the impression of a white short under a burgundy jacket.

Not sure what the globular object represents, but at present it seems like a Christmas bauble hanging from the collar.

4/10

Suggestion: simplify.
Just a plain burgundy flag,with the "bauble" in either black or white, would make a much stronger statement.

the circle was meant to be a globe but thank you for your criticism /skipme

[Plisseau]

6/10. A little busy, with some details that irk me.

The black border on the white triangle isn’t needed, especially on the top.

The red star that’s behind the middle black star is also not centered. It’s rotated at some weird angle.

[Perikuresu]

9/10
The colours mesh well and it's pleasing to the eye

[Roegerland]

8.5/10

Very nice looking flag and unique to boot, the bottom white stripe does seem to be slightly tapered though...

[Broader Confederate States]

9/10, simple, flaglike, and memorable while being pleasant to look at. I was going to design something like it for BCS, but didn't want to steal your look.

[Roegerland]

9/10, simple, flaglike, and memorable while being pleasant to look at. I was going to design something like it for BCS, but didn't want to steal your look.

Fill your boots mate, doesn't bother me!

/Skip

[Guama]

7/10 — Simple and memorable design, coupled with nice (muted) shades. My sole ‘criticism’ would be the fimbration on the triangle can make the flag look disjointed.

[Northern Amerique]

Is OK, little plain, but it give nice Caribbean vibes which i think is what you're going for. Might wanna zhuzh it up bit, maybe stretch the canton into the full hoist and ad another symbol

[Aenglide]

Interesting black and gold design! Very unique while maintaining the American flag look. 8/10 Looks nice.

[Perikuresu]

6/10
Basic design (which isn't a bad thing) but the colours don't mix together well

[Reino de Portvgal]

Beautiful flag, with good colours and good design. 9/10

[Guama]

5/10 — Feels more San Marino than Portugal. Nevertheless, it's not a bad design but the central arms are a little jarring, what with being black and complex. It doesn't really work with the lighter colors of the background.

[Laka Strolistandiler]

9/10- seems pretty original and well-visible from a long distance, also follows all the traditional rules of the heraldic (being the ability of a 5 year-old to draw a flag).

---

BN yes I know that the coat of arms is not in a position of honor and there is an IC reason for this.

[Vikanias]

Original design, the size of the three stripes reminds me of the Columbian flag. There’s not much to criticize in this as it’s n i c e.

10/10


BN: the only way I’m getting a rating above 5 is if someone thinks baby seals are cute.

[Roegerland]

1/10

Club club sealy

[Dowaesk]

9.9/10

Its very nice, but I think it can be just slightly better. I stared at it for a long time. Couldnt put my finger on it.

[Sherechia]

I think the color combination is nice, especially with the 2 different shades of blue. It's slightly complicated but still easy to draw so no points deducted from that, overall I think this deserves an 8.3. I've seen better but this one is still pretty good.

[Paxaklemtorno]

The writing on the flag reminds me of the Crimean Tatar and of the Idel-Ural flags, and the overall minimalism is very up my alley. Outside of my subjective feels, the flag works really well, as it is both simple and memorable, and white on red combination is one tested by time.

10/10

[Laka Strolistandiler]

Honestly the symbol seems a little bit over complicated, however I believe that it means something that I don’t know IC, so it doesn’t count. The general lack of other details also seems somewhat dull to me- 7/10.

[Isle of Emerald]

Pretty simple, but I like it that way. Nice, unique color scheme as well.

[Sanhana]

9/10. i love the communist symbols implying such a system, and it tells me everything i need to know about them with just a look, although the red is a little too dark in my opinion

[Berhakonia]

While I encourage the use of irregular colours on flags, Sanhana's, however, strikes me as odd and quite bland. Brown and dull blue do not stand out enough when used simultaneously.

[Jack and Diane]

It's pretty interesting, but some of the details seem kind of blurry. 9/10

[The Carenian Martian Authority]

Cougar/10

Berhakonia: 8/10 very interesting Coat of Arms design, would look much better in a higher resolution but Ik there's some kind of limit so I won't count that against it

[Onocarcass]

I genuinely don't have many criticisms. Maybe a bit darker red. But I love it tbh.

10/10