Constructively rate the above nation's flag (8)

[Sacrary]

It's a little pixelated. Like, the overall design seems nice and would work well with a streamlined design, but it's a little diminished in its pixelated form. The colours work well however, and the symbolism conveys the nation's identity adequately.

A 7/10 in its current form!

[Samicana]

Overall I think it's a good flag, may need to be simplified

9/10

[WonderMart]

Very interesting, I like the idea of the trident, it's meaningful and recognizable. From a composition standpoint, I think there are better ways to represent the elements encapsulated within the flag, starting with a simpler, more cohesive colour combination.

[Islas Cardinales]

The color scheme is nice and one could say it looks like a full flag. The only personal grievances I have with it are the calligraphic simplicity of the 'WM', this doesn't disrupt anything though.

9.5/10

[Fatimida]

The symbol at the center of the flag is too small to see properly without zooming in the site and the colour scheme, no offense intended, is a bit ugly, but beyond that it is a decent looking flag.
5.6/10

[Roegerland]

5/10

It looks nice but I just don't think this type of calligraphic flag holds up to the modern flag standards to which I most agree with.

[Synne Industries]

---

Slightly desaturated colors, you love to see it [+2]
Palette works and personally I think it's pretty [+1.5]
Unique incorporation of that thin vertical stripe [+1.5]
Placement of elements works fine [+1]
Recognizable from a distance [+1]
Easy enough to remember and draw [+1]

---

Nothing I could find that really detracts from it

---

Total: 8/10

---

BN: Link to IC flag

[Novo Portugal]

Simple, recognizable good symbols and color scheme. 9/10

[The Burke Islands]

8/10, good color scheme, but the yellow symbols on the front look out of place.

[Fatimida]

The amount of repetitive symbols is a bit much but I love the colour. The dots could be a bit bigger but those are my sole criticisms.
6/10

[Stahllicht]

I really like the flag's design, though the crown and crescent moon could be slightly bigger.

7.5/10

[Drifterica]

It's very simple. The colors work well together and it gives of a Nazi-esque feeling. Though the line looks kind of weird to me. 7.5/10

[Aenglide]

Nice colour palette! The good old classic yellow and purple. Also nice crown. I think the yellow overpowers too much a tiny bit though. 8/10

[Roegerland]

9/10

Lovely flag, could easily be a Westcountry English county flag. Colours just a little too bright for my liking though.

[Reino de Portvgal]

9/10 Very good looking and has a calm vibe, I like it, nothing much to say, maybe the fact that the left stripe and the bottom one are on the same colour, but it works so not really a criticism.

[Ygria]

The two stripe background is nice and calming. On the other hand, the coat of arms is rather busy and funky, but mostly in a good way. While that contrast is a bit distracting, it's also good, because the calm background waters down the busy coat of arms.

9/10.

[Murazgora]

the flag is formatted quite cleanly and is competent, but the color choice is a bit questionable in my opinion, mainly with how the black and burgundy part contrasts with the blue and white part, making it feel like two different flags in a not-very-good way

6/10

[Novo Portugal]

9/10, really like the color scheme and the design. Very good flag. Don't really know what could face improvement.

[The Disorder]

It is bright, and active, and it definitely grabs your attention! A tad on the complex side, but it works very well.

8/10

[Boring People]

Interesting Design
9/10

[Astinggalia]

7/10
the colors of the canton and cross are a bit hard to see but i like the design overall

[Badjuristan]

NINJA'D, EDITING

AN: 5/10. It's fine, but it's not flag shaped or very easy to draw.

[Schrack]

7/10, I think the color scheme works well and its overall design is good, but it does look like one of those stereotypical 'x-istan' Islamic flags

[Badjuristan]

7/10, I think the color scheme works well and its overall design is good, but it does look like one of those stereotypical 'x-istan' Islamic flags

i mean that do be the point tho
/skip

[Drifterica]

Looks to be a cool take on the American flag (I think it is anyways) If it is, there should be 13 stripes just to keep it more towards the American flag. 8/10