Constructively rate the above nation's flag (8)

[Aragon y Castilla]

9.7/10. The design is phenomenal, absolutely beautiful. The only problem I have is the emblem could be a bit bigger

[Saelmstica]

Aragon y Castilla's Flag

- Good colour palatte : just yellow and red
- Eye catching and thoughtful design flag
- The jewel is the design, beautiful drawing, unique symbol, proportionate colour placement
- But the design so beautiful that quite hard to draw-- simplified version perhaps?

7/10 Hard to draw but would keep it as collection

[Vykrotia]

6/10

Design is nice but I think the middle star is a little too big and the orange doesn't really work with the rest of the colors. Otherwise, looks nice.

[2nd Apil Republic]

Olive branch thingy and a eagle is the tops, easily 10/10

[BLACKGRUE]

Not usually one for a seal on a flag, but this one is pretty simple and easy to spot. The colors blend a little 6/10

[Soviet Adia]

The design seems a bit random, but otherwise fine, so 7/10

[Rhanukhan]

A well-proportioned design. The central charge is one of those complicated types, but avoids being needlessly fussy - a balance that not everybody achieves. I might be tempted to employ a brighter blue for greater contrast with the black - overall 8/10

[Republics of the Solar Union]

I must the sense of the orange background contrasted with a deep ocean blue keeps a warm and cozy feeling which very little facts achieve, and that octopus in the center is a perfect representation of the nation, a national symbol, which fits well in the environment the flag has created. Everyone can take some to learn from the complex juxtaposition of the colours or the beauty of such a simple but interesting symbol. One thing can be said and that is, I would believe this flag would be designed by an actual Rhanukhani. 10/10

[Soudar]

if there were less colors I would like it more, the design itself is cool but i gotta go 6/10

[La Paz de Los Ricos]

A very neat design! I do enjoy the elephant; though it might be a tad complicated to recreate exactly and the silhouette doesn't capture many of its features, it is unique, which I think is the point of flag emblems. The stars on the corners, I feel, could be better implemented. Maybe incorporating them somehow in the emblem would work better, such as having them in a circle?

Overall, 7/10 for the star placement and the elephant silhouette, but it is very nice overall!

[New Eestiball]

Love the symbol, but it needs to be bigger so that people can see the detail.
The gradientesque color scheme isn't great, maybe just a contrast, and the proportions feel a bit off.
5.5/10 but could be a 9 with just a little work.

[Lehpuhrta]

La Paz de Los Ricos - The colours and that intriguing charge felt like an Afrofuturist nation, so discovering that you're located in the Pacific was a surprise. All the same it is a pleasing flag - not one I can suggest any changes for - 10/10

ninja'd by New Eestiball - This is certainly the best iteration of your ever-evolving flag to date - a little simpler than some of its ancestors, but with an excellent dynamism. The colours work flawlessly, as ever - another 10/10

[Fame And Even More Fame]

A bit too complex, pink doesn’t blend well with the blue, not very flaglike. Would make an excellent logo, but not a flag. I think you should focus on the yellow and blue and try to redesign it. 3.5/10

[Republics of the Solar Union]

A bit too complex, pink doesn’t blend well with the blue, not very flaglike. Would make an excellent logo, but not a flag. I think you should focus on the yellow and blue and try to redesign it. 3.5/10

What, isn't that black?
/skipme

[Cannonio]

A bit too complex, pink doesn’t blend well with the blue, not very flaglike. Would make an excellent logo, but not a flag. I think you should focus on the yellow and blue and try to redesign it. 3.5/10

What, isn't that black?
/skipme

That is a very dark blue!

A bit too complex, pink doesn’t blend well with the blue, not very flaglike. Would make an excellent logo, but not a flag. I think you should focus on the yellow and blue and try to redesign it. 3.5/10

Pretty good flag, the use of white makes the red and green not clash with the black. The star in the middle is a pretty good size, but the crescent is pretty small. Maybe expand the star a tiny bit so the crescent can be bigger? 8/10.

[The Web Citadel]

the red and green clash a LOT, but the shapes and simple design work well. 6/10, but there's a lot of potential.

[Fragrancia]

7/10. Ignoring the anime character, it's got a pretty chill cyberpunk vibe and the dragon icon is pretty neat. I think I might have seen something similar in a game before, perhaps a violet one?

[Adharcaili]

Oh, lad, that is brilliant. It is so simple, yet unique and recognisable. 10/10

[Cannonio]

Good color scheme and I like how the background is not too fancy, but the harp is pretty complex for a flag with all of the intersecting lines and the intricate designs. 7/10.

[Raskana]

The red is a tad light, but otherwise good. 7/10.

[Russk]

just and ex nation...but honestly nation-states knew what they where doing when they made the EX-nation flag. LOL

[Ravemath]

The orthodox logo looks too big, so it looks frightening. Otherwise, it's a great flag! 9/10.

[The White City of Zerzura]

The raven is a bit pixelated, but I like the idea

[Prussianland]

9/10 very well done, stylish and represents the nation perfectly.

[Rivogna]

The design is a stylish rendition of the Nordic Cross with a cool coat of arms in the center, but it could use some color. For example, a dark Prussian blue could work well if it replaced the black. The red shade for the eagle's feet and beak could also replace the surrounding gray stripes. Regardless, I would rate the current design a 7.85/10.