Constructively rate the above nation's flag (8)

[Greater Rostoria]

Taosun: Took the Chinese flag, removed the party star and replaced it with a hammer and sickle, and then removed one of the stars that corresponded to one of the 4 Chinese social classes (probably the national bourgeoisie one). I don't hate it, but there are a million cooler ideas out there for a a Maoist inspired banner that don't look quite so basic or uninspired. That said, the symbolism does work and it isn't overly boring or complicated.

5/10, merely acceptable.

Ninja'd

AN: Fairly basic flag that does a good job in displaying its heraldry alongside the more classical green background colouration that I'm assuming represents the forested and naturally connected background of the regions. The heraldry is decently well done and shows off the ruling family's origins, religion, and state while not being overly designed and overstaying its welcome. Could perhaps be slightly more defined through a thicker shield border but otherwise a commendable effort.

7/10

BN: Do either the account flag or any of these: https://www.nationstates.net/page=dispatch/id=1896478

I will rate the New Oregon Republic flag from the dispatch: The flag is okay, not a big fan of the red line in the flag plus I would suggest going only for 3 colours. Symbolism is okay but a bit too small but it is distinct. Ill rate it like a 6/10

edit: Ninja'd

The flag of AN is solid, colours work really well, symbolism is present, and its distinct and can easily be drawn. 8/10

[Taosun]

Washington Colombia has a really neat flag. I like the design on the left, and festive Pride Month rainbow is awesome. 10/10

[Fragrancia]

I know this is sarcasm, but yeah not that good.

Red canvas + Communist symbol + Stars = Any ordinary and indistinguishable socialist flag

3/10, I'd say. You could probably add some anime characters, feet pics or maybe a vertical pride flag that looks more like a barcode.

[Anarcho-Merith]

I know this is sarcasm, but yeah not that good.

Red canvas + Communist symbol + Stars = Any ordinary and indistinguishable socialist flag

3/10, I'd say. You could probably add some anime characters, feet pics or maybe a vertical pride flag that looks more like a barcode.

10/10 The flag looks very cool, is unique, and simple enough. Well done

[New England and Greater New Brunswick]

Cool effect. Maybe not best suited for a flag, but on a screen at least both the icon and the main design seem pretty good. I can see them being worse in the air, though. 6/10.

[Neo Viking Scandinavia]

Cool effect. Maybe not best suited for a flag, but on a screen at least both the icon and the main design seem pretty good. I can see them being worse in the air, though. 6/10.

4/10. Other than the pride stuff there's not a lot going for the flag. The symbol is very small, and there isn't much in the actual design

[Settentrionalia]

5/10, while I do like some creativity to be added that’s just too much

[Inner Albania]

7/10 A bit too many elements in the flag.

[Neonian Technocracy]

???/10, not a flag.

[Baldwin Park]

6/10 Looks kind of like a kreigsmarine flag from Germany. I don't really like the colors or the crosses on it. Ummm. It's okay though I guess....

[Union of Albandrite Socialist Republics]

Overly complicated design, not too much of a flag either.

5/10, semi-cool design either way

[Reich of the New World Order]

Out of all the communist flags i have seen this is one of the best. It has good colour usage and a clear design. Nothing really wrong with it. 10/10

[Eeumerian Scotland]

Out of all the communist flags i have seen this is one of the best. It has good colour usage and a clear design. Nothing really wrong with it. 10/10

3/10. The characters just ruin the whole flag vibe. Remove them and it would be an 8/10

[New England and Greater New Brunswick]

Pretty cool. If anything, I'd remove the symbols and the stars and just have the cross. The symbol seems more like an official seal than a flag aspect. 8/10.

(If you wish to judge my normal flag, go to my factbooks where I have my normal flag).

[Taosun]

I love the Pride Colors and the main green color! 7/10; I’d recommend adding a bit more to it tho

[The Imperium Of Alarisia]

The flag looks a bit ugly, maybe make the hammer and sickle smaller and add more stars? (5/10)

[New Stonkopolis]

3/10
A black background with a white symbol is a terrible design choice. Secondly, the symbol in the center is very complex, and you should probably simplify it.
I have suggestions that I can make for a remade flag.

[Union of Albandrite Socialist Republics]

It's really solid, good colors and a unique design, as much as a big dollar sign pains me to compliment...

I'd say that simplifying the pentagon design would be a good move but it isn't really that crucial and boils down to preference
9/10

[Tyresaya]

looks pretty good I'd say 9/10

[Scytharum]

The color scheme works pretty well, but the design is a bit generic with a normal tricolor. It isn't a bad flag by any means, but it could be spiced up to make the flag stand out more as compared to other tricolors. Solid 8/10.

[Solar Ukraine]

The color scheme works pretty well, but the design is a bit generic with a normal tricolor. It isn't a bad flag by any means, but it could be spiced up to make the flag stand out more as compared to other tricolors. Solid 8/10.

10/10 The design is excellent!

New design yall! This I believe fits Ukraine much better

[Union of Albandrite Socialist Republics]

A unique take on the Ukranian flag but I don't like a lot of the choices.

The symbol in the middle being black causes it to blend when the image is smaller (or the flag is further away), making it harder to tell what it is. The white just doesn't feel like it belongs there and the circle in the middle being two colors just feels..off. Would be better if it was a solid color like blue and the symbol in the middle was a solid gold, that way it doesnt blend in as badly


5/10

[New Stonkopolis]

Daang!
I Never thought I would compliment a communist nation, but that flag is amazing!
The only thing I would suggest is moving the main symbol, what everyone looks at, to the center of the flag.
Other than that, it’s perfect.
9/10.

[Solar Ukraine]

A unique take on the Ukranian flag but I don't like a lot of the choices.

The symbol in the middle being black causes it to blend when the image is smaller (or the flag is further away), making it harder to tell what it is. The white just doesn't feel like it belongs there and the circle in the middle being two colors just feels..off. Would be better if it was a solid color like blue and the symbol in the middle was a solid gold, that way it doesnt blend in as badly


5/10

Thanks for the suggestions! I updated my flag keeping what you said in mind.


For the AN:

10/10. This is very cool and I love the combo of yellow and black.

[Reich of the New World Order]

Its a good flag but i do think it would be better if you had the background be like normal Ukraines flag. Right now it reminds me of the anarcho ideologies. 7/10