Constructively rate the above nation's flag (8)

[Union of Albandrite Socialist Republics]

I can't seem to find the actual image of the flag, and I dont think it looks particularly well edited onto that propaganda poster.

2/10 for presentation

what i can see is at least 7/10

[Merith]

I can't seem to find the actual image of the flag, and I dont think it looks particularly well edited onto that propaganda poster.

2/10 for presentation

what i can see is at least 7/10

10/10 It looks simple, it looks good and the symbol is unique. Well done

[Reich of the New World Order]

Its honestly a very good flag, there is nothing really bad to change. 10/10

[Redeeemed Black League]

Ok, I will give it 5/10 just because the characters for me gets all to trash, without the characters, it will be a very good/recognizable flag.

[Kampfler]

8/10 Simple and straight to the point. I like it.

[Anglian Angles]

9/10. Simple and good. It give the medieval vibe in a weird way. I think that black is a little don't fit because it don't go good with the way you doing it OR I just feel it weird.

[New England and Greater New Brunswick]

Weird fusions, fine flag. The white and colors make it look like a kingdom, but it's communist. THe fasces and hammer and sickle make it look Nazbol. However, even if the fasces' are a bit too much, still a 6/10.

[Delatia]

I know it's pride month and all, but you probably don't need to put the LGBTQIA+ flahs in your flag (not trying to be cancelled in NS of all websites but) 7/10 with it and 8/10 without it, (at least it actually looks like a flag and not a corporation, no offense.)

[New England and Greater New Brunswick]

I know it's pride month and all, but you probably don't need to put the LGBTQIA+ flahs in your flag (not trying to be cancelled in NS of all websites but) 7/10 with it and 8/10 without it, (at least it actually looks like a flag and not a corporation, no offense.)

Don't need to and my bad for forgetting, but my main version has gold instead of the flag.

/skip

[Reich of the New World Order]

I know it's pride month and all, but you probably don't need to put the LGBTQIA+ flahs in your flag (not trying to be cancelled in NS of all websites but) 7/10 with it and 8/10 without it, (at least it actually looks like a flag and not a corporation, no offense.)

The white part is merging with the website and it makes the flag look off. Not sure what you could do to fix that. Other than that its a perfectly fine flag nothing wrong with it 8/10.

[Vinichi]

I know it's pride month and all, but you probably don't need to put the LGBTQIA+ flahs in your flag (not trying to be cancelled in NS of all websites but) 7/10 with it and 8/10 without it, (at least it actually looks like a flag and not a corporation, no offense.)

The white part is merging with the website and it makes the flag look off. Not sure what you could do to fix that. Other than that its a perfectly fine flag nothing wrong with it 8/10.

4/10. Your characters are covering up what looks to be a really cool flag. Id like to see it without the characters.

For the BN

Id like to give some context behind the symbolism of my flag. Ive gotten critiques that the flag is either busy, or has too many symbols so here's what each one means. i don't expect this to change my ratings, but I think it would be cool to share.

First, the star. That is called in this countries universe, "The Valerian Star" its represents the star that the first king of this world followed back to his kingdom to liberate it, and the symbol he used for the kingdom and his family.

Second the cross. The first king was Christian as are most people on this planet, however faith was very important to the first king, and that devotion to faith spread within the culture.

3rd, the rows of stars above and below. These represent all of the past kings and queens who have ruled up until the current monarch, Queen Jade Valerian. Due to the current number, and flag space, their will be no more stars added for any future monarchs.

4th. The colors. Theyre just taken over from the Valerian Coat of arms and mean this. Green: Fertility and Prosperity. Yellow/Gold: Justice, White: Purity and innocence

And that's it! Tbh, as far as the original flag design I though it was just cool.

[Ereckia]

The cross on the hoist side is too cluttered It would be better if the central symbol was emphasised more and moved to the centre

[Vinichi]

The cross on the hoist side is too cluttered It would be better if the central symbol was emphasised more and moved to the centre

I appreciate the constructive criticism, however I would also like a 1-10 rating


/stillMe

[Ohio Men]

Remove the white and it will look better. 8/10

[Ereckia]

The cross on the hoist side is too cluttered It would be better if the central symbol was emphasised more and moved to the centre

I appreciate the constructive criticism, however I would also like a 1-10 rating


/stillMe

Ahh I forgot so sorry! I’d give it a 6/10

[Scytharum]

Not quite sure it counts as a flag, but it isn’t irredeemable. If you could make a simplified, wordless depiction of the meme, it could be a very funny, simple, and recognizable flag. For example, perhaps have the Ohio planet slightly to the left of center, shining beams off of it like the Imperial Flag but only to the right. Something like that could very well work. As of now, 5/10 for the effort.

For Ereckia: 9/10 flag, the color combination works really well together, it really only isn’t a ten for being a simple tricolor. Still an excellent flag, perhaps make it non-rectangular or add something to make it stand out more and it could potentially be a solid 10/10.

[Vinichi]

I appreciate the constructive criticism, however I would also like a 1-10 rating


/stillMe

Ahh I forgot so sorry! I’d give it a 6/10

No worries! Thank you friend

/skipMe

[New England and Greater New Brunswick]

Not quite sure it counts as a flag, but it isn’t irredeemable. If you could make a simplified, wordless depiction of the meme, it could be a very funny, simple, and recognizable flag. For example, perhaps have the Ohio planet slightly to the left of center, shining beams off of it like the Imperial Flag but only to the right. Something like that could very well work. As of now, 5/10 for the effort.

For Ereckia: 9/10 flag, the color combination works really well together, it really only isn’t a ten for being a simple tricolor. Still an excellent flag, perhaps make it non-rectangular or add something to make it stand out more and it could potentially be a solid 10/10.

Pretty good. I fail to see why the space between the gold bars is white and not black. I like the star design, though I would make it bigger or do something to fill in the unused space around it. I also feel the white chevron between the gold and black and gold bit is thicker near the center, though that could be an optical illusion. Solid flag. 7/10.

For BN: You could judge my pride flag, or my normal flag which you can see in my symbols factbook.

[Rasuq]

Pretty cool; I like the colors

[Allachia]

8.5/10, always minus points for being too complicated, but it's cool and recognisable from a glance

[Taosun]

I like the unique shape, the colors are a bit much from a distance though-9/10

[New England and Greater New Brunswick]

The colors are too vibrant for communism, or really for any flag. The hammer and sickle are a tad too big, and I'd have the stars be bigger or further apart. Otherwise, good flag. 8/10. Minus a point for ripple, so 7/10.

[The United Eridani Military Authority]

Taosun: Took the Chinese flag, removed the party star and replaced it with a hammer and sickle, and then removed one of the stars that corresponded to one of the 4 Chinese social classes (probably the national bourgeoisie one). I don't hate it, but there are a million cooler ideas out there for a a Maoist inspired banner that don't look quite so basic or uninspired. That said, the symbolism does work and it isn't overly boring or complicated.

5/10, merely acceptable.

Ninja'd

AN: Fairly basic flag that does a good job in displaying its heraldry alongside the more classical green background colouration that I'm assuming represents the forested and naturally connected background of the regions. The heraldry is decently well done and shows off the ruling family's origins, religion, and state while not being overly designed and overstaying its welcome. Could perhaps be slightly more defined through a thicker shield border but otherwise a commendable effort.

7/10

BN: Do either the account flag or any of these: https://www.nationstates.net/page=dispatch/id=1896478

[Taosun]

I like the unique shape, the colors are a bit much from a distance though-9/10

Oh, this is a dash, not a negative btw /skipme

[Washington-Columbia]

UEMA's Flag - Probably a really solid design if I've seen one. The color choice matches very well with the black and white looking great with one and another. The symbolism and design is done well here, with a simple design with the star matching the stellar nature of the UEMA with a wreath surrounding the star, also symbolizing the troops and the military. One of the best flags I've seen.

9.5/10.

To save BN some time...