Constructively rate the above nation's flag (8)

[The Verking Federation]

7/10, the flag is OK, but the rainbow throws it off, i’m not Homophobic or Anything, but im tired of seeing rainbows EVERYWHERE!

[Valles Marineris Mining co]

7/10, interesting color scheme. I like the design with the circle however I don’t like how dark the red is, it almost looks brownish.

[Rhanukhan]

I love this - a very appropriate sci-fi type of design for such an organisation. I assume that the circles represent Mars and its two moons? The outer elements suggest Olympus Mons. red is the obvious colour choice. 10/10

[Gaybeans]

I've gushed before about the beauty of your flag, the colour scheme, everything. It's 10/10.

[Valles Marineris Mining co]

I love this - a very appropriate sci-fi type of design for such an organisation. I assume that the circles represent Mars and its two moons? The outer elements suggest Olympus Mons. red is the obvious colour choice. 10/10

/skip me


Yeah the circle is mars and the smaller circles are the two moons. The outer elements have 2 meanings, that being Olympus Mons and since there are 4 of them it represents how mars is the 4th planet.

[Achaxis]

I've gushed before about the beauty of your flag, the colour scheme, everything. It's 10/10.

It is certainly an eclectic flag with the rainbow color pattern on the side giving way to the dueling fields of green and read. The iconography of the flag makes it a little busy, but the uniqueness of using your symbols where you did kind of counteracts that to me. I'll give this flag a solid 8/10 for originality!

[Augustomare]

7/10
I enjoy the Galactic Empire reference, clean design and unusual contrast of red and grey. But all in all the colours are a bit too samey, I think it would be hard to make out from a distance what's what - and that's ultimately the point of flags.

[New England and Greater New Brunswick]

6/10. Clashing colors. The outline of the lion blends in, and the colors are mid. That said, not awful. Blends in to other flags.

(BN - You can judge the pride flag, or go to my overview and judge my regular one, or both.)

[Union of Albandrite Socialist Republics]

Eh. Simple but gets to the point (I love the seal). My gripe is the shield emblem blends too much with the background of the flag, which kind of makes it blend in
too much.

4/10

[The Steam-Gardens]

8/10

The flag overall is really solid. I am a bit curious about the little stripes in the hammer-and-sickle configuration--they feel out-of-place--but I have no other issues with it.

[Inner Albania]

9/10 A bit too complicated, I'd say. Otherwise, good flag.

[Boneville]

9/10 but a computer keyboard really?

[Regnum Aeternum Humani Technocratiae]

5/10, not a flag but the poster is really cool.

[Aaaaaa]

5/10, not a flag but the poster is really cool.

It's bold, I'll give it that. The MS Paint quality of it all is almost admirable just out of the sheer audacity of it. I don't think you are expecting a genuine analysis of this, but I'll say this could work if you made the purple a little less vibrant and fire the 6-year-old you hired to draw the eagle in the middle. 1/10.

9/10 but a computer keyboard really?

What's the point of posting on this thread if you just have an image as your flag? You know you're just going to get the typical "not a flag/10" response (and justifiably so) so why bother?

[Random Country 453632]

Pretty good! The shape is unique yet simple enough to not clash with the tricolour. However, said tricolour is too similar to Austria, so any damage to the flag would make it look like a tarnished Austrian flag. However, this flag is in a web game and most likely won't be put on a flagpole, so 9/10

BN, sorry for the high contrast colors :3

[Great United States]

5/10 Textbook definition of eyesore

[Union of Albandrite Socialist Republics]

4/10

The colors are nice, but the design is a total mess. Way too much going on and the designs are complex and weird. I'd try simplifying the design and removing those stars.

[The Steam-Gardens]

AN: Alr did them earlier.

AAN: 2/10

The flag is very messy in general. The thin-white-outline pentagon feels weird and out of place, the leaves are not appealing, and there's text on the flag. The only good part is the background itself, but it is extremely overshadowed by the rest of the clutter. To summarize, it feels like someone poorly scribbled random stuff over a decent enough base for a flag. Unless intentional, I recommend you scrap this flag entirely and make a new, cleaner one.

[Rhanukhan]

AN: Alr did them earlier.

I'd think it more polite to simply go away and return to the thread later in such a situation, but I'll do you the service of a review also.

Union of Albandrite Socialist Republics - a novel spin on the classic communist red flag. I like the main device's combination of elements and the overall layout and colours - 8/10

The Steam-Gardens - not such a striking design, but it works for the kind of nation described in your factbooks - 7/10

[The Draconic Islands]

10/10, The animals is unique, the colors fit, everything is aligned correctly. so it's really good!

[New England and Greater New Brunswick]

Pretty good. IMO, a bit crowded and a bit too many detail lines, but overall nice colors and nice designs. 7/10.

[Eeumeria]

Pretty good. IMO, a bit crowded and a bit too many detail lines, but overall nice colors and nice designs. 7/10.

4/10

Im not a fan of that green, and I think the symbolism could be a little better.

[Urine Town]

Great color scheme, great symmetry. Just a bit too much going on IMO. 9/10

[Merith]

Great color scheme, great symmetry. Just a bit too much going on IMO. 9/10

7/10. This seems like a corporate banner more than a flag, but as that it looks great! Perhaps there could be an alt version that's more like a flag?

[Boneville]

8/10 looks really good but the shape is complicated