NationStates

6/10 8/10
the symbols are great, but the blue looks a tad bit too bright, and the brighter colors aren't seperated by darker colors (outlines)

Aguila de Oro wrote:6/10 8/10
the symbols are great, but the blue looks a tad bit too bright, and the brighter colors aren't seperated by darker colors (outlines)

Not exactly a flag so...

N/A out of 10

6/10

The flag is good in general. However, I would prefer the stripes to have an even length or even have the white be the biggest. I'd also make the Coat of Arms on it look more professional, as the simple yellow outline sticks out in contrast to the complex eagle within--maybe change the little eagle thing to your nation's COA on your factbooks. It doesn't break any major rules, though.

The Steam-Gardens wrote:6/10

The flag is good in general. However, I would prefer the stripes to have an even length or even have the white be the biggest. I'd also make the Coat of Arms on it look more professional, as the simple yellow outline sticks out in contrast to the complex eagle within--maybe change the little eagle thing to your nation's COA on your factbooks. It doesn't break any major rules, though.

9/10. Im not a fan of the shades of green and orange but it looks cool!

It works but I'm not a fan of the symbolism and colours, 5/10

-2/10
The colours clash and the symbol should be put in a less awkward position.

4/10, its not exactly a flag. If you want to make a flag out of it i would suggest to remove a lot of the details and stylize it.

I personally prefer the red version of the factbook, but I like this one as well, 8/10, well designed simple yet memorable.

3/10 Not a big fan of yellow and black.

0/10 as it is not a flag, but seems to be a keyboard from the 80s.

5/10, not great nor remarkable, not bad either, very neutral

The color scheme is decent, but the shield is throwing me off. Also looks like an AnCap state.

6.3/10

9/10. It's very pleasant. The colors complement one another, the coat of arms is well-designed, and the line gives it additional character. I will say though it initially gave me the impression of the flag of a ski resort or some smaller thing than a country. Good job though. Altogether solid I feel

7.5/10 black & white usually doesn’t look good on flags and I thought it was a bit cluttered but that’s just the size difference between the forum and the factbooks. Creative color scheme and symbols

7.5/10. It's a tad busy and loud, yet the contrast of colours does work. The flag would also be very recognizable from a distance. Overal it's good and stands out.

The blue needs a bit of a touch up though as the lines are a bit jagged, but I get the idea so won't judge on that.

Simple, yet memorable and good looking, 8.5/10

the yellow is a bit too bright, maybe think about dulling it down. Otherwise, I'd say it's a good flag! 7.5/10

It's certainly appropriate to the nation's name and I do quite like the worn cloth effect. The only petty fault I could come up with is the fact that, unsurprisingly, there's a lot of Stars & Stripes-based flags on the forum and you risk being lost among them. 9/10

10/10 good flag.

1/10. Horrible shapes. The columns are too detailed and it would be better if they were simplified into a straight, undetailed, grey pillar. The eagle is uneven. The colors clash and the cloth on the pillar is ugly.

(BN - You can judge the pride flag, or go to my overview and judge my regular one, or both.)

I won’t say anything about the stripe at the bottom for pride month.
It seems like a good 6/10, but I will say quite a bit about it.
Firstly, If you’re going to have a coat of arms with similar colors as your flag has, at least make sure they don’t blend in with the background. Secondly, can you add something else to help distinguish your flag from others? Mostly a plain green flag with a bit on the edges isn’t that unique. Maybe port the design you have for your CoA as your flag? It looks like an interesting design, and I would love to see it being used ti the fullest that it can be used.
Other than that, you seem to be good.

FOR BN:
Rate THIS FLAG-

0/10 THAT PRIDE FLAG IS HORRIBLE! ok where I begin? the eagle in the pride flag doesn't work, colors too bright, stars doesn't fit AND THE FLAG IS LIKE THE ONE OF NEPAL!
101 motives of why I don't like pride flags:
Update: Ok much better, looks like your average american flag, pretty casual.
5/10 for bad creativity, I like the ancient one of Neoliberalism.

Redeeemed Black League wrote:0/10 THAT PRIDE FLAG IS HORRIBLE! ok where I begin? the eagle in the pride flag doesn't work, colors too bright, stars doesn't fit AND THE FLAG IS LIKE THE ONE OF NEPAL!
101 motives of why I don't like pride flags:

Oh, whoops.
I forgot to tell people not to rate my pride flag, and instead rate a different one. Give me a sec. Also, do you mind changing your rating of it when U pull out the actual flag?
/Skipme

Who else just doesn't like animals on flags? (A bit hypocritical, as I've has them on alts before, but it was a dragon. So it was cool)

Overall though, it's cool.

7.5/10

Good contrast, excellent symbols, solid color and shape schemes. Maybe a tad uninspired, and I like original symbols, but who am I to speak? 8.7/10.

(BN - You can judge the pride flag, or go to my overview and judge my regular one, or both.)