Constructively rate the above nation's flag (8)

[Great Jenovah]

2/10: the blue is overpowering while the brighter yellow/orange doesn’t mingle well whatsoever. It appears like a pretty decent start, but change the colors and get rid of the ripples.

[Rivogna]

First, I like the unconventional use of orange, black, and white! However, the white chevron to the right feels somewhat out of place. Perhaps you should create a white border from that chevron or remove it altogether. You should also simplify the bear to a slight extent; you could use orange outlines within it if you prefer keeping detail. Right now, I rate your flag a 7/10!

[Spratly Islands]

7.5/10

It’s a nice design, the olive branches kind of remind me of the SPQR flag. I also like the shades of red and yellow. I think it would look better if it didn’t have stars, or maybe move the stars.

[Islamic Holy Sites]

6.5/10

I like the circle thing around the compass
The red blends in with the blue and maybe you can remove the black borders?

[Vrazdovia]

I Love the colour scheme, its not a colour combination traditional to irl islamic nations...but I actually like the difference!

It does break the "Rule" of "No Text on a Flag" but a lot of islamic flags do break this rule. Guessing as a non native speaker it adds to the "Décor" and Symbolism of the flag. So I like it as well.

I am however not a Fan of the Black Arabic writing, it feels very out of place on the flag for me opposed to the golden Arabic writing which looks natural, So I would remove the Black Writing.

The Crescent Moon and its symbols are nice, but do feel too big and the Crescent does encroach on the writing a little bit. it also causes the writing to have a wider gap between the left writing and the middle writing, making it not symmetrical. So I would Shrink the Moon and its symbols slightly and readjust the left writing to have more even spacing with the middle writing.

It is also very distinct and could imagine a very Unique and Large Desert Islamic Empire or Kingdom when I see this Flag.

8/10

[Twenty Community]

The flag it self are hard to look at because how dark the red is and it mix with black so basicly in the night you can't see the flag . The gray also feel weird because when you look you think it black but it gray but hey it a solid 8/10. Cool flag my dude.

[Islamic Holy Sites]

9/10, the plain yellow is nice and the shape is great but perhaps you could make the coat of arms a bit less complictaed.

[Delatia]

9/10, the plain yellow is nice and the shape is great but perhaps you could make the coat of arms a bit less complictaed.

8/10
It's good, but why are some words stretched to the right.
Other than that, good for me I guess.

[Regmotto]

9/10, the plain yellow is nice and the shape is great but perhaps you could make the coat of arms a bit less complictaed.

8/10
It's good, but why are some words stretched to the right.
Other than that, good for me I guess.

4/10,I find the flag to be convoluted and with too many elements to it.

[Diarcesia]

8/10
It's good, but why are some words stretched to the right.
Other than that, good for me I guess.

4/10,I find the flag to be convoluted and with too many elements to it.

From an aesthetic perspective, 7/10 because the emblem off-center looks weird and the color clashes.

But it is a realistic flag, so 8/10

[Great Jenovah]

I am having a little trouble finding a flag without the anime girl but filling in the gaps, I will give the flag an 8.5/10. I think it's memorable, simple, and the colors work well with each other. I would get rid of the ripples.

[Washington-Columbia]

While the bear and the spear is overdetailed, It still looks cool and is memorable, and the orange and the white fit very nicely. 9/10.

[Casodium]

I love it overall although I think there could be a white border around what I presume to be a stylised tree to contrast it better with the green and purple or even a golden border around it. Overall a solid 7/10

[Islamic Holy Sites]

9/10 It is awesome but maybe make the globe simpler

Also I think it would be cool if instead of one yellow stripe on the globe, there was a white stripe sandwiched by two yellow stripes (like in the rest of the flag) but that’s just my opinion

[The Aquaria]

4/10.

Tbh; your flag before leaving is much better. It is... quite messy now.

[The Vita Federal Authority]

9/10, perfectly easy to remember and yet highly distinguishable among other flags (except maybe Denmark or Norway)

[The Republic of Western Sol]

5/10, it is a good flag, just not a good national one, it looks more like a government office logo, with the free colours on the right representing the true flag

[Cerespasia]

8.6/10

Although the overall design of the flag itself looks rather intricate, it still does its job of being distinctive from any other flag fairly perfectly, astoundlingly, dare I say it. Orange as the base color of a flag is a bit of an oddball color choice, but when paired with the other colors in the flag, it makes up for in blending in with them seamlessly. the blue and black stripes when also paired with the white slivers also add to the flag's distinctiveness, although the blue stripe could use a more vibrant shade rather than a grayish tint. The device on the upper hoist region of the flag, although seemingly inctricate in design with most of it having a black outline (excluding the sunrays which don't have those) is really what hammers home the fact that this flag is different from any other flags out there. Overall, a bit complicated (design wise, at least), but clealy distinctive from others.

[Dantek]

8/10

Overall design is nice, but the shading around the flag makes it less like a flag and more like a painting.

[Sabutaka]

simplistic, minimalistic and pleasing to look at
blue and white is a good color combination and the way their shown makes them look very nice
9/10

[The New Underground]

simplistic, minimalistic and pleasing to look at
blue and white is a good color combination and the way their shown makes them look very nice
9/10

10/10 This flag is awesome. I think it would be better without the ripple however

[Nyetoa]

When I see this flag, I see two incredible 10/10 designs mashed together. You have a unique tri colour, and an incredible Nordic Saltire, but combining the two together, 8/10. If you just chose one, this would be a solid 10/10.

[North Bulgaristan]

Uses a basic flag making website, not bad, though. Too simple. 4/10

[Anarcho-Merith]

Uses a basic flag making website, not bad, though. Too simple. 4/10

7/10. Its very cool looking, but the coat of arms is a little complicated

[Hidenan]

10/10
Good colours, fantastic design, simple enough to be memorable, complicated enough to be interesting.