Constructively rate the above nation's flag (8)

[Reloviskistan]

8/10
Pretty interesting flag, looks like a medieval banner.
Would be better if the tips were pointy instead of flat.

[Allpharia]

8/10
Pretty interesting flag, looks like a medieval banner.
Would be better if the tips were pointy instead of flat.

New flag.

8/10. I think it would be better without the ripple effect. Otherwise great work!

[Lackadaisia]

5/10

Circle of stars is sitting low, overlapping the black border.

[Scytharum]

8/10. The color scheme works really well, the only real criticism I can think of is that the stars are a bit overbearing and all over the place, I would advise making them somewhat smaller and concentrating them in one area. Otherwise, still a pretty good flag.

[Great Jenovah]

7/10: I think the yellow is far too overpowering for the white. It's a very strong color palette which really needs better use of contrast. It could work together very well if AN is able to reorganize and adjust the colors in a way where they compliment each other instead of fight with one another.

[Islamic Holy Sites]

8/10:

It’s great, but if you make the tips pointy it would be even better

[Reactorland]

8/10:

It’s great, but if you make the tips pointy it would be even better

Another Islamic flag, I'll give it 6/10 because it has too many writings for a flag. I think one writing is enough for an Islamic flag.

[Dantek]

8/10
It's simple with a good colour combination.

[Neonian Technocracy]

7/10, maybe make the shark a little bigger (because at first time seing it I thought it was a gun xD).

[Barcus Nation]

2/10. feels messy and over crowded, also the little square shouldn't have any text on it.

(Use IC flag)

[Estasia]

3/10, it's a little bit too complicated and could do with some simplification

[Great Jenovah]

9/10: It looks pretty plain, memoizable colors. It's sweet and simple.

[Aclya]

9/10: It looks pretty plain, memoizable colors. It's sweet and simple.

4/10

Im not a fan of the colors and the bear is a little complicated.

[Islamic Holy Sites]

8/10

It’s good, and the little stars are cool, but the star kinda reminds me of the NATO symbol. Maybe it’s just me

[Safiloa]

6/10, its a beautiful mess

[Allpharia]

6/10, its a beautiful mess

9/10! The stripes are a little complicated but it looks really good!

[Islamic Holy Sites]

6/10, its a beautiful mess

Thanks!
/skip

[The Aquaria]

6/10, its a beautiful mess

9/10! The stripes are a little complicated but it looks really good!

Probably a 7/10.

This colour of blue can make a flag quite frustrating to see. Not a bad design but, probably need a change in colour.

[The Dodo Republic]

One of my fav flags on NS. simple, nice colors, nordic cross. What else would you want. 10/10

[X3nder Tech]

9/10, nice dodo.

[Islamic Holy Sites]

Not a flag, but 3/10 for the cat

[The Dodo Republic]

5/10

Bit much going on. Lots of writing and things seem out of place. Not the worst though

[The Aquaria]

One of my fav flags on NS. simple, nice colors, nordic cross. What else would you want. 10/10

Ah, thanks

/skip

[Minal]

Simple yet intriguing design.
7.5/10.

[Hidenan]

4/10
It just looks like Côte d’Ivoire’s flag with a coat of arms