Constructively rate the above nation's flag (8)

[The United Vex Imperium]

I generally like the flag. While it is a bit busy, it does work and gives off the exact "over the top, revolutionary, etc" vibes that these sort of communist flags usually like to have. My main gripe is the non-centered hammer-sickle-torch insignia, if it was centered I think it'd make the flag seem a little more collected. Another thing I would say that's knocking down a point or two is the double usage of the hammer and sickle. Reusing the same "complex" asset or iconography like that just makes the flag a bit too cluttered and unimaginative. Maybe replacing the bottom one with something else or just getting rid of it entirely would improve the design.

7/10

[Western Theram]

8/10 nothing looks out of place or contrasts weirdly with the maroon/red. Image is centered and not too cluttered. Design if the flag is nice. Good work!

[Merulla]

I would just reduce the size, the height, of the diamond. Consider leaving it within the height of the red stripes without letting the blue diamond bleed into the yellow background.
Another thing is the animal inside the blue diamond, it can also suffer a reduction in its size, just a little bit, of course. 7/10


BN, you can skip me if you want, I'm just here to help other nations.

[Islamic Holy Sites]

10/10

Great flag all round, good colours, awesome trident

[Gran Cordoba]

1/10

Massive mess. The colors also don't contrast too well with eachother, and any words of any script on any flag looks bad.

[New Stonen]

Switch the symbol in the middle for a star. 7/10 without edits, 7.5/10 with edits

[Mohorg Gathanauffand]

9/10

I like the color choice and the design of the flag. Amazing!

[Nandez]

Switch the symbol in the middle for a star. 7/10 without edits, 7.5/10 with edits

ninja'd


10/10 This is a pretty awesome flag

[Hidenan]

8/10

Good colours, nice layout, but maybe make the stripe go from top left to bottom right or make it a cross, because how it is now seriously bugs me. And maybe a different colour outline for the symbol in the middle. But overall, great flag! (Love the hexagon)

[Ivartixi]

4/10, could be better.
Simplify it removing the stripes top and bottom
Plus. Maybe simplify the flower a tad bit more.

[The Itzgari]

0/10, the way how its hand drawn is rather ugly to me personally. (No offense to your drawing skills!)

[Hidenan]

4/10

Looks nice, but it looks more like something out of Star Wars than a real flag. No offence, just my personal opinion

[The AC]

Apologies. Maybe it's just me, but... The color scheme is kind of an eyesore. Maybe they're the national colors and maybe I'm overreacting a bit. But they seem a bit over-saturated, Especially with the combo you have going on. Maybe desaturate them a bit, or even swap some of the colors out.

5.9/10

[Socialistic Britain]

It's amazing, perfect even
But that centre needs to be less complicated
I'm gonna have to give it a 8/10
If the centre was perhaps more simple and less cluttered, it would be a 10/10

[-Britain-]

Not bad, though it's puzzling why a British flag is dominated by the Welsh Dragon. 7/10.

[Soviet Haaregrad]

It's a great coat of arms but it's not a flag. No score awarded... because there's no flag to rate.

[Dardalonia]

+ Clear design, the connection to Slavic influences is clear.
+ Unique layout, makes it stand out from other flags.

- Choice of colours, the red clashes a bit with the light blue.
- Ripple effect, it detracts from the flag's design.

Overall rating: 6.5/10 (would be higher without ripple effect)

[Merulla]

My only complaint is the super detailed coat of arms which would make it difficult for a child to draw just from memory... However, we know this rule is largely ignored, so...

10/10

Congratulations, impeccable flag.

[New Stonen]

I like everything about the flag is fine with me except for the trident... maybe make it more angular or something? Minor complaint; otherwise, 9/10. Great flag!

[Atlantic Isles]

Great color choice. I'm a fan of the layout too, it's a bit unusual but it works. 10/10

[Socialist Ancomistan]

8.5/10. I love your color combination as well as the tridents on the upper left. One suggestion (if you made this flag and didn’t just find it online), is to add a third blue stripe to the bottom to get three stripes of red, yellow, and blue

[Frisemark]

Eh. 5/10? It's extremely generic and I've never been a fan of maps on flags. It does its job, I guess, but not in a way that's memorable or significant.

[Islamic Holy Sites]

6/10

Nice flag, but it isn’t long enough and with me at least you have to zoom on to see St George and the dragon. Maybe that’s just me though

[Allpharia]

6/10

Nice flag, but it isn’t long enough and with me at least you have to zoom on to see St George and the dragon. Maybe that’s just me though

2/10


Too many colors, too many symbols, and wording. Wording is a no go on a flag.

[Great Jenovah]

4/10: The black stripe blends in with the red and blue, both of which are too deep for my liking. The stars are too close together.