Constructively rate the above nation's flag (8)

[Jilia]

I really like the symbol in the middle, but think the rest of the flag looks like the North Korean Flag, 6/10, add some more Stars and Stripes If you want, Id suggest that you should just change the color patterns of the flag instead.

[Neonian Technocracy]

10/10, I like it! also, it looks like brazil + etiopia + something england.

[Aurevbush]

4/10, I would like the flag better if the cross was inverted with the long part put on the right, and maybe try a better shade of green to mix with red.

[Islamic Holy Sites]

9/10, really a great flag, maybe just add a seal or something in the middle

[Aclya]

9/10, really a great flag, maybe just add a seal or something in the middle

5/10

Im not a fan of that shade of red. Although I understand that its typical for Islamic flags to have wording, I still don't think its a good design. And this is an example of why the ripple effect doesn't work for every flag.

Other than that, its simple, and the symbolism is good

[The AC]

9/10, really a great flag, maybe just add a seal or something in the middle

5/10

Im not a fan of that shade of red. Although I understand that its typical for Islamic flags to have wording, I still don't think its a good design. And this is an example of why the ripple effect doesn't work for every flag.

Other than that, its simple, and the symbolism is good

Not bad. Not bad at all. Although I thought one of the points of flags and coats was the visibility of certain iconography. And I can barely see the size of the stars which make up the outer rim of the seal. Maybe make them larger, or make the seal larger to make said stars larger without trimming down their number (which I feel like they all symbolize something -- probably a number of provinces, states, kingdoms, etc).

But either way, nice. Love the colors as well. Really hits me specifically. 8.5/10.

[Nandez]

5/10

Im not a fan of that shade of red. Although I understand that its typical for Islamic flags to have wording, I still don't think its a good design. And this is an example of why the ripple effect doesn't work for every flag.

Other than that, its simple, and the symbolism is good

Not bad. Not bad at all. Although I thought one of the points of flags and coats was the visibility of certain iconography. And I can barely see the size of the stars which make up the outer rim of the seal. Maybe make them larger, or make the seal larger to make said stars larger without trimming down their number (which I feel like they all symbolize something -- probably a number of provinces, states, kingdoms, etc).

But either way, nice. Love the colors as well. Really hits me specifically. 8.5/10.

9/10

The eyes are a bit mich for me but this is an absolutely beautiful flag! Well done

[Lesbias]

4/10, the colours are nice and can work together but the design they're in sorta fumbles it a bit, the yellow stripe feels off. The symbol on the centre is a bit complicated for me but it would work! It's got a lot of potential and it's not a bad flag but there's a lot of room for improvement! <3

[Western Theram]

4/10 fairly generic for a socialist country to have the hammer and sickle, it also doesn’t contrast well with the other colors of the flag other than red. I’d recommend a different symbol & color

[The Steam-Gardens]

6/10

Feels like a worse take on the Catalan flag. The colors are paler, which I believe should be regular, and the "antler kangaroo" doesn't fit well in the current flag; some of it is cut off to my dislike. However, I still like the Catalan flag's foundation--which mostly carries the flag for me.

[Safiloa]

I like it. It's cute, unique, simple, and easy to remember. The gears however can only be seen when nearby, and when seen brings more questions than answers.
8.75/10

[Vesilen Island]

9/10

I appreciate the Austronesian design motif within the flag itself. I always love it when flags do those. It's not higher just because it's a little complicated to draw, but that's just it.

[Safiloa]

9/10

I appreciate the Austronesian design motif within the flag itself. I always love it when flags do those. It's not higher just because it's a little complicated to draw, but that's just it.

/SKIP ME
Fun fact: That motif is both Persian and Austronesian, which is why it is so perfect for my Pre-Islamic Perso-Austronesian nation/conlang/religion.

[Lievue]

9/10

I appreciate the Austronesian design motif within the flag itself. I always love it when flags do those. It's not higher just because it's a little complicated to draw, but that's just it.

The only thing I could suggest is to make the emblem a little smaller, but... there's nothing else really to say. Good colours, unique tricolour asymmetry. Just a very solid flag. 9/10.

[Ankuran]

3/10 - Name and two mottos, seal, all those lines at the bottom, really complex central picture... As much as I hate to recommend Good Flag, Bad Flag because I don't respect the legitimacy of anyone who likes Maryland's flag, I feel like maybe a readthrough of that will help get the basics. Beyond that, I'd say keep the green and white, and focus on the chapel as an emblem (though simplify it). An emblem consisting of a gold circle with the chapel in the middle might be a good jumping off point.

[The Republic of Western Sol]

Oh Ankuran, probably in the top 3 for my favourite flags on NS! I love the colours and how they compliment each other, I love the symbolism of the flags crest, I simply love every little detail! The only thing I’d honestly complain about is the shade of red, it could be just a tad brighter, 9.7/10

[The Dodo Republic]

6/10. Not a bad flag but nothing new nothing that stands out. Its fine though

[Suuri]

Oh Ankuran, probably in the top 3 for my favourite flags on NS! I love the colours and how they compliment each other, I love the symbolism of the flags crest, I simply love every little detail! The only thing I’d honestly complain about is the shade of red, it could be just a tad brighter, 9.7/10

9/10 Good flag, the colors are bright and saturated, I like it

[Ankuran]

Oh Ankuran, probably in the top 3 for my favourite flags on NS! I love the colours and how they compliment each other, I love the symbolism of the flags crest, I simply love every little detail! The only thing I’d honestly complain about is the shade of red, it could be just a tad brighter, 9.7/10

If you've got a specific shade in mind, I'm open to suggestions. I decided the old red was too brown so I've been unsuccessfully playing around with different shades of red.

/skip

[Western Theram]

7/10 the only thing I can say is it’s hard to criticize a blank flag but sometimes the most simple ones suit the nation best

[Sarolandia]

6/10

The design isn't a bad idea, but the ripple effect... please no. The Rhombus is also not symmetrical and the color does not work on the yellow and red at all.

[Davidtopia]

Nice, Simple but it says a lot about the nation sporting it.


8/10

[Islamic Holy Sites]

Nice triangle and star, but the red and orange look too similar
7/10

[Suuri]

Nice triangle and star, but the red and orange look too similar
7/10

5/10

The black inscription on top of the lines looks strange, the flag has too many details, the inscription on the yellow circle is not really visible, there is no concept, everything is somehow chaotic

[Jilia]

3/10,

I feel like it's a little bland, I mean, putting the borders of your nation is a little creative, but that's just it,

I feel like you should add more stuff, for example, a tricolor flag with an emblem in the middle where it contains a shape of the Country's borders.

It would stand out, but I feel it needs more details.