Constructively rate the above nation's flag (8)

[Taungne]

8/10.

It looks pretty corporate, and something about the colors could be improved.

[The 8th Dystopia]

eh, 6/10 i would put the symbol a bit closer to the blue and rid of its unnecessary border between the Blue and dark blue of the sybmol

[Uminaku]

6/10. The colors and basic design is very recognizable and looks good, but it is far too complex. Try using one single bar at the bottom of removing it entirely, and using a 2D triangle instead. Also, make the symbol centered, and if you want, extend that bar to the bottom. While the colors are dark, they fit the nation, so no problems there. Overall a nice flag, but has it could be very easily improved.

Anyways, here are the fixed flags if you want:
https://i.imgur.com/3Q2adsz_d.webp?maxw ... lity=grand (without bar)
https://i.imgur.com/qZw51Yq_d.webp?maxw ... lity=grand (with bar)

[Reactorland]

6/10. The colors and basic design is very recognizable and looks good, but it is far too complex. Try using one single bar at the bottom of removing it entirely, and using a 2D triangle instead. Also, make the symbol centered, and if you want, extend that bar to the bottom. While the colors are dark, they fit the nation, so no problems there. Overall a nice flag, but has it could be very easily improved.

Anyways, here are the fixed flags if you want:
https://i.imgur.com/3Q2adsz_d.webp?maxw ... lity=grand (without bar)
https://i.imgur.com/qZw51Yq_d.webp?maxw ... lity=grand (with bar)

7/10, better if you make the flower symbol larger or remove it but still, it's a good flag.

[Merulla]

It's a nice flag if we consider its layout and colors, the only thing that bothers me is its shape.
Unless your nation is in the Middle Ages, it doesn't make sense for it to have this shape yet. Consider making it rectangular like most flags if your nation is a modern one. I would perhaps advise adding a symbol that defines your nation somewhere, probably the center of the flag.

But in general, it only loses a few points for its format. 7/10



BN: If your comment is to nag about how my flag reminded you of Barbados, save our time and energy and just skip me.

[Inner Albania]

9/10 The Barbados style flag is actually really well-done.

[Vinichi]

9/10 The Barbados style flag is actually really well-done.

6/10 The colors along with the circle surrounding the symbol clashes very hard. The concept is good but that really brings it down for me

[Anarchic States]

9/10 The Barbados style flag is actually really well-done.

6/10 The colors along with the circle surrounding the symbol clashes very hard. The concept is good but that really brings it down for me

eh, 7/10.

i don't like the green

[Apple America]

6/10 The colors along with the circle surrounding the symbol clashes very hard. The concept is good but that really brings it down for me

eh, 7/10.

i don't like the green

5/10 the stripes going fully across the flag doesn't look that great to me

[Anarchic States]

eh, 7/10.

i don't like the green

5/10 the stripes going fully across the flag doesn't look that great to me

says apple 0/10

skip me

[Neonian Technocracy]

3/10, I would like some more color but the symbology is very good!

[Sibirovsky]

2/10
It’s just SOOOOOO cluttered! Clean it up a lot, and it would be much, much better!

[Safiloa]

3/10
It looks like it was photoshopped or an image stolen online and then added at the last minute to a black background. I don't mean to be mean.

A fine flag. Lovely colours in a pleasing arrangement. I'm intrigued to know what the icon in the corner represents? 9/10

It's the supposed symbol of the Mazdakite Zoroastrian movement, a pacifist, vegetarian, free-loving, theodemocratic and, "communist" movement from the early 6th century Sassanian Persia empire. Some believe it might have even inspired Marx and Engels, as well as led to the Khurramites, the Qarmatians, and even the early Qizilbash/Safavid form of Shia Islam.
https://www.wikiwand.com/en/Mazdak

[Anarchic States]

8/10

simple and easy to make, might be my ADHD kicking in but im not making it 10/10 because it's not semtircal

[Jilia]

9/10, it's just like the US flag, but better, but I think the Ying Yang symbol is too thin, it needs to be a little more wider to make it a perfect circle

[Anarchic States]

9/10, it's just like the US flag, but better, but I think the Ying Yang symbol is too thin, it needs to be a little more wider to make it a perfect circle

8.7/10

i don't like the center emblem but otherwise good

[Barks Nivvlla]

10/10 good design

[EER OT]

10/10 good design

9/10 works for a rogue state like Afghanistan would be a 10/10 if the symbol was smaller

[Barcus Nation]

8/10. i like it, but the texture in the background ain't too hot. So just change that and i'd call it a solid 10/10 or 9/10.

(Use IC flag BN)

[Ankuran]

9/10 - Much better than before. I'd suggest maybe try increasing the width of the central band. As is, the emblem feels a bit cramped.

[Lemsrow]

8/10.

Reminds me of the flag of Angola. And it is mighty fine.

[Settentrionalia]

7.5/10, it is simple and haves this papers please flag style, I like the vibe it gives, but the eagle feels a bit out of proportion

[Uminaku]

8/10. Looks nice and somewhat unique design of a tricolor and a rhombus. However the colors are very light and it is also quite complex (eg. the white lines, the emblem). The emblem is not centered, and I would prefer using something else rather than the white ribbons.

[Aaaaaa]

Conflicted about this one. It fits every flag convention we have; it objectively looks nice, but I can't shake the feeling that it has a corporate, design-by-committee vibe. 8/10.

[Rhanukhan]

That's certainly a novel, if not totally unique, shape that makes you immediately eyecatching and distinctive. Red and white is a good, bold combination - 9/10