Constructively rate the above nation's flag (8)

[Scytharum]

I'll say a solid 9/10, actually. Despite its simplistic design, it actually fits an Apple theme pretty well, and the use of gray is something not often seen in flags. The only real thing that could be improved is to distinguish the two shades of gray a little bit more, other than that it's a very good flag.

[Reactorland]

I'll say a solid 9/10, actually. Despite its simplistic design, it actually fits an Apple theme pretty well, and the use of gray is something not often seen in flags. The only real thing that could be improved is to distinguish the two shades of gray a little bit more, other than that it's a very good flag.

Epic design. Speechless.
9.5/10 I believe no flag is perfect.

[Ankuran]

6/10 - Simple and functional, just not very memorable. Bumped it up a point for the shape.

[Eeumeria]

6/10 - Simple and functional, just not very memorable. Bumped it up a point for the shape.

7/10

The flag looks very cool, but the symbols get a little complicated for me.

[New San Andreas Republic]

Pretty nice and original choice of colors, which are both unique and not-off putting. The saltire design, while certainly not original on its own, is well-chosen and the use of alternating colored stars makes sure the flag remains fairly distinct. My only gripe I guess, is the symbol in the middle, which isn't evident on what it is on a glance and would probably need explaining by the flag creator.

8/10.

[Kreushia]

I love it!

It looks like California's flag though.
6/10


Edit:

the placement of the stars seem kind of arbitrary, they would probably look best in the moon. also, most likely not intentional, but the flag looks too similar to a certain German flag for my tastes. overall, it gets a 6/10.

You make a great point, this flag is a joke.

[Eeumeria]

Pretty nice and original choice of colors, which are both unique and not-off putting. The saltire design, while certainly not original on its own, is well-chosen and the use of alternating colored stars makes sure the flag remains fairly distinct. My only gripe I guess, is the symbol in the middle, which isn't evident on what it is on a glance and would probably need explaining by the flag creator.

8/10.

Fair enough. A lot of my flags are heavily based on the lore for the game series I'm making which isn't out yet, so a lot of it would need to be explained.


/Skipme

[Cyber Duotona]

the placement of the stars seem kind of arbitrary, they would probably look best in the moon. also, most likely not intentional, but the flag looks too similar to a certain German flag for my tastes. overall, it gets a 6/10.

[Claff]

I love it!

It looks like California's flag though.
6/10

10/10

Cool looking flag with great colors and symbols, and its a simple enough flag for a child to draw!

[Democratic Poopland]

4/10. Good contrast, 6/10 so far, complex symbol, 4/10 so far, not in middle, infurates me, 3/10, not simple enough for a child to draw, 2/10, good colours, 4/10. Overall, 4/10! Good try, make it simpler next time.

[Eeumeria]

the placement of the stars seem kind of arbitrary, they would probably look best in the moon. also, most likely not intentional, but the flag looks too similar to a certain German flag for my tastes. overall, it gets a 6/10.

Ooofers! Two at the same time.

Well id rate your flag a 8/10

This is a bada** looking flag. The colors are great and the symbols work. Theyre just a little complicated for flag making.

/skipme again

[The Front Range]

4/10. Good contrast, 6/10 so far, complex symbol, 4/10 so far, not in middle, infurates me, 3/10, not simple enough for a child to draw, 2/10, good colours, 4/10. Overall, 4/10! Good try, make it simpler next time.

I know it’s the flag of a real world place, but I just can’t remember where. I don’t think the flag itself is that good anyway. Weird colors, questionable symbology and a generally ugly layout would probably get it at maximum a 5/10. However due to a lack of originality, 4/10

[Davetopolis]

I think your flag is a nice 4.5/10 I like the snake but I think it could use some more colors than just blue and white but it's a good color combo for a simple flag, Very Nice!

[Generic Communist Utopia 1948671]

Er... get an actual flag that isn't just a quirky and unfunny illustration of a cartoon character's head on an egregiously-designed background? What do you expect to get as an answer.

0/10.

[Coldian]

8/10 I like the symbol and colors. But I feel like it definitely needs more depth or more to it. But its still a solid flag!

[Barcus Nation]

9/10, i would remove the borders around the white part, otherwise than that, it is a good flag




use IC

[The Marakouan Islands]

Not a flag, but if it were, 1.5/10

If using the link:
7.9/10 - pretty memorable, definitely different, kind of piratey/spooky

[Pellucidar]

A fine flag. Lovely colours in a pleasing arrangement. I'm intrigued to know what the icon in the corner represents? 9/10

[Kreushia]

I love the whole split circle with the star in the middle thing you have got going on here.

10/10

Nobody rated my flag

[Merulla]

It is a beautiful flag, undeniable. But I really think there's too much color in it, black bands, red bands and gold outlines? It's too much!
I only recommend that you remove those golden lines. 8/10
Ninj'd twice.

The background flag is already dull, so you filled it with internet memes over it... 0/10


BN: If you're going to waste your time talking about Barbados. Just skip me, it's better for everyone.

[Sarolandia]

8/10

While the similarity to Barbados is uncanny, it reminds me more of Nigeria with the white in the center.

[Merulla]

Really? You guys make me want to quit this thread... I just haven't abandoned it yet, because I really like helping when there's a nation that really needs help.

/SkipMe

[Rhanukhan]

Quite the striking design. An interesting icon in bold B&W certainly stands out - 10/10

[The Draconic Islands]

9/10 Pretty unique flag With eye Like design.
By God you post fast!
This was for The Nation above the skip me

[Anarchic States]

9/10 Pretty unique flag With eye Like design.

very chaotic, and the colors don't work well, but i like the theme and cross design. 5.9/10