Constructively rate the above nation's flag (8)

[Saarz]

Cyan and black is a terrible color combination. Maybe swap the black out for a different color, or make the blue darker. Symbol is good. 5/10

[Mozambiki]

It's a smooth flag and has a original color scheme by using brown, it's a bit bland but still nice to look at 7/10

[Imperial Rifta]

It’s too bright and the colors don’t blend well. 5/10

[Tsaivao]

8.5/10 - I feel like the color combination is a little dull, but I like the pattern and general aesthetic. Good job.

[Alinghi Federal-Democratic Republic]

6.5 nice flag, I'm not a fan of red-black color combination, but it's a quite good

[Japerlasa]

I like the colours, the top left part looks kinda weird. It's like a dumbell.

7.5/10

[Roegerland]

4/10

More suitable as a logo for a sports team than as a flag for a nation. The blue is too bright for my liking and there should never (or at least, very rarely) be text on a flag.

[Bosardia]

I like it a lot. The colours fit well together, the overall look has a very stately feeling about it. The symbolism is nice and adequate, and I could absolutely see this flag in the real world. So there's little else to do other than giving it a 9/10!

[Wapistan]

I like it to some extent, its quite simple and charming. 7/10

[Foederati Kronii]

I like it to some extent, its quite simple and charming. 7/10

I like the guy's eyepatch, 8/10

[Cakasia]

I like it to some extent, its quite simple and charming. 7/10

I like the guy's eyepatch, 8/10

Colour palette works well and the lion symbol is cool. 8/10

[Northern Albania And Western Macedonia]

8/10 i like everything except the symbols color

[Bosardia]

The design looks good, and the colours fit together well too. However, the ripple effect is doing a disservice to this flag in my opinion. It would look much better without it. So, with ripple effect a 7/10, without it would be a 8/10.

[Republic of Burgundy]

8/10. Great color scheme, great design, but the design of the trees is a little complicated.

[Brytwysh]

Look like Beiyang(based) flag
7/10

[Goraria]

Union Jack. Not that original but the Union Jack is a great flag. 8.1/10

[Nookville]

A tad bit unmemorable, but effective. 7/10

[Syndicalist Great Britain]

Distinctive design, but would look better with bolder colours. 6/10

[The Dodo Republic]

Very nice flag. No real comments other then its really nice 7/10

[United Communal Burrow Republics]

AAAN: 6/10. Quite frankly, the colors don't contrast enough, everything blends together and the symbol is so small, it makes it almost impossible to determine what it is. I'm also not a huge fan of curves on flags, but that's more of a personal taste thing. Overall, not bad, but I don't think it works too great either.

AAN: The symbol is simplistic and clear, but I'm not a huge fan of the flame being it's own color. Multicolor symbols like that always make me think more of seals, so it kinda pushes me off. The green and red also contrast a lot, which I'm not a fan of. The design itself is fine though, so I'd say it's a 6.5/10

AN: 7/10. Design is simple but fine, not anything particularly wrong, but not pushing any boundaries either. Would get an 8 if there wasn't a ripple.

[Bosardia]

Really phenomenal flag. It is unique, memorable and incredibly well-designed. The colours work, the symbolism even more so. Seriously, I have no negative critique about this flag. I'm very sorry, but you have forced my hand. This is going to be a 10/10. A sincere, true 10/10.

[Imperial Rifta]

The two shades of green don’t blend well. Changing the green on the outside to a different color might be better. Great design though. 6/10

[Japerlasa]

The colours go very well together and I like the design. Feels like something is missing, though.

8.5/10

[Tsaivao]

6/10 - This could be so much better if you dropped the text and changed the colors to be less saturated.

[United Communal Burrow Republics]

0/10. Bad, no likey, red look ugly. The wormhole look bad.

As an actual serious answer for the Vao, I do quite like your flag. It's one of the few that does black well as a primary color, the use of the less common double stripes is always a win when it's done right, and I've always been a fan of the storm on your flag. Plus I kind of owe you cuz a lot of your usual ratings on flags is what led me to make my flag like this, XD. Solid 9/10