Constructively rate the above nation's flag (8)

[Floofybit]

8/10, it's a good flag but the bird could use a little more detail and the cross seems a little too much like a plus, unless that was your intention

[Indecent Anime Empire]

Nice change of pace, 6/10

clear colors, four colors is one over. The orange is a contrast but it doesn't seem necessary. Nice recognizable symbol in the corner.

[Floofybit]

Nice change of pace, 6/10

clear colors, four colors is one over. The orange is a contrast but it doesn't seem necessary. Nice recognizable symbol in the corner.

Does it look better with the white? /Skip

[The Great Nevada Overlord]

Would be an 8/10 for a good color scheme and originality, but it's gonna be a 6/10 for the fact that they keep changing it.

[The United Penguin Commonwealth]

AAN: 5/10 it doesn’t really look like a flag. the flaming anvils (?) are a bit awkward. I’d remove them and/or make the symbol one of them. the curved line is also a bit weird. maybe it could work if there was another on the bottom for symmetry. you should think about what you want the flag to say about your country and use clear symbolism.

AN: -1 / 10 the rays aren’t even socjxksoaojcisksmsnsk

[Atlantiumia]

Very good, simple and very easy to understand.
10/10

[New-lamp Dynasty]

Yeah no 5/10, i refuse to give it anymore until; the wreath is surrounding something. Other than the bothersome empty wreath, its a fairly decent flag I guess. soooo

personal 5/10
Non personal 6/10 I guess

[The Great Nevada Overlord]

AN: -1 / 10 the rays aren’t even socjxksoaojcisksmsnsk

Next time I will make the rays socjxksoaojcisksmsnsk.
/skipme

[Vinichi]

AN: -1 / 10 the rays aren’t even socjxksoaojcisksmsnsk

Next time I will make the rays socjxksoaojcisksmsnsk.
/skipme

7/10

The flag is visually appealing and very neat, but it doesn't have anything to me that makes it stand out visually. Other than that, good design

[The United Penguin Commonwealth]

AN: -1 / 10 the rays aren’t even socjxksoaojcisksmsnsk

Next time I will make the rays socjxksoaojcisksmsnsk.
/skipme

I meant the rays weren’t evenly sized/spaced as far as I could tell

and then I added socjxksoaojcisksmsnsk for emphasis

/skipme

[Baiddsound]

7/10

The flag is visually appealing and very neat, but it doesn't have anything to me that makes it stand out visually. Other than that, good design

I would reccomend moving the entire pattern to the right and adjusting accordingly, as the left part of the design feels kind of squashed

[Likhinia]

It would be awesome if the sword had a carving or even just a line on it, 7/10.

[Free Vinichi]

It would be awesome if the sword had a carving or even just a line on it, 7/10.

6 out of 10.

The flag's concept is very good and would make an awesome flag with these ideas in mind.

1. The flag is very complex in some places, and very simple in others. Its hard to get the message the flag is trying to convey. In flag making simpler is always better

2. The colors are overly complicated. Youre lettering has a gold gradient which isn't necessary and makes the flag feel busy and cluttered.

3. Your leaves are also a bit messy due to over detailing. Unless that level of detail is significant, you can do much better making them simpler.

In summary, I would use simpler colors, and switch the busier designs with more solid designs and this flag will be outstanding!

[Scytharum]

It's individual elements are pretty good and well-designed, but putting them in this specific format is a bit distracting. It's hard to focus on one part of the flag as the center piece when it feels like this flag has two. Not that having two centerpieces can't be executed, but as it is now it's a bit hard on the eyes. As well, I would advise making the shade of yellow slightly lighter, for more contrast with the background. Solid 6/10 flag, still.

[Free Vinichi]

It's individual elements are pretty good and well-designed, but putting them in this specific format is a bit distracting. It's hard to focus on one part of the flag as the center piece when it feels like this flag has two. Not that having two centerpieces can't be executed, but as it is now it's a bit hard on the eyes. As well, I would advise making the shade of yellow slightly lighter, for more contrast with the background. Solid 6/10 flag, still.

Thanks! /skipme

[Claff]

It's individual elements are pretty good and well-designed, but putting them in this specific format is a bit distracting. It's hard to focus on one part of the flag as the center piece when it feels like this flag has two. Not that having two centerpieces can't be executed, but as it is now it's a bit hard on the eyes. As well, I would advise making the shade of yellow slightly lighter, for more contrast with the background. Solid 6/10 flag, still.

(yes this is another account related to Vinichi and Free vinichi. I have other flag designs to other than this basic design
9/10

This flag is what a good flag design should look like. The only reason I'm not giving a 10 is simply for personal taste. I think the stripes are a little small and from afar would be hard to see. I would have personally made them bigger but other than that its an amazing flag!

[The Niconian Republic]

It's quite decent... but... the gray on the left is really throwing me off. Especially with the symbol which I don't know the name of being in black. If that was changed I think it'd be better.

7/10

[Regnum Alea Spaceflee]

10/10, looks perfect, don't have any complaints

[Eeumeria]

10/10, looks perfect, don't have any complaints

9/10. The overall design looks good, and its still a very recognizable flag. The main thing that bothers me is the breath upon a second look but its still awesome

[New Stonkopolis]

2/10
Terrible colors, bad design, not the best symbol placement. And it has a Flag Creator watermark, so that lowers it 3.
The only thing good about this is the main symbol.
In my opinion, it would be best to completely remake the flag.

[Stevie T]

2/10
Terrible colors, bad design, not the best symbol placement. And it has a Flag Creator watermark, so that lowers it 3.
The only thing good about this is the main symbol.
In my opinion, it would be best to completely remake the flag.

8/10
Very nice symbol, but the orange hurts my eyes.

[Aicrowian Canada]

10/10

Stevie T is an amazing youtuber

[Eeumeria]

2/10
Terrible colors, bad design, not the best symbol placement. And it has a Flag Creator watermark, so that lowers it 3.
The only thing good about this is the main symbol.
In my opinion, it would be best to completely remake the flag.

8/10
Very nice symbol, but the orange hurts my eyes.

Myself or stonkopolis?

[Stevie T]

8/10
Very nice symbol, but the orange hurts my eyes.

Myself or stonkopolis?

Stonkopolis

[Eulisia]

Myself or stonkopolis?

Stonkopolis

Stevie T.. Indeed a great Youtuber.

10/10