Constructively rate the above nation's flag (8)

[The Front Range]

It’s a solid flag, even if the yellowish color is a bit offputting. The sword spices up the standard cross a bit and makes the flag a bit more lively. There isn’t a whole lot to complain about with tjis flag.

Baiddsound’s flag is a solid 8/10

[O r i e n t i a]

Perfect use of colors. Dominated by blue and red, with a pinch of white in the middle acting as a border between the two colors--which, is stylized, probably represents the nation's geography, or symbol? Two mountain peaks with stars. Though the angle of the left mountain is different than the right mountain, probably intended that way.

8.5/10 from me. The combination of the color and the symbolism is good, i magine kids would have no problem drawing it--probably slight difficulty because of the stars.

[Snz Velvet GD Swift]

8/10 it looks very nice, although it kind of copies South Korea

[Galactic Powers]

This flag has serious problems. The strange green opaque crescent overlayed over the already incredibly complicated logo that is off center to make room for a giant crescent that stretches off screen. Too detailed, way too detailed. The only saving grace for this flag is the color combo or purple and gold, and that I like complex flags to an extent. The emblem is nice, but not as a flag. As a coat of arms it even would be too much

3/10

[Sauros]

Gives me flash-backs to learning about the various US state-flags. For one, there's text, which immediately makes me cringe slightly; and then there's the plain field of bright blue, which further reminds me of those flags.

The crescent (which I presume is supposed to be a moon) is a good start, however, and the removal of the text would even forgive the plain field of blue.

With the text, 5/10. Without the text, 7.5/10.

[Terra-Zealandia]

I mean, I love the Jurassic Park vibes going on, but this doesn't work as a flag that much, especially with the wave effect. 4/10

[Merulla]

Nothing to complain about, it follows the rules of vexillology and delivers a new and differentiated result. It would be nice if Australia (or New Zealand) were inspired by their flag to create new flags of their own.

I'm a ripple effect advocate, so that was the only thing missing. 9/10

(I know my flag has the same model as Barbados, no need to mention that. In the real world numerous flags are identical with just another color scheme, this is completely normal.)

[Catsfern]

7.5/10 simple but effective, the design is distinctive and the simple color palate means colors cant clash, and while yes it is a fairly simple design that just means its theoretically quickly recognizable.

[Buhers]

6.5/10 - the bright yellow stars and red and white stripes do not mix well, but i do like the idea

[New Eestiball]

Eh. Symbols too small.
6/10

[Illiryja]

This is a really really nice flag. I love the color scheme and the placement of the stripes on the left. 9.5/10, I don't even know how to exactly improve this, but the yin and yang feel somewhat like there is something super small missing. Also, add the ripple!

[Kostromin]

symbolic, represent the country the seal has a bit much going on though, 8/10

[Kolegei]

Very sunny. The blue and red remind me of of a beach towel. So youre a sunny place with beaches. Hawaii. Youre hawaii. Alohaer than a 7 i suppose

[Krusilov]

7/10 is literally just Venezuela and that's how I rate Venezuela's flag

[Yekateria and Farlandia]

7/10

The colours of the flag are really cool (in fact I have those colours too!) and the emblem is sweet, although sadly the emblem doesn't go on well with the flag (colour clash). Still a lovely emblem though!

[Enthisea]

8/10, it was very nice to see its scandinavian traits

[New Stonkopolis]

8.777777.

Makes me very calm, but too much blue.

[Merulla]

Reduce the center element. There's no need for it to take up sooooooo much space on your flag. Solving this huge problem, pun intended, you will have a work of art.

8/10

(I know my flag has the same model as Barbados, no need to mention that. In the real world numerous flags are identical with just another color scheme, this is completely normal.)

[Terra-Zealandia]

Not bad. Very simplistic and symmetrical, and two basic colours. I've seen a recent uprising of ripple effect support, and personally, I don't think that ripples are clean in my opinion, so it'll be a slight takeaway for me. 7/10

[The Islands Of The Red Dawn]

7/10 love how its colorful but they dont go together in my opinion so thats why i didnt give it 10/10

[New Eestiball]

This doesn't use ripple. That is literally the ONLY good thing about this flag.
1/10

[North Macaronesa]

9/10, I love how simple it is, but it would be better if you added a third stripe to the left of the black one.

BN: Do my IC flag (in the Overview, linked in my signature)

[CSB PM Union]

I like the cute GIF 8/10
Theother flag is kinda mid I like the colours and the sharp edges, don't like the bird 6/10

[New San Andreas Republic]

While the tri-color design is somewhat generic and overdone, as well as the colors being quite simple, I will say the tie adds a certain identity and uniqueness to the flag since I can genuinely say I've not seen it anywhere else. That said, that doesnt necessarily mean it belongs on a flag.

5/10. It's an alright flag.

[Galactic Powers]

Blue California flag, the concept has been done before but this flag makes It work. The shade of blue used is perfect, and the beavers instead of the bear makes it unique to the nation. I like it, although the usual complains about complexity cAn be applied here.

8/10