Constructively rate the above nation's flag (8)

[Frokolia]

10/10 honestly
at first glance i thought i wouldn't like the color scheme, but it all works very well. the wolf(?) head in the center of the cross looks very nice as well; not too simplistic but not overly detailed. very good flag ;P

[Indecent Anime Empire]

8.4 out of 10. very well constructed with the simple symbols in the center and easy color scheme with minor conflicts. Though the only draw back is the Mario character that would possibly look more complete if made to be transparent or seemed to be stitched or imbedded into the flag itself.

[Lucerosa]

8/10.

Not really a flag, but is Christmas time, baby.

[Yenikader]

The sheer amount of yellow's throwing me off, maybe a bit more green on the sides? The rose in the center's beautiful though, maybe it could a tiiny bit bigger though? Also, I don't know if it's not vertically centered or I'm losing it.

7/10 though, it's good!

[Nova Secta]

I like the creativity that went into the flag; I'm not one to adhere to traditional rules of vexillology so I enjoy the emblem on the flag and the accoutrement as it were. My main critiques of the flag would be the busyness of it and the color palette choice: it doesn't quite pop like it could with some different selections, though what those selections would be, I couldn't say. I give this design a solid 8.5 out of 10 for originality and uniqueness though.

[Zingar]

The form is good and easily recognizable. It isn't easily confused with another flag. It is distinct without being too elaborate. It can be easily recalled from memory and easy describe. The color palette is good. I think the yellow could be made to stand out better, but it is very good the way it is. It is a fitting ensign for a ship of the the line for a great maritime nation.
Note: After looking at the flag on a better monitor, it looks like a good yellow to have with the blue and the white. 10/10 for good form and execution.

[Popular Resistance United Front]

The basic shape is okay and gets point for being simple but the colors clash because the middle is too bright and needs a background color like white

[Kaliitnuunati]

8/10, the colors mix great together while not being too boring, the symbol in the middle in extremely unique and adds to the composition quite a lot despite how simple it actually is. Overall I believe it's a rather unique and well-composed flag

[Pathonia]

Simple, a unique type of cross; and adding to it a neat symbol in the middle.
10/10

[Republic of-the North]

0/10
I don't even know what I'm looking at. Overly complex, with clashing colors, a bunch of symbols, and low-res.

[Samrif]

Overall I rather like it, but I find the grey just doesn’t vibe all that well with the white and blue. The wolf symbol in the middle could also be bigger I believe. 6/10

[Safiloa]

It’s very busy, but also very beautiful. A lot of colors are present and the symbols do appear to particularly large, especially the sun.
Overall, it’s not impossible to redraw from memory, is memorable, and is culturally themed….

I’ll give a 9.25/10

[New Eestiball]

No ticker tape. 9/10

[Rivogna]

9.5/10; this flag has little to no faults and conveys the nation's themes very well.

[Sierra Grand]

9/10
I love it, but just the blue and red shades take a point off from perfect.
I would not use red and a lighter blue, but really nice.

[Siddiqatun]

7/10
Good choice of colors, but I feel more could be done. Too much simplicity isn't the way to go.

[Lucerosa]

7/10, I would perhaps simplify the symbol and remove the ripple effect.

[Asaurcmi]

At first glance, the flag design is solid. Though the emblem, symbol? On the flag is too complex, if I was the designer, I’ll removed the central image, but keep the stars for simplicity. The background color is nice and do like the worn look of it.

5/10

[Paradeavenlisian States]

7.9/10, whilst its design might not be the most distinctive, it very much makes up for it with its appealing and striking colour scheme as well as the design's overall simplicity whilst feeling mostly grounded enough to feel like a potential real world flag. The only slight issue I have with it is that the black outline and bottom blue band do blend with each other a little too much and the former feels just a little too thick. As such, I feel the blue could be just a tad lighter and the black outline could be thinned a little, but these are merely just slight nitpicks.

[The Kosaki City Authority]

8/10 The flag design is good and eye catching but the antlers will be tricky to draw

[Hawthane]

8/10

Wonderful coloration, though maybe slightly too complex of symbols though hardly egregious enough to matter. It's good!

[Kiddian States]

5/10
Would be a solid flag, except for the goddamn image on it. It’s an anime girl, too. You’re lucky I didn’t take more points off

[Alski]

6/10
Would be better without the flashing cyan blasted all over

[Lovely Lady]

8/10

I'm Scandinavian, I like Scandinavian-like flags and therefore I like your flag.

[Baiddsound]

Hold on, is your flag related to Carthage? If it is, 10 out of 10, if not, 7.5 out of 10