Constructively rate the above nation's flag (8)

[Cerata]

It's certainly a unique orientation and looks very nice, but you could do without the ripple effect. 9/10.

[Sabutaka]

while it doesn't really look like a flag and has letters on it, it gets a pass since its layer out really well and looks like a war lord flag, but the 4 on the gear on the top doesn't really go well
8/10 unorthodox but its good

[Cerata]

Simple and eastern-esque. Still could do without the ripple, and perhaps the green could be swapped out with a more vibrant color to fit with your background.

[Baiddsound]

Simple and eastern-esque. Still could do without the ripple, and perhaps the green could be swapped out with a more vibrant color to fit with your background.

From a flag perspective, horrible. From a meme perspective, quite good.
Also, someone other than Cerata comment here please

[Free Pyongyang]

pretty good i think the color of the sword should be blue

[The Distanic Confederacy]

A tad bit complicated but other than that it's a solid banner
7/10

[New England and Greater New Brunswick]

I'll be honest. I don't like this flag. I feel that the shapes are all over the place, and the things connecting the box to the corner look uneven and phoned in. There are too many lines, and the shape in the center is weird and not necessarily in a good way. However, I like the color schemne and I believe if the design was simplified it could look good. 4/10.

[Chosin]

8.5/10. Love the color scheme and the simplistic overall design. My main criticism is the emblem - it's too offset to the left. The red and white look a bit superfluous IMO (should have stuck with green and gold). Lastly, even the the outer edge of the emblem is a ring, the internal portion is shaped like a shield, so there's a bit of spillover (e.g., the top of the shield goes into the ring)

[Independent republic of MOSAICA]

Very simple design, and the color don't match that well. 4/10 because it's ok, but this is the place for going wild with flag ideas

[Nothark Vilum]

More of a flag for an elephant reservation or a weird buddhist shop. I've always liked pink and black together tho.

6/10

[New England and Greater New Brunswick]

A simple design, but the colors are elegant and regal. Depending on your coat of arms, or if you have one, adding it may give it that extra star power. 8.5/10

[A blue shirt]

i like how simplistic it is. But personally, I feel like the emblem should be bigger
8/10

[Transoceania]

6/10. It's not a flag, it's a blue shirt, albeit a really nice blue shirt.

[Eotaland]

8.5/10 - I like it. It's clean and memorable!

[A blue shirt]

6/10. It's not a flag, it's a blue shirt, albeit a really nice blue shirt.

My flag fits my name tho /skipme

[Orang Moku]

I like the design, looks like a mix of Scandinavian but with the cross in the center like England’s. Not quite sure about the dark green fitting with the red and yellow though.

[Republic of-the North]

I like the design, looks like a mix of Scandinavian but with the cross in the center like England’s. Not quite sure about the dark green fitting with the red and yellow though.

While the colors are nice, the flag is too cluttered. Removing the fin and star would clean it up and make it a lot better. TBH, I also think five colors is a bit too many, perhaps remove the green? Overall, 5/10.

[Galactic Palestine]

Very colorful and looks like Star Trek.

[Kamchatska]

It’s ok, 7/10

[Republic of-the North]

It’s ok, 7/10

Doin' this again since I got skipped

Nice flag, simple, reminds me of the German Empire. It's eye-catching, and I like the use of black on flags. 8/10

[Rivogna]

I like this flag a lot! It is a very aesthetically pleasing variation of a Nordic flag; in my opinion, the two crosses and circles hit the "goldilocks zone" between simplicity and complexity. However, from now on, the only problems I see in this flag are that the wolf is slightly too intricate to be visible and that the gold could be a bit brighter and more saturated. You could also try making the wolf that storm blue while maintaining its facial features. Right now, though, I would give this flag an 8.5/10!

[Noristoniaka]

I really like this one. Just by a glance at some factbooks, I can really see how this flag represents the nation. The colour scheme is unique and describes the feel well, and I also like the mountains and sun, as it seems somewhat modern but ‘nostalgic’ and meaningful. 9/10

[Aumbura]

The colors are really too bright, and they don't really go together all too well. I dont mind the nordic pattern tho. 4/10

[Berendal]

Great choice of colours, but the symbol in the middle is a bit small when viewed from a distance. The ripple effect needs to go though, because it really diminishes the overall design of the flag. My final rating is a 8/10!

[Waldoven]

The flag design is beautiful. The symbol is unique, creative and wonderfully designed. The colour scheme is nice as well, matches perfectly! The bottom two stripes help to contrast against the blue. All in all, 9.5/10. I don't see what can be improved however

BN: Check the full resolution flag. Tiny profile picture flag has weird artifacts

Edit: For anyone confused, it seemed that AN changed their flag. I didn't rate the wrong nation