Constructively rate the above nation's flag (8)

[Nothark Vilum]

A simple enough flag that accomplishes it’s purpose distinctly.

10/10

*ninja’d, editing…

I’d say it’s too complex: the “symbol” isn’t really defining, with too many colours. And there isn’t really a contrast between the pink background and the sort of magenta symbol.

4/10

[Yutalica]

8/10 really like the colors and how they compliment each other

[Baiddsound]

Nice Design! maybe make the bird a block of colour so that its easier to read when waving in the wind

[New Eestiball]

The yellow is unnecessary. 7/10

[Gopnikea]

I like the contrast between colours, pleasing to the eyes, and it's fairly minimal. It's pretty decent if you ask me.

7/10

[New England and Greater New Brunswick]

I'm a fan of emblems on flags, but yours just seems a tad out of place. Perhaps the wings are too thin, but I digress. Given I like tricolors, but yours is stolen from the motherland, I give your flag a 6.5/10.

[Kyojinou]

The main problem with the flag is that the emblem is way to small, besides that, the color and the design make the flag very recognizable. 6.5/10

[Kandorith]

Ha! It's Japan in the style of Saudi Arabia.

11/10

[Grand Ventana]

This is a 10/10 flag for me. Elegant design, simple, beautiful, nice color pattern, just overall a clean, sleek slice of tastiness.

[New England and Greater New Brunswick]

It's overall good, but I'd change maroon to red and get rid of the circle around the wheel. 5/10

[Farallon]

I like the color scheme, but the symbol in the top-left corner doesn't have enough space horizontally and is a little complex.

[Weltkria]

10/10. Perfect flag for me. Attention is directed to the symbol and the color scheme just works.

[Kranistan]

Nice subversion of an overused colour pattern (guilty as charged), but the amount of detail in the emblem warrants a larger size or a less emphasized position within the frame, like in the top left for example. 9/10

[Diarcesia]

Nice subversion of an overused colour pattern (guilty as charged), but the amount of detail in the emblem warrants a larger size or a less emphasized position within the frame, like in the top left for example. 9/10

9/10 the flag has the right amount of menacing imbued to it

[Aumbura]

Not counting the anime girl ofc. I'd give it a 6/10. I like the colors you chose, as well as the idea that your emblem is going for. I would have just chosen a more menacing or elegant looking cat.

[New England and Greater New Brunswick]

I like your flag. I feel that the colors are good, and the symbols aren't too complex or too symbol. I might remove the wreath and the bow to just have the roses, but it's a solid 7/10.

[Colya]

I like your yellow stripe but maybe enlarge your seal. 7/10

[Kroki]

Looks nice, but is overall pretty lacking. I would recommend adding more stripes, maybe fill the flag with horizonal stripes, and attach some kind of meaning to it. The singular green line at the bottom seems to not have much meaning and comes off not-so important, being on the bottom of the flag. 6/10

[Eotaland]

It's a nice concept, but the pure black and the ripple looks strange (I'd either make the black a very dark grey or remove the ripple). The symbol is unique, but I'm not sold on the colour choice - 6/10

[Weltkria]

Sadly, pretty cliche. Color scheme is good - 5.5/10

[Nythopia]

8/10

[Bededonia]

Looks pretty good, but kinda blank, i think that if the colors were evenly distributed across the flag it would look a little better, but it's very original. 8/10

[Valentine Z]

Fits pretty well. Relative plain, but hey, sometimes the plain flags are the best ones. So it's an 8/10. Good symbol, the tried and true tricolor.

[Dennenberg]

A lovely flag, I enjoy the simplicity of the design and it doesn't feel like there is blank space despite only one thing on the flag. It is very clean in its design and would be recognizable in almost all cases. I do think that the colors could be tweaked to be more distinctive, but it is an absolute nitpick of a complaint due to how well-designed the flag is. 8/10

[Huaren Gongsi state]

The color scheme and the contrast between each color is great, and the patterns are well-organized too. 10/10