Constructively rate the above nation's flag (8)

[Eotaland]

6/10 - It feels a little bit crowded and the ripple effect doesn't work too well with flags that have pure-black on them. It's unique though and suits the theme of the nation, so with a little tweaking I think it could be really good.

[Beric]

8/10 It actually feels fresh due to the color scheme given its layout is fairly standard. The yellow with the green works better than I would have expected and based on the flag alone makes me think of a island nation.

[New Stonkopolis]

An interesting symbol in the center...
Stars around it?

9/10.
Beautifully simplistic.

[Not FNU]

Fits the anarcho-capitalist vibe, and the snake is a nice touch. A bit of a shame the yellow is so hard against the black. 9.5/10.

[Superlols]

This is a really creative flag! I like the use of libertarian snake forming the circle on the middle. The colors go well with it as well.

9/10

Ninjad, wait a minute

I really like its minimalistic aproach, the color is descent, but i dont know what the symbol inside the star is about, sorry .

7/10

[North Finslisia]

It looks like Chile but there was an earthquake so now it's all oblique 5½/10

[Frokolia]

the three blues doesn't look bad somehow, though it still feels lacking in variety because it's just blue. the symbol in the center is also difficult to see :/

6/10

[Atlantic Isles]

Neat emblem. I'm personally not a fan of so much black on a national flag, and the brighter red block on the right is really harsh against the black. The purple is fine but looks a bit flat IMO. The red in the emblem is fine as a nice pop, it's just the right-side block that's tough to look at. 7.25/10

[New Stonkopolis]

Hawai'i Plus.

8.999999999999999/10

[Baddo Darklands]

6/10 Clever, but not the most visually appealing

EDIT to clarify: The colour scheme is my issue with the flag. I think I will increase my rating to 7.5 as it fits the nation.

[Huron League]

Uhhhhhhhhhh 123.381/10 beautiful no change needed whatsoever

[Imperial Provincials]

Not a bad flag, but it feels like you drove up the saturation a bunch because the colors are very dim and bland.

[Kradsen]

5/10. I don't like the colors, plus the white square with the cross feels kind of just thrown in there, and a bit short.

[Great United States]

5/10 3D shapes REALLY dont work with flags

[Grand Ventana]

There's a lot going on with this flag, and the darkened color palette makes it a bit difficult to make out details. But it's also creative and innovative and I like the colors chosen, which counts for a lot. I kind of like the design, I would honestly give it a 7.5 out of 10 I think - well done mate!

[Terra-Novan Federation]

The yellow leans a bit too orange, and the symbol could be larger. That's all I can criticize. 7/10 flag.

[Atlantic Isles]

Cool emblem, but… s p i n ! 8/10 just because of the animated element, don’t think it really works as a flag. But it’s a cool emblem for sure.

[North Macaronesa]

6.5/10, I like the navy, gold, and white color scheme, but the Scotland-style cross in the upper left-hand corner has too much going on, maybe just combine all the symbols in a CoA, then put that in the middle of the cross? Otherwise, it's a great flag that's quite unique

[Southern Republic of Dixie]

8/10
The Mismatches throw me off. Yellow blue, and white are not a good mix when the white being blocked by a bird.

[Samrif]

I rather like it. There is a soft feel to the flag, the colors look good. A 9/10 I believe would be appropriate.

[Sagrea]

AAN: I've said this before about AAN's flag but I really like how it's very distinctly the Confederate flag but it manages to distance itself from the connotations of the flag. It fits very well with what the AAN is, that being a more progressive Dixie. 10/10 for that, honestly it's very well done. The colors are also very pleasing to look at.

Edit: ninja'd, please stand by.

AN: Good color scheme, nice symbolism. Everything is laid out in a pleasing way. Except for the tiger. It's way too small and overly detailed so it ends up looking like a bright orange blob that is off from the rest of the flag. 8.5/10 but would be a 10/10 without the tiger.

[Uminaku]

5/10. It is just the flag of Namibia with a tiger at the bottom right and minor changes. While I like the colors and design, it isn’t that original and the tiger emblem is too complex for a flag and just doesn’t fit well. So definitely minus points for that.

ninja’d.

9.5/10. That is an extremely nice flag. It is simple enough and can be distinguished easily from far away. The colors might be too dark and lack contrast, but I think that isn’t a big problem.

[Cachard Calia]

9/10, a little on the plain side

[Noristoniaka]

I do like the stars, although the Macau crest throws me off a little because of the palette. 7.2/10

[Cachard Calia]

I do like the stars, although the Macau crest throws me off a little because of the palette. 7.2/10

I mixed up the Hong Kong and Macao flags when requesting this
/skipme