Constructively rate the above nation's flag (8)

[Holy Hawaiian Empire]

10/10 love the colors and a nordic cross is always nice

[Atlantic Isles]

Holy crap I love that! I'm a bit biased, though... also based my design off the Hawaiian flag. Colors work very well together. 10/10

[Sabutaka]

The yellow blue white color combination kinda burns my eyes a bit (then again its 1AM), although the design looks well, especially the upper left part
overall 7/10, could be better but its good

[Samrif]

I like it. Looks pretty beautiful and organized. 10/10 for me.

[Atlantic Isles]

Looks like the Namibian flag with a different star and a tiger... looks nice but not crazy original. 7/10

[Nouveau Strasbourg]

I'm not the biggest fan of the color combo, but I think the overall design looks pretty neat. 7.5/10.

[The Dodo Republic]

9/10 great flag

[Eotaland]

9/10 - A really nice flag. It's very memorable, well proportioned, and the colours compliment each other.

Ninja'd

6/10 - It's a fine flag but perhaps if the triangle was another colour it might stand out more.

[Atlantic Isles]

9/10, very nice flag. Definitely gives Scandinavian vibes but with a cozy forest feel because of the red/rellow/green. I'm a fan.

[Kenowa]

4/10. Kind of odd to be honest. The cross blends with one of the yellow stripes, the tridents are too small to see properly and the waving effect makes it look weird. I like the concept and the colours but the execution could have been done better, it just feels as if there was too much going on.

[The Kosaki City Authority]

6/10 the design is ok but difficult to identify if seen from far away

[Kjalaara]

Hell no! It was 10/10 last time I checked and now it is even better. It might work better with only three stars but it is difficult to improve what is perfect.

[Atlantic Isles]

Looks very futuristic. I can see a Scandinavian influence but it isn't quite the same (which I don't mind) and the axes contribute to that. The figure in the middle of the circle gave me a quick pause scrolling down the page but it's interesting on further review. 8/10.

(Also, check out the 2nd iteration of the Atlantic Islesian flag!)

[Huron League]

8/10, solid color scheme but a little crowded.

[Kurdistan 2022 rp]

6/10 reminds me of a nordic flag but otherwise bland

[Atlantic Isles]

It's literally the flag of Kurdistan. Not much to be said. It's meh... a fine flag but not that original. 6/10

[Nova Secta]

I actually think the emblems in the flag's field do it a bit of a disservice; without them it's a 10/10 flag for me, I love the color pattern and the design. As it stands, I'd give it a solid 8/10, but do believe a less-is-more approach might work better here.

[Siornor]

Sweeeeet flag, emblem is classy as all heck. The colors are great but if there's one area I'd suggest for improvement it would be darkening the blue or throwing in another color that will make it all "pop."

9/10

[Ralshia]

Sweeeeet flag, emblem is classy as all heck. The colors are great but if there's one area I'd suggest for improvement it would be darkening the blue or throwing in another color that will make it all "pop."

9/10

Colors are a bit too dark, but i like that pattern design that extends from the center and the pear is a nice touch. 8/10

[Aumbura]

3/10. Not a big fan of the colors or symbols, but that's just my personal taste.

[North Keyton]

6/10, emblem is cool, but the colors don't match well

[Parmilo]

8/10, very simplistic (wich if you've seen at least one post from me on this thread with my main nation you know I like) but it still feels kind of lacking. There's not a whole lot that's too unique that you could look at and go "This is North Keyton's flag."

[Sabutaka]

the colors don't match well and the seal in the center is a bit too simplistic, and also there's a bit of a gap between the tree and the rest of the circle, 3/10

[Aumbura]

7/10. I really like the colors as well as how clean the flag is. It's a flag that reflects a nation of peace.

[Huaren Gongsi state]

Ratio is a bit too wide and optimally speaking, the emblem should be put on the left side since that's the least movable part of the flag. the Emblem should also be larger but I honestly like the theme. 7/10