Constructively rate the above nation's flag (8)

[Equai]

Usage of red-blue-whitr colors is nothing new, arguably a bit too basic option for colors but it works, it just works very good with this flag and what (i think) is trying to portray. The writing blends good with the background. A solid 7 form me

[455 Lands]

I like this a lot.

Good use of pink and black, given the nation´s theme.
The subtle triangle on the left, with the leftist symbol...

My only concern, and it´s a small one, is the horizontal black band.

As the diagonal bands are constructed from two colours (two borders and one thick diagonal in between), the unicolour horizontal seems a bit underwhelming.

If that should present a situation where the stars become the next issue (why diagonals with stars, and a horizontal without them), maybe the best improvement is: no stars at all, and all bands the same two colours?

As is: 8.8/10

[New San Andreas Republic]

Oh Dear Lord. This flag is like the terrible proposed EU striped flag on steroids. It's like r/place became a flag. It's like a Jackson Pollock painting felt flaggy today. It violates every rule of good vexillological design. It doesnt even look like a flag, it's just random symbols and whatnot like you're on acid.

1/10, definitely.

[Aegeonia]

This is a Good Flag

I only don’t like 2 things, first off the beaver (I’m assuming the beaver is supposed to be a 2 headed mutant thing) doesn’t really look like 1 beaver, it looks like another beaver is standing behind it and sticking it’s head up, might want to fix that, and 2nd of all, the Text, just get rid of it man.

8.5/10

[Relwynia]

I think the flag has a lot of potential, but it is unfortunately a little diminished by the ripple effect. If the ripple effect were to be removed the flag would look a lot better, because the choice of colours and design is very nicely done.

In its current form, I'd rate the flag a 7,5/10.

[Rivogna]

The above flag is one of the few that balances simplicity and intricacy. The yellow-and-purple color scheme is unconventional yet aesthetically pleasing, and the deer and chains make it stand out. In general, the flag is excellent! 9.5/10!

[New San Andreas Republic]

You've been told this a lot, but this is a damn good flag. The sun and mountain symbolism is excellently executed, the two stripes are just enough to look distinctive with a great tone, and the yellow choice for the symbols contrasts well. Furthermore, the sheer simplicity, lack of need for text and originality of the design help it more. No criticism really, just good.

10/10.

[New Eestiball]

I get the style, I know exactly what you're going for and basing it off of.
And it sucks. Your flag is like a better version of the California flag, but the california flag sucks.
6/10.

[Kingdom of Lechia]

Simple but well made flag. Work on such a flag is not long.

8/10

[Karazicu]

Simple but well made flag. Work on such a flag is not long.

8/10

Something just doesn't seem right about the text on the flag. Don't really have any gripes when it comes to having text on your flag, but it looks squished, and that tosses it off for me. The Slavic wheels also sort of spoil it for me because of their placement, so perhaps you could space out the text and the wheels so that it looks better, perhaps more like how the Ba'athist Iraq flag looked. I do like the color palette, though, I can easily imagine a nation like yours using this flag, perhaps with less squishy looking text and the Slavic wheels spaced out. Overall, 5/10.

---

BN: Ignore Saddam Hussein on my flag. I decided to be very much unique and use two different flags, do whichever one you please, perhaps both if you feel like it.

[New San Andreas Republic]

I'll do both. There are definitely elements I like that both share, such a unique combination of colors typically reserved for naval jacks. Furthermore, I'll admit there's an element of charm in the usage of a 4-pointed star with does a good job of making your flag look more unique. Unfortunately, I'm not a fan of either symbol prominently featured on each of them. The weirdly-formal fonted 'M' looks just sorta odd, and the Dragonov on the variant just makes (as does any gun on a flag, really) your nation look like an armed insurrection group. I don't hate the flag, but I don't love it either.

5/10.

[New San Andreas Republic]

/bump

[Tea Chuggers]

8.5/10 -- does what it sets out to do with aplomb, and nothing more than that. I love the shade of blue, and the beavers are really well done, but I don't think I can award any points for originality, just stellar execution.

[Azania-]

Assuming that the flag at the top of the sidebar in this factbook is their flag, I think it's good. More than good, in fact; I like the use of only two colours, and the green and white complement and contrast each other quite nicely; the design is also great, especially the three tea leaves (I'm assuming that they're tea leaves) which, given that the love of tea is the AN's whole thing, is a nice little touch. Overall, 9/10.

[New Eestiball]

Such a good color scheme, but the stars and line are too small and nitpicky.

8/10, for what could have been.

[Azurros]

The colors are simple yet match together nicely. The patterns on the flag look simple and clean yet unique enough to distinguish itself from other flags.

Overall, 9/10

[Patagonja]

8/10 — Overall good design. I think the colours clash a little in the middle, and I’ve taken (as I always do) a point off for the ripple. Unique, though.

[Ayushvandra]

I don't see any factbooks, so your flag is a good way to express your lore. that being a british argentina (i guess?). however, it is, like many other union jack canton flags, a bit unoriginal. it follows the classic union jack on the corner and then a symbol on the side. although i guess i can dismiss that for the lore.

7.5/10

[Arpasia]

I would feel like the stripe dividing the bicolor would be realigned to make it more neat to the eye, as for the device in the center, it does look like the Surya Majapahit symbol, maybe it is a similar symbol. When paired with the bicolor, it does look somewhat like a good combination, though it would look more appealing when the symbol in the center is enclosed in a shield. Overall, it's an excellent design. 7.8/10.

[Amoresierra]

O.K. besides the Henry image insert, flag has simple and easy to understand layout but still there are too many colors (five) to know the meaning of the flag. 7/10

[Arpasia]

/ s t i l l m e , I g u e e s .

[The Kingdom of the Three Isles]

Uhhhhhhhhh 7/10
Please don’t hurt me

[Frisemark]

A non-horizontally rectangular flag is always interesting to see.

That said, the design just feels...uninspired. It doesn't really pop, and it just feels like "what if EU but giga-germany". Also, the UN wreath is greatly overused and I don't like seeing it on stuff anymore.

I dunno. 5/10 I guess? It's not bad, just...not memorable.

[The Kingdom of the Three Isles]

A non-horizontally rectangular flag is always interesting to see.

That said, the design just feels...uninspired. It doesn't really pop, and it just feels like "what if EU but giga-germany". Also, the UN wreath is greatly overused and I don't like seeing it on stuff anymore.

I dunno. 5/10 I guess? It's not bad, just...not memorable.

Wait, EU but giga Germany?!
But other stuff I agree with
/skip

[Junatia]

62/100
The Angel and Dragon in the center is pretty unique and the shade of storm blue (stripes) looks very cool, but doesn't really fit with the yellow shade. Still ok flag though. Also looks very dutch to me