Constructively rate the above nation's flag (8)

[Southern Republic of Dixie]

Your Flag is all over the place, Figures aren't the same. Black flag but it is bearable.
3/10

[Agencourt]

This would be 9 except for the fact that I don’t like that website, it just isn’t that helpful and I have a lingering sense that it came from random flag generator, also ripple.

But everything else is great! 7.5/10

no it did not come from a random flag generator, I have enough self worth to design my own.

/skipme

[The H Corporation]

Your Flag is all over the place, Figures aren't the same. Black flag but it is bearable.
3/10

The colors red and blue normally combine with each other and do a very good duo, plus they are my favorite colors! In this flag though the color red is practically not used other than dividing the cross and the background of the flag and because of the excessive use of blue makes the flag really nothing special, the cross with lighter blue does not combine with the red one. The only thing that is good in the flag are the stars in white, and that is it.

2/10

[Kirungabi]

Not a fan of black on flags, but it's clean and looks nice.

7/10

[Reino de Portvgal]

I actually love it, great design and great colors. 9/10

[Laka Strolistandiler]

7.5/10, due to the crown’s design being a little bit over complicated IMHO, same goes for the whole coat of arms-ish element in the center. Other than that a solid flag!

[Yellow Fingers]

8.5/10 simple colors and a good design

[Skarmia]

2/10. Violates the rule of tincture, and the yellow is too light to avoid the pitfalls of many other such violations. The coat of arms and the version of the Union Jack just blend too much into the background.

[The Aber]

2/10. Violates the rule of tincture, and the yellow is too light to avoid the pitfalls of many other such violations. The coat of arms and the version of the Union Jack just blend too much into the background.

Out of all the ones I've seen so far, Skarmia's is probably a prime example of how you can make something so simple yet so appealing to the eye. The pattern, the colors, the stars...just...mwuah. Love it. 8.3/10

BN: Yes, it's supposed to be unsettling, if not damn-near terrifying. That was the Aber vexillologist's goal, in part. And to not make it look too much like anything you'd find in the flags of the other 200-something countries.

[Agencourt]

I can't tell if it should be 12/10 for the aesthetic or 0/10 for the extreme complexity.

I'll split the difference and say 6/10

BN: This is the pride month flag. Check my factbooks for the real one if you wish.

[New Zoigai]

The real one Looks great, I do think it fits with the theme of your nation, I especially like the Blue and red, in sections, with a hint of white,



8.3/10


BN: Posting My Normal Flag in a Different factbook shortly.

[Hathian Prime]

I’d say it’s a solid 7/10. It could easily be higher if it wasn’t cluttered. However, the colors compliment each other very well and the designs certainly catch the eye.

[New Zoigai]

7.9/10

Only issue is that hidden anime girl. Other than that,I like the colors and the Spaceship looks cool

[Altmelia]

8.9/10, not bad, but why the Ethiopia star?

[Laka Strolistandiler]

7/10- looks a bit too complicated as well as some questionable color combinations. Other than that that’s a very good-looking and original flag!

[Bistritza]

hypnotic, trippy. i like it. the white might be better if it was black though.
9/10

---

i know it's temporary but please give recommendations for a better color pallet on front-objects (crescent and stars), i cant think of anything else

[Broader Confederate States]

9/10, maybe darken the blue a little so the stars pop more (or replace the black with white), and the circle (which I assume to be the moon) is barely visible. The black and orange look good, though.

[Farallon]

7/10, I like the colors but the flag layout and how bright the palette is makes it personally not my favorite.

[Rivogna]

I love that flag! It is very sleek, and the color scheme is pleasing to the eye. The stars and the bird are great final touches, too! I do not have complaints; in my perspective, the flag is nearly flawless. 9.5/10!

[Guama]

8/10 — Great design and colors. My sole criticism is that it's maybe a bit busy but a great flag overall.

[Rivogna]

/bump
/skip

[Azania-]

8/10 — Great design and colors. My sole criticism is that it's maybe a bit busy but a great flag overall.

I mean, as they stated, their flag is supposed to look like Cuba, so I don't think there's much to be said. It's a solid design with an excellent colour scheme, and it fits in with their parodical theme. Overall, 10/10.

[Kandorith]

Right, personal opinion aside, the flag looks great. It's clear, symbolic and recognizable. The colours fit and the overal form works. A solid 8/10.

This is where the personal opinion comes in, to me it feels like a generic African Union flag, but that's me. Overall its well designed and works.

[Khantashonia]

The symbol looks pretty cool. The colors work well too. This flag gets a 9/10 from me.

[Apexiala]

9/10 very cool
Colours work well together and look authentic without directly copying any IRL flags.
Geometry used in the flag is very original too, haven't seen that design before so looks great.