Constructively rate the above nation's flag (8)

[Die Nieuw Nederland]

Original, Distinctive, and it pops. I like it! No complaints, 10/10.

[New Eestiball]

Putting red on orange isn't a good idea.
6/10, because the rest is ok.

[Broader Confederate States]

Nice palette that doesn't pierce, balanced, and very flag-like design (a lot of this stuff tends to be minimalist artwork), I approve. 8/10. The only thing I'd say would be that my personal preference would be to flip the design.

[Yohaulticetlia]

I really like it. The sun has a good number of points at attractive angles, although I might make the angles shallower and decrease the number of points by maybe two in order to make them more individually visible. I greatly enjoy that slightly teal-ish shade of light azure blue as well, although I might darken it just a smidge. The yellow and red of the stripes provide good visual balance, and although the balance is off a little because of the blue in the triangle on the hoist, it is offset by the yellow border, and the slightly off-balance feel to it creates a sense of composition.

EDIT: so sorry I keep forgetting the number rating. 9/10

[The H Corporation]

I don't really like the combination of colors, the color palette is awful but it is somehow saved by the crest in the middle. I don't know why or how that is possible, without the crest, the flag is plain awful but with the crest, it is actually a decent flag and easily recognizable because no one would use that color palette. The flag just blew up my brain tbh

7/10

[New Eestiball]

Amazing, 9.5/10

[Frisemark]

Rather great actually. Estonia’s always had a beautiful color palette to go off of, so it’s hard to make something that’s bad. Combine that with a unique layout and yin-yang esque emblem, it makes a very visually pleasing piece of vexillology. 9/10.

[Sauros]

Represents the "TL;DR" in their signature very well. The background stripes are a tad distracting. 8/10.

[Alasiqak]

6/10, honestly, all the colors and design are there and would make a great flag, its just the excessively complicated dinosaur and plants that bring down the flag as a whole. If it were simplified, it would look great.

[Yohaulticetlia]

Alaska has a wonderful flag. I love the Ursa Major with the North Star depicted in their actual orientations, and the shade of very deep dusky blue is awesomely invocational of the night sky. It is interesting here with the white stars, and the white does complement the design elements in the canton, but my other favorite part of the Alaskan flag is the rich, golden yellow used for the stars. The bright red hoist band is stunning, though, and the white is striking against it and the dark blue alike. The canton design is very interesting as well. I like the sickle contrasted against what looks like an axe-head.

8/10, I liked it.

[Gjotland]

Their flag is very cool, especially that coat of arms in the middle, that's my favorite part of the flag. The color combination of their flag is interesting, I have not seen a flag that uses those 3 colors, let alone combine them. Not the first weird color combination I've seen, but I have seen others way worse than this.

8/10

[Stravonia]

I wish the logo in the middle was bigger and there was more contrast in colors. 6/10

[The H Corporation]

Unoriginal, and too simple, the trident does not fit the flag. Overall I give it a 4/10

[Southern Republic of Dixie]

Too much Black, it's a yellow Sun on a flag, nothing unique about it....
0/10

[The H Corporation]

Too much Black, it's a yellow Sun on a flag, nothing unique about it....
0/10

It's not even a sun for your information .-.
/skip me

[Stravonia]

I don't like flags with a black background, 3/10

[Agencourt]

8/10

There isn't too much to change. A small complex symbol is usually bad but in this case it works. I do think the red is slightly too dark, though.

[Sanguille]

Yours is otherwise perfect, but I think the ripple affect takes away from the grandeur. 9.5/10.

[Free Kathen]

Your flag may not be representative of your motto, but it’s otherwise really good! The flame balances being fairly complex while being simple enough to easily read at a distance. It feels a little empty due to the white space, but I’m not 100% sure how you would fix that. Overall, 9/10.

[Indigenous Peoples Of America]

Very nice, smooth and basic flag. Only complaint is color on emblem in center clashes with 2 others. Very distracting. Overall, 8.5/10.

[The H Corporation]

I don't like flags with a black background, 3/10

And you literally skipped Dixie which was next .-.

Very nice, smooth and basic flag. Only complaint is color on emblem in center clashes with 2 others. Very distracting. Overall, 8.5/10.

It is too simple. But it works in this case

7/10

[Umbratellus]

7/10 It's a good, solid flag though somewhat unmemorable. I do like the choice in colors, they aren't garish and give off an-cap vibes lol. The 8 pointed star or octagram in the middle captures an essential future tech feel.

[Agencourt]

Certainly a memorable flag, though I'm not sure about the contrast (or lack thereof) between that red and black/charcoal grey.

7/10.

[New Eestiball]

This would be 9 except for the fact that I don’t like that website, it just isn’t that helpful and I have a lingering sense that it came from random flag generator, also ripple.

But everything else is great! 7.5/10

[Reich of the New World Order]

The yin and yang look out of place but other than that its a good flag 8/10.