Constructively rate the above nation's flag (8)

[Cypress City]

8/10 pretty good, makes me think of Chechens

[Free Kathen]

3/10. The flag in the corner is fine, although there isn't anything explaining whether that's a colony or just the preference of the flagmakers. However, I don't like the detailed seal on the flag, as that can be really hard to see from a distance, and without much else to complement it the white field on the flag just seems kind of bland and characterless. I think if you were to simplify the tree and center it on the white field, or put a simplified tree on a white field in the corner and put the stripes on the main part of the flag, it might look better.

[The Aber]

3/10. The flag in the corner is fine, although there isn't anything explaining whether that's a colony or just the preference of the flagmakers. However, I don't like the detailed seal on the flag, as that can be really hard to see from a distance, and without much else to complement it the white field on the flag just seems kind of bland and characterless. I think if you were to simplify the tree and center it on the white field, or put a simplified tree on a white field in the corner and put the stripes on the main part of the flag, it might look better.

(Yawn) Too much like other flags. Same general design and everything. 1.1/10.

[Khantashonia]

9/10
White and blue work pretty well on this flag. The swirls make it more interesting.

[Arpasia]

7.1/10

My most favorite part in this particular flag would obviously be the Tricolor and it's color combination, because, no other country in the real world has the same colors of blue, green and yellow, and that in itself is able to set it apart from other designs on this site, alth there are similar designs like this. But then we move on to the coat of arms in the center, for one, the coat of arms is sized a bit too large, taking up maybe, 50%percent of the blue stripe, secondly, the inclusion of the more finer details in the coat of arms such as the stars on top of it and the circle below the trident makes it a little difficult for one to draw it by hand, but it also makes the flag easily memorable. Overall though, a very interesting design for a flag.

[Frisemark]

9/10. Recognizable and eye pleasing. Simplistic yet quality central emblem and wonderful colors work together to make a great flag.

[Seven Banners]

9/10 that's a sexy flag for what it is
I would say it's cluttered, rule of tincture, not simple to replicate bla bla bla, but that's clearly the point with the European heraldic symbolism and Icelandic Commonwealth-style stripes. It does its job well.

[The Moonlight Land]

Frazzle end, wide aspect ratio, tip a different color... 8.5/10, maybe even a 9.

[Isle of Westland]

8/10

Great flag, however the dark blue and black do just blend into one another so I'd probably stick to the dark blue alone.

[Reino de Portvgal]

This flag just works for me, despite it being a square I really like how it goes well together. 9/10

[The H Corporation]

I like the black and yellow since it is a safe combination of colors, what is in the middle not so much, I feel like it would be better if the coat of arms was in another place rather than the center

7/10

[Frisemark]

8/10. Easily identifiable, easy to draw, sticks out great, and is just eye-pleasing. Plus, nails the corporate hellscape feel.

[Frisemark]

/bump (I lied )

[Erloane]

8/10. Easily identifiable, easy to draw, sticks out great, and is just eye-pleasing. Plus, nails the corporate hellscape feel.

8/10 Very pleasing. Love the design.

[The Finntopian Empire]

seems farmiliar... but very good design, 8/10

[United Tropics of Torchland]

7/10

very rare find of purple in flags, and gives a meaning of the country being located on a cold land inhabited with penguins.

[Insulamia]

Not enough white, red, and blue arranged in three horizontal stripes with a QR code in the top-left corner. Other than that, it seems a little unbalanced to have such detailed symbols on the left third while a plain colour on the right two-thirds. Also, I don't think the colour combination of purple, blue, white and a little grey and black go together well. Looks like Qatar, but without the cool zigzag and with some .png images slapped on. O'erall, 3/10.

nin jade

Torchland's flag has five colours, but these are incorporated well into the design. I generally like the it, and it is also quite distinctive and realistic. What bothers me, though, is that the red, white and blue lines in the left are not evenly wide. Also, I think the Zimbabwe bird could do without the black outline, just makes things more simple and fitting with the rest of the flag. Overall, 8/10 flag.

[Kingdom of Lechia]

It's kinda weird. British colony + France.

Anyway, 6/10

[The Finntopian Empire]

very nice, text on flags tho >:( 5/10

[Karazicu]

So, this flag looks quite decent to me, I particularly like the swallowtail shape. However, I think you went a little too far in, so I think you could improve it by not indenting the swallowtail flag that much, like make it less deep. Overall, 6/10.

---

BN: Ignore Saddam Hussein. You can choose to rate either the M flag or the flag with the rifle on it. You can do both if you please.

[The Aber]

So, this flag looks quite decent to me, I particularly like the swallowtail shape. However, I think you went a little too far in, so I think you could improve it by not indenting the swallowtail flag that much, like make it less deep. Overall, 6/10.

---

BN: Ignore Saddam Hussein. You can choose to rate either the M flag or the flag with the rifle on it. You can do both if you please.

Eh. looks a little bland, the flag with an M on it. Maybe it's the font or accompanied field color behind the letter. See if you can work something out, choose a new font, maybe a new field,, maybe it'll be more appealing to the eye.

---

BN: I'm taking this specific flag for a quick spin. Telegram me if y'all want to offer some more constructive criticism without clogging up the wall.

[Planula]

The strong point of this exercise in psychedelic experience is that it consists of just two colours.

And in doing so, it evokes just enough reference to - say - old Japanese imperial flags to seem like a realistic flag as well.
(Take my flag for an example of something entirely UNREALISTIC, and less artistically executed.)

It may not be everyone´s cup of tea, but it is very well done all the same.

My only advise would be to make the mask/eyes/whatever in the middle a little more outspoken, as it probably represents something quintessential to the soul of your nation. Make it a shade more cartoonesque, if you catch my drift.

9/10

[Diarcesia]

The strong point of this exercise in psychedelic experience is that it consists of just two colours.

And in doing so, it evokes just enough reference to - say - old Japanese imperial flags to seem like a realistic flag as well.
(Take my flag for an example of something entirely UNREALISTIC, and less artistically executed.)

It may not be everyone´s cup of tea, but it is very well done all the same.

My only advise would be to make the mask/eyes/whatever in the middle a little more outspoken, as it probably represents something quintessential to the soul of your nation. Make it a shade more cartoonesque, if you catch my drift.

9/10

Not vexillologically-compliant, but I can see them ICly adopting it.
5/10 for verisimilitude

[Frisemark]

9/10. Great and recognizable design, with a great color palette and believable reasoning behind it.

My personal issue is that I don’t generally like flags that are just bedsheets with emblems, even if they work spectacularly like Diarcesia’s does.

[The H Corporation]

8/10

It is simple, easy to recognize, original, the colors blend, the coat of arms or whatever that is in their flag is nice, the only thing I have a problem with is the shield, like I dislike that coloring and how it blends but it not that bd still since it doesn't ruin the flag