Constructively rate the above nation's flag (8)

[The State of Moultrie]

It's Okay. But the Colors are a bit Poorly Chosen and the Shape is a bit Complex.
4/10.

[Arathane]

Perfect US flag.. 11/10

[Burkitts]

The red is a bit dark so it makes it kinda of hard to distinguish the shapes, but overall a good design 7.5/10

[Digval]

It's unique.. I'll give you that. 5/10

[Aquyia]

looks very different, although it's a bit too bright, wouldn't say it's bad 5/10

[The H Corporation]

Unique design but the colors don't convince me or fit the design. 5/10

[Diarcesia]

Unique design but the colors don't convince me or fit the design. 5/10

8/10

It's supposed to be lower, but for something that represents a company, this is really good.

[Rivogna]

The proud and steadfast cat is a powerful and memorable design. Although, it may have to be spruced up a little. 8/10!

[Drifterica]

Cool Flag, original design but I think the star is slightly to large. 9/10

[Reich of the New World Order]

The design is nice but the colors look odd 7/10

[Somiens-et-Haveras]

6.5/10. The design overall isn't terrible. I would recommend changing your emblem to something more recognizable and/or simplistic, and I would get rid of the gradient in your field in favor of a solid black. The varied thickness of the stripes is an interesting touch, though. With these changes I think it could get up to an 8 or 9.

[Rivogna]

A lovely design, but I would recommend making the stars a bit larger. Excellent work; 8.5/10!

[Barlyy]

Absolutely gorgeous. The colors are amazing, the design is beautiful.. Nothing else to say. 10/10

[Huosheng]

Hard to tell what the actual look is with all the color changes, but from what I think the original pattern is, it's pretty cool. The colors work well with each other and the repeating rose pattern is pretty unique. Overall I'd say 8.5/10

[Ozymontias]

It's a nice color scheme, but having the whole bottom half be white makes it feel too top heavy in my opinion. The gold border around the canton looks nice. 7/10

[Aquyia]

The design is unique, the colors go well together are pleasant to look at, it's just overall good, only thing that would stop me from giving a perfect 10 out of 10 would be the one missing star in the flag, but other than that its great 10/10

[Arathane]

Definitely one that makes Aquyia stand out from the rest with its purple background and orange stripe

6/10

[Reich of the New World Order]

I like it ,nice design and good color 10/10

[Ozymontias]

The flag overall has a nice design - black, white, and purple go together really well, the middle symbol is distinctive if a little complex, and I like the black bars of varying thicknesses. I think the biggest issue for me is the composition; the gradient at the top and bottom distracts from the color, as does the striped texture and gradient shading of the purple and the texture of the white areas. It's very complex and busy up close, which is a shame because it has a really great profile and design from afar when you can't really see those details. 4/10.

[Capital-Neptune]

Strangely reminds me of an African nation flag. I personally like the top-left golden/yellow star. I don't like the design of the flag, but some do. Very unique. Overall 7/10.

[Earth-24601]

I like the colors and the emblem, but i think placing four of them in the corner is a mistake, maybe two (in the center) or just one would do, 7/10

[Novotia]

8/10

[The H Corporation]

The design, the colors, the symbol...

Jesus, you deserve a 10. Great job

[Xorvo]

It definitely gives off that soulless, (maybe evil?), corporate feel. The colours yellow, black, and white work incredibly well together, and the overall design gives it the effect of a sleek, modern company logo. However, from a vexillological perspective, it's really held back by the whole text thing, and the thin typography doesn't exactly lend itself much in the way of easy-reading and visibility at a distance. 7/10.

[Ozymontias]

I like it. The colors pop and complement each other. I can't place my finger on it, but it just feels like there's something missing and holding it back from being great; wish I could be more constructive than that. 7.5/10 (also it would look nicer without the ripple imo)