Constructively rate the above nation's flag (8)

[Tyrantfolly]

7/10, pretty nice, but the yellow part stands out a bit weirdly.

[Aquyia]

8/10, checks out in the 5 rules, does look quite nice, the only thing bad I have to say about it is that the swords are a bit too detailed, but wales has a flag, it's just pretty good

[Bigpipstan]

The design is utilitarian then asthetic in nature, as such it is completly abstract. The colour scheme is nice atleast. Unlike other utilitarian flags it is not a boring tri colour. 6/10

[Wormfodder Delivery]

It's quite a busy flag but I rate it along the 5 rules first.

1. Keep It Simple. The flag should be so simple that a child can draw it from memory.
2. Use Meaningful Symbolism. The flag's images, colors, or patterns should relate to what it symbolizes.
3. Use 2 or 3 Basic Colors. Limit the number of colors on the flag to three which contrast well and come from the standard color set.
4. No Lettering or Seals. Never use writing of any kind or an organization's seal.
5. Be Distinctive or Be Related. Avoid duplicating other flags, but use similarities to show connections.

1. Keep it simple: Absolute failure in that regard, it's highly complicated and not something a child could draw, even an adult would have problems with it.
2. Use Meaningful Symbolism: I guess that does apply here.
3. Use 2 or 3 Basic Colors: High failure, even without the gradient in the logo, the blue and purple lack any meaningful contrast, but the gradient is an absolute no-go.
4. No Lettering or Seals:The Emblem breaks that rule already.
5. Be distinctive or Be Related: Well, it's certainly distinctive.

So, ultimately I give it a 2/10. For a flag, it's really bad.

[Roegerland]

2/10

It hurts my eyes. The colour palette is really not appealing in the slightest, I do like the Light Infantry style horn though.

[Somiens-et-Haveras]

That's a great flag. The extra white space between the southern cross and the tricolor is a subtle touch, but adds a lot. 10/10.

[Invadilism]

It's quite perfect, colors, simplicity, distinctiveness, all there.
10/10

[San Sonada]

8/10 it is good

[Soviet Koreya]

4/10, you could maybe cut off the white border on the left side of the flag and/or find a slightly higher quality picture

[Potenzia]

3/10, the lines are uneven and it could be cleaner.

[Aellwynn]

The ripple effect sadly diminishes the flag's design, which is quote beautiful and majestic. The coat of arms is very nicely designed and well-placed on the flag. The colours work well together, although perhaps a slightly brighter shade of red would make the whole appear less dark.

Overall, very nice flag design. A 8/10!

[Enzonar]

10/10 This flag turns complexity into compatibility. Easily one of the best flags on Nationstates.

[Aquyia]

7/10 for me, it's very simple but very nice to look at and follows the rules, although I can't see that flying as a flag.
also, that symbol makes me think of an alternate universe version of ben 10

[Bronchadia]

5/10. The choice to use an orange + blue colour scheme seems like something that could work well with a more conventional design, like a Tricolour with white. And I think the angled stripe with the circle is a good design. However, the combination of the two makes your flag look rather tacky. If I was to want to improve your flag, I'd either change the design or the colour scheme and maybe make the circle into some sort of logo / coat-of-arms rather than just a blank circle.

If you'd want inspiration, Brazil's flag does the logo / coat-of-arms thing rather uniquely and suits the mood well.

[Huosheng]

8/10

For what I can understand after a glance of Bronchadia, the flag represents what the user was going for when making the nation. Just a classic nordic cross, which is reinforced by the nation's motto and politics. Also, yellow and green is a really rare combination, making for a more unique flag. Though, this is slightly dampened by the fact there there are no symbols/coat of arms to enhance the cross, so it still seems a little generic. Overall, simplicity works well a lot of the time, and I believe that flags are a lot better if they represent the politics and earth-adjacent location they'd be from, which Bronchadia's flag achieves.

[Arathane]

Not a fan of the yellow borders for the canton.. and the ratio of it is just a turn off. If done right, it can look nice like Qatar but not this one.. 3/10

[The H Corporation]

I really don't like the flag is mostly red and the figure in the center is black and then changes back to red. I am not really a fan of red and black being mixed up together but I think it could be done better if the design was remade

4/10

[San Sonada]

its more a logo
0/10

[Arathane]

I really really like this one. Not only does it look very much like a US state flag (which can be a bit boring tbh but your crest makes up for it) but also the left side with the bearings is a nice touch. 10/10

[The H Corporation]

That's a great improvement of the flag, maybe the figures/emblems/coat can be smaller, but overall a great flag.

7.5/10

[Random Country 453632]

Looks very well done, and the H is very graphically excellent. However, it includes text, which shouldn't be in a flag. Keep the big H though. I also like the 3 stars above the H.

(also I like memes)

7.8/10

[The State of Moultrie]

Hurts my eyes a bit, but Objectively a good design.
8/10.

[Wiolgopomorska]

8/10. Quite distinctive, the color combination is perfect, and using a palm tree on a flag is quite unique. Not the most appealing to me personally, but it is still a grand flag.

[Random Country 453632]

6.5/10. The colors are too bright, and the dragon thing is too complex and detailed. Don't really like it

[Arathane]

Really really cool. One of my favorite flags is Greenland so I approve of it. 8/10