Constructively rate the above nation's flag (8)

[Greater Liyue]

Love it!

I don't see that shade of green much.

Black background is very ominous and intimidating.

Their symbol is an excellent emblem for their military.

10/10

-Ningguang, Tianquan of Liyue

[The H Corporation]

The symbol is nice and clean, engulfed in a dark color which makes it even better. 9/10

[Azania-]

I would remove the text, as it makes it look too much like the flag of a corporation (though that may be your intention now that I think about it). I'd also remove the stars and the horizontal stripes for simplicity's sake. The black and gold contrast very well, so I see no reason to change the colour scheme. Overall, 5/10.

[Rivogna]

It is a wonderfully done flag, but I recommend making the rays of the sun more visible. 8/10!

[The H Corporation]

Cool flag you got there, 8/10, the addition of the star seems a bit off but overall well done

[Wiolgopomorska]

Honestly a perfect design for a corporate emblem, 10/10. As a flag of a nation per se, the text (except for the H counting as an emblem) should probably be removed, but otherwise still a 9/10.

[THE Grob]

Color choices fit together well and do not put strain on the eyes, national animal seems to fit in with the general style/aesthetic (slavic or celtic? not entirely sure) of the nation. Very well done, simplistic without being boring, and tells you everything you need to know. 9/10.

[Transnatia]

7/10 | Steps to greatness:
1.) Remove the gradient effect
2.) simplify the emblem
3.) maybe remove the emblem border?

[The H Corporation]

7/10

I personally hate the blend between red and black and the flame should have a different color

[Enzonar]

3/10
That's a logo, not a flag. No text would be good.

[Invadilism]

8/10
It's distinctive, doesn't break any of the rules and works fine.
Would maybe make it a bit more interesting to look at, but it is fine as it is.

[Camplings]

7/10 good symbolism and unique design, but the shade of green is a bit unpleasant and the jagged edges are a bit too fine of a detail

[Tremulo]

10/10. Very distinctive choice of color and a symbol. Reminds me of the flags of Japanese prefectures.

[The H Corporation]

Not really unique. But its simplistic design is good for the eye. 8/10

[THE Grob]

7/10 | Steps to greatness:
1.) Remove the gradient effect
2.) simplify the emblem
3.) maybe remove the emblem border?

The Emblem Border is supposed to resemble the Grox's cybernetic eye, but I guess that's not apparent with the gradient . I have one without it somewhere.
/skipme

[Esperantistenland]

Not really unique. But its simplistic design is good for the eye. 8/10

Interesting & unique choice to incorporate the H as a logo-like emblem, and it looks neat, but... Everything else in the flag is just okay.
The biggest issue is the text, which should never, NEVER be used on flags. They work for corporate logos, but not flags! As many people say, "Show, don't tell."
Instead of having this design, consider incorporating the H as a recognizable logo on a simplified flag, like Walmart's. Anybody can look at that, and go "Wow, hey! That's the H corporation!" without having to be told directly that it's supposed to be that.
The golden/metallic stars are very out of place with the rest of the flag, and the contrast between the black, yellow, and white and the sudden inclusion of a softer color is offputting. Consider removing them altogether, or change their color to fit in with the general colorscheme.

[Huosheng]

Nice use of the green black white color scheme. It's a fairly underappreciated palette for flags. It gives off a vibe of either a nationalist country or a monarchist one, unsure what you were going for. The horizontal tricolor is an overused format, but if it works it works. Overall it's decent

[Nordeameriko]

8.5/10

I really enjoy the overall design. I do think the double-headed eagle could be bigger.

[The H Corporation]

9/10

Good flag

[Bigpipstan]

I would remove the text but otherwise it fits the corporate asthetic well.

[Aquyia]

6/10 it's a well-made flag, the colors are nice and I could see that in a fantasy world but I feel it's a too complicated and the pixel art in the flag doesn't fit very well, feels a little bit cluttered

[Transnatia]

Nice design, but those colors burn my eyes. 3/10

[WonderMart]

10/10 Superb. You've done it. Striking proportions that pay careful homage to the elements and principles of design, terrific balance, good colour choice, ideal contrast, and great consideration for simplicity when it comes to recreation. The symbol is unique, identifiable, and scalable at varying distances. Lovely.

[Roegerland]

10/10

I believe I've said before, but I absolutely love this while nation idea let alone the flag.

[The H Corporation]

10/10 lovely design and the colors are nice