Constructively rate the above nation's flag (8)

[DeMoNiC sAtAn]

Stonk's back at the eye-killing game but got an upgrade!
10/10

[Hiltshire]

Why he cute tho

10/10

[Buhers]

No rock. 6/10.

[Hiltshire]

No rock. 6/10.

My country is literally
S W O R D

We don’t need a stone on our flag.
/skipme

[Buhers]

My country is literally
S W O R D
We don’t need a stone on our flag.
/skipme

Where you gon' pull that sword from?

[Hiltshire]

My country is literally
S W O R D
We don’t need a stone on our flag.
/skipme

Where you gon' pull that sword from?

Bought it in a shop. And because you forgot to say /skipme, that is a response to your own flag.
/skipme

[Buhers]

Bought it in a shop. And because you forgot to say /skipme, that is a response to your own flag.
/skipme

I don't needa put no /skipme when I'm literally the last poster.
/stillme

[Intergalactic Colonization Project]

20/10
Yes, I have nothign to say

[Safiloa]

The only issues are the green-on-blue wreath, which acts more of a distraction AND the accompanying issue of the flower not being centered within the cross, which makes it look messy and unorganized.
Colors, patterns, and symbolism are otherwise all there and clear.
7.5/10

[The Steam-Gardens]

9/10

I don't really have any issues with it but the pattern between red & turquoise is a bit weird. It's fine, though. Great flag!

[Sanasalia]

Why is some kind of bitcoin symbol I assume hovering in a semicircle above a pine tree.
4/10, much room for improvement, but I like the pine tree

[The Steam-Gardens]

Why is some kind of bitcoin symbol I assume hovering in a semicircle above a pine tree.
4/10, much room for improvement, but I like the pine tree

The bitcoin symbol is basically the national currency.
Pine is the national plant.
Also, the five currencies represent the five states of the nation including the municipality, just to make the symbolism clear.

Anyways, I'll do yours now.

0/10 - It's basically the LGBTQ+ flag with the Turkmen moon and a Taiwanese sun slapped next to each other. Looks terrible and the contrast is nonexistent between the symbols and the base. Unless satirical or not serious intentionally, I recommend making a new flag from scratch ASAP.

[Decnotixa]

Why is some kind of bitcoin symbol I assume hovering in a semicircle above a pine tree.
4/10, much room for improvement, but I like the pine tree

6.8/10; definitely a questionable nation, while the flag kinda sucks i appreciate the fact that this nation shows care for democracy and for its people(even if in a weird way with the sortition policy); while the factbooks are all pretty basic and without any of Testlandia’s famous codes I still appreciate the fact that they seem to be written with some passion, i also like the fact that something like 3/4 of the economy is directly jurisdicted by the government (which is an hard achievement to get). Overall, good nation to live in, and while not perfect it’s definitely decent enough to look at

[Amogias]

so much going on in the flag, i like it

9.2/10

[Ojiyo]

so much going on in the flag, i like it

9.2/10

Relatively simple, gets across the assumed futuristic aesthetic well.

9.4/10

[Forden]

It is essentially the flag of Ohio, but judging from your name, I'm sure that was intended.

9/10

[Intergalactic Colonization Project]

6/10
Please center the symbol, anyway pretty good flag

[The Steam-Gardens]

8/10

Solid flag! It reminds me of Greece's revolutionary flag, and that's my only issue. But it's fine as it is.

[Terran American Republic]

7/10
As a Super Mario Odyssey fan myself, I'm a bit biased, 'cause I love seeing flags for all the Kingdoms. The design is simple, recognizable, and easy on the eyes. Just gotta dock a few points for the ripple effect, which sucks

[The Steam-Gardens]

7/10
As a Super Mario Odyssey fan myself, I'm a bit biased, 'cause I love seeing flags for all the Kingdoms. The design is simple, recognizable, and easy on the eyes. Just gotta dock a few points for the ripple effect, which sucks

Alright! Fixed it.
I'll do yours.

8/10 - Great take on the American flag! There are two small issues:

1) The emblem/eagle with the stars around it looks too big. Try making the blue rectangle more square.

2) It could have been a bit different from the modern USA flag. I personally would have preferred the blue rectangle covering the left side top-to-bottom and the eagle being in the middle of that. The current one's still good, though, so if you don't have the time, you can keep its general design as it is.

[New Stonkopolis]

Surprisingly simple Mare.
Very, very simple.
Love the aesthetic too.

9/10

[Buhers]

Sometimes ubiquity makes a flag good. Stonk's flags are always alien in concept and design, but never work out aesthetically. The shape is weird, the colors contrast poorly, and the symbolism is negligible at best. I don't have any suggestions other than a complete redesign, unfortunately.
4/10

BN, do not mindlessly praise my flag, like so many others've done. This is the constructive criticism thread, not a feel-good thread made for users to fellate or bash others.

[Volhyna]

10/10. I like the dot that sticks out from the others, the colour on the sides, the unique colorings, and even the detailed circle. Very good flag, and the circle kind of feels like a planet (its literally a KSP nation so yeah).

[Ugunnustan]

A solid 8/10.

Although ti might just be me but It looks slightly of-centre? IDK maybe my eyesigh is just off.

[Past beans]

6/10
It’s fun to look at but the way it looks like 2 flags on top of each other feels wrong.