Your thoughts on AN?

[The Aquaria]

Bendicion is a type of F7ers that might not always appear in my sight, but they usually do a decent quality of posts. I think they are probably one of the main reason F7 is wonderful.

[Mets Hayk]

Well, would you look at this! Could it finally be - a nation with a sliver of effort put into it? Well, it sure seems that way!

You know, despite the obvious fact that The Aquaria is just one of the many socialist nations on this website; at the very least he TRIES to make it slightly bit more unique than most. A good plethora of his factbooks have some pretty decent images and are rather informative, unlike most others'. I do, however, have a few issues:

Some of your factbooks are clearly unfinished. Please, do take the time to thoroughly complete them; I'm sure they'll turn out pretty good!

I'm not the fan of *insert anime character here* representing a nation's politicians; as it kinda makes it hard to, you know, suspend my disbelief that they could co-exist with say, someone who's using a picture of King Ferdinand I of Romania (as I am). This is even more so apparent when you use a character from an anime about having some sort of magical bullshit (or so I think).

So, despite a few factbooks needing some work; I think The Aquaria's a relatively decent enough nation. Keep it up!

[New Zoigai]

Seems chill.

Goddamn it.

Well, would you look at this! Could it finally be - a nation with a sliver of effort put into it? Well, it sure seems that way!

You know, despite the obvious fact that The Aquaria is just one of the many socialist nations on this website; at the very least he TRIES to make it slightly bit more unique than most. A good plethora of his factbooks have some pretty decent images and are rather informative, unlike most others'. I do, however, have a few issues:

Some of your factbooks are clearly unfinished. Please, do take the time to thoroughly complete them; I'm sure they'll turn out pretty good!

I'm not the fan of *insert anime character here* representing a nation's politicians; as it kinda makes it hard to, you know, suspend my disbelief that they could co-exist with say, someone who's using a picture of King Ferdinand I of Romania (as I am). This is even more so apparent when you use a character from an anime about having some sort of magical bullshit (or so I think).

So, despite a few factbooks needing some work; I think The Aquaria's a relatively decent enough nation. Keep it up!

Ah its the Armenian nation who doesnt meet their own standards.

Seems nothing much has changed about them, Their factbooks still the same. Not much of a worthy read. I dont plan on copying and pasting what
I said last time but my opinion hasnt changed on them. An alt-history nation that has been done better. If you want to say its unique because its Armenia I am not agianst that.

[Diarcesia]

Seems chill.

Goddamn it.

Well, would you look at this! Could it finally be - a nation with a sliver of effort put into it? Well, it sure seems that way!

You know, despite the obvious fact that The Aquaria is just one of the many socialist nations on this website; at the very least he TRIES to make it slightly bit more unique than most. A good plethora of his factbooks have some pretty decent images and are rather informative, unlike most others'. I do, however, have a few issues:

Some of your factbooks are clearly unfinished. Please, do take the time to thoroughly complete them; I'm sure they'll turn out pretty good!

I'm not the fan of *insert anime character here* representing a nation's politicians; as it kinda makes it hard to, you know, suspend my disbelief that they could co-exist with say, someone who's using a picture of King Ferdinand I of Romania (as I am). This is even more so apparent when you use a character from an anime about having some sort of magical bullshit (or so I think).

So, despite a few factbooks needing some work; I think The Aquaria's a relatively decent enough nation. Keep it up!

Ah its the Armenian nation who doesnt meet their own standards.

Seems nothing much has changed about them, Their factbooks still the same. Not much of a worthy read. I dont plan on copying and pasting what
I said last time but my opinion hasnt changed on them. An alt-history nation that has been done better. If you want to say its unique because its Armenia I am not agianst that.

Seems chill, but not that chill.

I get the impression that New Zoigai is another FFT multiversal realm that morbs stomps on everyone who dares challenge them. Factbooks are majority heavily-WIP and haven't found anything that stands out yet... except that trying to represent their territory into something mere humans can understand is an exercise in futility and madness.

[The-Rapture-Republic]

Despite seeing Diacresia frequently on this site and occasionally responding to his posts like on the leader thread. I have relatively little to really express about him. That isn’t intended to say I find him dull. It’s just I don’t know very much about him, and extends to his nation which could use more development to be fully freshen out. That would resolve this problem, added if chosen, to talk or join a server to interact with each other or by chance, end up in the same roleplay. The latter being simply more realistic despite potentially being very low. Overall, Diacresia has shown to be nice person when he posts and never seems to provoke anyone.

[Perikuresu]

Honestly, I'd say neutral and AN is a chill person but it'd be a shame to just slap someone who I see puts some effort into their posts with that so I'll elaborate further on first impressions + others. Honestly, when I first saw the nation, it gave me the Combined Syndicates of America vibes, i've no idea why but maybe that thing in the middle looked very similar to the Kaiserreich CSA fan flag with the Statue of Liberty in the centre. Overall, I'm glad I was wrong, cause looking thru your factbooks the concept of a person who escaped the USSR and became a mogul who basically built Atlantis during the Cold War is SUCH AN INTERESTING IDEA and there's so much detail and effort added into it, right now, the overview factbook is my favourite, although that's not to say any of your other ones are just as good, it's that I'm personally not attracted towards character or military focused factbook. Overall, I'm excited to see what you add onto the nation the next time I see it, and I'll take time reading the overview (and taking notes for my own nation)

[The Aquaria]

Oh hello there.

Perikuresu isn’t a nation I will always be able to interact with. Seems they focus a lot more on a different thread, which has no evidence of my existence, and I rarely see him in the threads I usually post. However, I can tell that they spend their time making an F7 post with decent quality and length.

From what I have seen in their factbook, I can also tell that he definitely spent a lot of time on improving it. I usually only look at their overview when I enter a page of a nation, but gosh, Perikuresu's overview is already 2.5x bigger than mine.

Well, I guess I can check the Anarchy RP out.

[The Huterric Union]

I cant say an awful lot but I get the sense they would work alongside the Huterric Union incredibly well both as trade partners and military allies in its canon. I respect their socialist ideology a lot.

[Karazicu]

Factbooks are very incomplete, and rather bare. Your overview factbook is seemingly a collection of answers to some surveys in F&NI threads, and doesn't exactly stand out too well. I will give you props for trying to make a language of your own for your nation, though.

[Broader Confederate States]

Karazicu is... terrifyingly realistic. I mean, obviously there's enough plot convenience that it's... helped along to where it is now, that's just a convention of storytelling and it's kind of a necessity, but I could genuinely see that happening the same way it had. Which... honestly, is so depressing that my hand is forced and I have to give it a recommendation, even if I wish there was way more detail. But then, I suppose it doesn't really matter, since I know about as much about it as I do about most other countries on that continent. In that way, being vague probably helps it to feel real, but I really do think that it could exist in a timeline not very far removed from our own. The travel guide especially really cinches it -- it's kind of condensed, but that's understandable, especially if it's more of a long brochure than an encyclopedia.

[Laka Strolistandiler]

Theyre an interesting take on a matter which was previously done countless times both on this site and elsewhere (I swear I’ve seen like 4 Confederate states in a single Russian RP once lol), however them admitting the wrongs of the real confederation OTL and the author focusing more on the libertarian elements is what sets AN ultimately apart from all of these confederate AH’s. Moreover than that their lore which is detailed but not extremely hard to read through, like in some other cases here also earns them a couple of points

[Trivalve]

I know I say this to a lot of people but I like to congratulate people on it, you have put and excellent amount of effort into your factbook which were interesting and fun to read. Nation wise your civil rights and political freedoms could be better but that just my opinion, you do you. A few questionable policies but yet again, it your choice. Over all they have done a good job.

[East Plate]

Well, there is not much I can say about Trivalve. We seem to be focused on totally different aspects of NationStates. While they are more into regional gameplay and politics, I'm more of a nationbuilding and factbooks guy, so I can't really give an opinion on what they do, as I basically know nothing about that. Nonetheless, Trivalve seems to be a friendly and very sociable user, which probably explains why they are more interested in the regional gameplay.

Regarding your nation's lore, I have to agree with what others have already said in this thread. Your lore is not very developed, but you probably already know that. However, I'm quite sure that if you wanted to, you hace the potential to develop a very interesting nation.

[Bendicion]

Well, there is not much I can say about Trivalve. We seem to be focused on totally different aspects of NationStates. While they are more into regional gameplay and politics, I'm more of a nationbuilding and factbooks guy, so I can't really give an opinion on what they do, as I basically know nothing about that. Nonetheless, Trivalve seems to be a friendly and very sociable user, which probably explains why they are more interested in the regional gameplay.

Regarding your nation's lore, I have to agree with what others have already said in this thread. Your lore is not very developed, but you probably already know that. However, I'm quite sure that if you wanted to, you hace the potential to develop a very interesting nation.

Oh.My.Godness. The above nation must have one of the most amazing factbooks around there! Judging from this enthusiasm and attention to detail, one can only rightfully assume that East Plate is an avid lover of history. Not many people give such amazing factbooks, let alone such detail and intricacy.

You my friend are going a long way if you continue such work. I suggest you join a region that has an active roleplay activity. One that can help you even become bettre and also as an outlet for you to share your amazing factbooks!

Kudos once again!

[Black Raven Movement]

I apologize for the short post, as I have to conserve battery on my phone, but my thoughts were neutral, before taking a look at you. All I can say? You impress me. Your older factbooks are honestly the highest quality I've seen out of the era they were published in, and your current ones are, formatically, well done. In all, my thoughts about you are positive, and I can't wait for more stuff to release out of your name.

Kudos well deserved.

[Laka Strolistandiler]

You know what? I really like how they have essentially foresaw the current Russo-Ukrainian conflict long before I anything started to point towards it. Moreover than that, their take on a post-war Ukraine is a very good one, way better than quite a few examples I’ve seen on this side. If anything, now I want to see one thing- an independent Donbass!

[Romanic Imperium]

You know what? I really like how they have essentially foresaw the current Russo-Ukrainian conflict long before I anything started to point towards it. Moreover than that, their take on a post-war Ukraine is a very good one, way better than quite a few examples I’ve seen on this side. If anything, now I want to see one thing- an independent Donbass!

Laka! I've been wanting to do this on you. But anyways I love how you have a character Factbook dedicated to f7. I've never seen this before and it's really interesting. Your military factbooks are very informative and are always a good read. Every factbook you have is really detailed. I do have a few complaints though. One is the F7 character list it's kinda a mess.. Two is the fact that you keep changing your flag, other than that all good.

[The Holy Britainnian Empire]

They have a good number of factbooks, though some of them are short in info. They seem to still be developing, but I'd like to see how their story go.

[Karazicu]

This nation just isn't really good. You've got the concept of this essentially being a futuristic variant of the Roman Empire complete with all the space shenanigans that I don't find too original nor that great, and there isn't exactly a lot to distinguish it. Then, there is Jaguar Aquilion, one of my least favorite bits, who is just really poorly written, and honestly seems like some kind of Percy Jackson self-insert OC. Factbooks are extremely bare and contain barely anything, and I don't really find the stuff within them to be that interesting. Overall, I don't think this is really a good nation, and you should really try to write more stuff in them, and while you're at it perhaps you can add some more stuff to make it more unique and less terrible.

Ninja'd, hold up a second.

So, this nation is a Code Geass based nation? Don't watch that show, or really any sort of anime, so my judgement here might be a little bit off. Anyways, I have to say that this feels like a fairly standard monarchy of sorts which I am generally not fond of considering we already have way too many of those, although there are indeed some elements that set it apart from the rest of the generic European monarchies, like the Geass stuff I suppose, but even so I still feel like more could be done. Not quite sure what the nation is supposed to be since the few factbooks that you have don't exactly go too far into detail about what this nation is like, although I suppose I'd have to watch Code Geass in order to know that. Factbooks have decent detail and comprehensive formatting, though I still have to say that they are a little barebones, a little lacking. So, I will say that this could be interesting, there is promise behind this nation, perhaps some fleshing out of your nation would do this nation good.

[Karazicu]

Just going to /bump this up real quick. Also, /stillme.

[Nordic Peoples Reich]

They're a chad

[The Aquaria]

Karazicu... When I think about him, an image of some Pinochet flashback comes.

Well, there are capitalist and communist nations in NationStates, but for me, it is quite rare to see a nation which is simply a military junta. Not saying it is bland, but it is unique when things go like that. You also have detailed factbooks to describe your nation. From the judgement by me regarding the language and religion, is it based on Bosnia?

The user is a chill one who does not judge people by their political ideology and can have a conversation. Their post qualities are also decent, which we can see in his previous post.

Overall, quite a decent person.

---

Breh, ninja’d.

The Nordic People Reich is somebody I have only seen recently. Since I interact with them for few-to-none time, I pretty much have no thoughts. Neutral.

Though,

Seems it is Finland but fascist?

[The Aquaria]

/bump

/stillme

[Drongonia]

A fresh but pleasant face on the forums, with very well written and fleshed out set of factbooks. What's not to love? Besides the communism, unless you're into that sort of thing

[Frisemark]

Drongonia is genuinely probably my favorite "realistic" MT nation. Everything about it is believable, it's factbooks are awesome, it's writing is top-tier and overall the aesthetics and graphic design are genuinely some of the best on the website in my opinion. It's a double whammy considering the dude behind the nation is super nice and cool too.