Constructively Rate the flag above you: VII

[Astoriya]

8/10, although the fleur-de-lises may be a bit of a pain to draw

[Vadterland]

7/10. Good colors, good design, but basic and unremarkable.

Here's the base flag, though I really shouldn't have to do this.

[Gowinia]

7.5/10 - Would be great without all that anime

[Zitravgrad]

6.5/10

Too dark... methinks.

[Nitrona]

6.5/10

Too dark... methinks.

Nice colours, but the bit on the left is a bit much in my opinion. Perhaps better with a simpler pattern or even a solid colour. Can’t fault the rest though!
9/10

[Astoriya]

7/10

[Sapnu puas]

7/10

Simple but only that. 5/10

[Arkhadiam]

Not even a flag mate 0/10

[Draos]

Not even a flag mate 0/10

while the Vulture is a unique touch the writing really takes away from the flag 4/10

[Vadterland]

9/10. It’s fairly simple with a good choice of colors and design. Green is almost a novelty on flags these days, but it’s done well on this one.

Here's Vadterland’s flag without the waifu. Don’t be obnoxious.

[Astoriya]

7/10 for overtly complicated emblem

[Equalsun Empire]

New thread, new rating: 5/10, good colours with the bare minimum of complexity.

[Gowinia]

9/10 - excellent flag, the rotating cog is a nice touch

[Valehart]

9/10 awesome flag, love the colours personally. Very unique layout

[Astoriya]

7.9/10

[Gordfield]

Pretty nice looking and overall quite nice
Could maybe use something more but I quite like it
8.5/10

[Priobalslavia]

Very nice, also very simple. A tiny bit more complexity could perhaps make it look slightly more iconic, however, as is, i'd say it still gets a solid 7.3/10

[Anglomir]

0/10 not a flag

[Captiotia]

8/10 It's very distinctive and simple, some of the features might be too small though.

[Anglomir]

7/10, would like to see some more colour. Sorry for double post, feel free to double post me Captiotia as I just changed my flag

[Captiotia]

10/10 This hits all of my good flag design spots and I can't find anything I dislike about it, maybe the crosses should be centered in their regions, probably not.

[Valentine Z]

8/10

Very good design, and is pleasing to look at all around! Looks a little similar to Cuba, but that's okay!

[Dragonia Re Xzua]

Fits the theme of the nation, plus the circle looks a little intricate.

Sadly, it is also, overall, over-simplistic for my tastes.

6.7/10

[Anglomir]

0/10 yee

[Valentine Z]

I personally prefer the older flag, but hey, this one works in your favor as well!

I would give it a 9/10, because design wise, it's fantastic. Just that I'm not sure what the target things are supposed to be for.