Constructively rate the above nation's flag (8)

[Eeumeria]

2/10

Very cluttered and covered in writing, which is two things I think a flag should not be.

Although the aspect ration reminds me more of a coat of arms, the design is outstanding. Simple, eye-pleasing, and unique. 10/10

[Islamic Holy Sites]

9/10
I would prefer a solid black instead of grey, but it is unique and the logo in the middle is great

[Faro and The Algarve]

I’d say it’s a 3.5/5, the red on the right of the beige should be transparent in my opinion.

[The Steam-Gardens]

It's a 6/10 for me.

Although you can't really mess up a simple tricolor, I have two issues with the flag. The shade of green clashes with the red & is too dark, and there is a ripple effect. I would personally replace the green with white and remove the ripple.

[Rairundya]

It's a 6/10 for me.

Although you can't really mess up a simple tricolor, I have two issues with the flag. The shade of green clashes with the red & is too dark, and there is a ripple effect. I would personally replace the green with white and remove the ripple.

I love it! Nice mountains!

[The Steam-Gardens]

It's a 6/10 for me.

Although you can't really mess up a simple tricolor, I have two issues with the flag. The shade of green clashes with the red & is too dark, and there is a ripple effect. I would personally replace the green with white and remove the ripple.

I love it! Nice mountains!

Can you give it a rating out of ten, please? Thanks
/skipme

[Rehy]

It's a 6/10 for me.

Although you can't really mess up a simple tricolor, I have two issues with the flag. The shade of green clashes with the red & is too dark, and there is a ripple effect. I would personally replace the green with white and remove the ripple.

I love it! Nice mountains!

7/10 The southern cross is too close to the top. Ripple effect is a no.

[Exarkyon]

I love it! Nice mountains!

7/10 The southern cross is too close to the top. Ripple effect is a no.

Interesting insignia. It doesn't look like it's supposed to be a flag. It would look good on a bicolor background, I think.

Not a flag, but 7/10 because it doesn't look anything close to bad.

[Islamic Holy Sites]

6/10, the grey and the diamond is messing it up. I would switch the white and black, remove the diamond and make the cross thicker

[Ankuran]

6/10 - It's coming along, but it's not quite there yet. The sunrays are too close to the edges of the yellow, so either the emblem needs to shrink a bit, or the band on the left needs to shrink and the emblem move left. It might also be novel to get rid of the red field on the fly entirely and have a swallowtail-type flag shape.

(All this is assuming a dexter hoist; I read somewhere once that Arabic flags are typically designed for a sinister hoist.)

[Uinted Communist of Africa]

6/10 - It's coming along, but it's not quite there yet. The sunrays are too close to the edges of the yellow, so either the emblem needs to shrink a bit, or the band on the left needs to shrink and the emblem move left. It might also be novel to get rid of the red field on the fly entirely and have a swallowtail-type flag shape.

(All this is assuming a dexter hoist; I read somewhere once that Arabic flags are typically designed for a sinister hoist.)

9/10
though i love the design of it i cant get behind that color scheme.
It needs to pop against the blue sky and draw either ire or hope. I dont feel it does that with such a deep blue(?)

[Islamic Holy Sites]

5/10
Maybe remove the black border around Africa, switch the yellow and red, make Africa smaller and in the middle and move the hammer and sickle to the top left corner. Or, if you want to, move the small Africa map to the top left corner and keep the hammer and sickle big and in the middle

[Carter Kayden and Ken]

10/10

I love the unique colors. It would have been easy to grab the stock red and yellow in PhotoShop, but these more subdued hues tell a story. The yellow/gold makes me think of aged linen. This, paired with the symbols and the asymmetrical stripes make me think of a warm setting in an arid country.

[Merulla]

Childish and unprofessional.
-50/10

[The Tripolis]

simple use of colours and symbol. its relly creative and easy to draw. it reminds me of water



8/10

[The Antarctic Sphere]

Too bland and simple. Find a pattern that best suits your nation's culture and integrate that into your flag to give it some finesse. In the meantime...

2.9/10

[Islamic Holy Sites]

6.4/10

A bit too complicated. Maybe replace the little stars with stripes, and make the lower part of the lion blue so it doesn’t blend in with the background.

[Random Country 453632]

While the stripe on the left is a little off-putting, the rest of the flag is quite nice. I dig the red gold color scheme very much. 8.5/10

[Unified Republics]

7.5/10, I feel like the bright yellow's uneven placement (not by size or arrangement but by what parts are colored yellow in proportion to the rest of the flag) with respect to the well-matching black and red is a bit garish, and could look better if it simply used two colors or found a way to better incorporate yellow.

[Unogonduria]

8.7/10, the black look really cool on AN's flag.

[Twenty Community]

7/10

The flag is kinda weird because the yellow in the orthodox cross isn't the same as the canton (the flag in the left side) but it not a good or bad flag in general.

[Holy Islamia]

Automatic 10/10 swallowtail flags are always based

[Merulla]

The colors are ok, they are dark but they contrast with each other.
A weapon, a super complex design, in the middle of the flag is not a good idea.
Things written on a flag are always a bad idea.
The flag's proportions are a little weird, but it's acceptable.

I would say 4.5/10.

[Boneville]

9/10
I love where the trident is at on the flag, so good!
and i like the way the stripes are layed out.

[Applicatia]

5/10. The color scheme of blue-green-orange is garish and the way that the green interior doesn't fill the entire star is unsatisfying