Commend the Gunshine State

[Coronational Chechyans and affiliates]

Hello I was recommended to post this here.






Acknowledging The Gunshine State as a young but thriving region;

Further acknowledging the Gunshine State as the first Frontier to ever be featured. A monumental event in Nationstates history.;

Even further acknowledging that as a consequence of being featured this region was raided and the natives expelled. However the nations called for help and managed to get defended by the Rejected Realms Army. Who returned the region to the natives and cast out the invaders.

Believing the Security Council should not hesitate in commending such a notable Region;



This is my first attempt at one of these as you can probably tell

[Space beans]

I don't see how being raided makes a region more commendable.
And the only notable thing about this region is that it was featured.

[Eternal Algerstonia]

Full support.

[Astrobolt]

Not a commendable nominee.

[Bhang Bhang Duc]

Nothing Commendable here. Possibly illegal for the reference to being featured - that is an aspect of the game NationStates, so R2(a).

Edit: Missed the obvious illegality - it doesn’t have an operative clause.

[Nova Vinelandia]

If anything we should commend Sparkalia for their incredible op. Sure Gunshine was the first frontier to be featured, but we were the first raiders to raid a featured frontier and surely that's worth something .

[Coronational Chechyans and affiliates]

If anything we should commend Sparkalia for their incredible op. Sure Gunshine was the first frontier to be featured, but we were the first raiders to raid a featured frontier and surely that's worth something .

That's the next proposal

[Coronational Chechyans and affiliates]

https://www.nationstates.net/page=UN_vi ... mission=ok

Fixed to have an operative clause. Also I would like to hear from a mod if featured is illegal. It's a tag after all why would it not be considered fair play for commendation or condemnation

[Bhang Bhang Duc]

If anything we should commend Sparkalia for their incredible op. Sure Gunshine was the first frontier to be featured, but we were the first raiders to raid a featured frontier and surely that's worth something .

That's the next proposal

Oh wonderful. Another crappy badge hunt.

[Endorse]

You can hear Bhang Bhang Duc's skin peeling off as we speak in this thread.

This is obviously never going to fly, maybe get to the queue because anything can get to the queue. As long as its legal.

[Nova Vinelandia]

If anything we should commend Sparkalia for their incredible op. Sure Gunshine was the first frontier to be featured, but we were the first raiders to raid a featured frontier and surely that's worth something .

That's the next proposal

Amazing.

[0cala]

It could be Rabbit season or Duck season, but its not Badge hunt season.

[United Calanworie]

"being featured" is a 2a violation -- referring to game mechanics. I highly recommend consulting the SC rules before continuing to draft this proposal.

[Tinhampton]

"being featured" is a 2a violation -- referring to game mechanics.

Commend The Quote of the Day (and its repeal), Commend The Featured Region Followers, Commend Paffnia and both Commend One Small Islands acknowledge that regions can be featured. When did this change?

[Wrapper]

Nothing Commendable here. Possibly illegal for the reference to being featured - that is an aspect of the game NationStates, so R2(a).

Ahem....

[Sedgistan]

Yeah, we've had a few resolutions mention featured regions; it's another "unique aspect of the NationStates world", and legal to mention.

[Bhang Bhang Duc]

Nothing Commendable here. Possibly illegal for the reference to being featured - that is an aspect of the game NationStates, so R2(a).

Ahem....

I did emphasise “Possibly” - the old fourth wall/NS as a game is often hard to adjudicate.

Anyway looks like Sedge has taken the view that it’s legal, so it moves back into the queue.

Was writing the above while Sedge was posting so it’s superfluous now.

Of course legal does not equal good and this draft is a classic example of that.

[Coronational Chechyans and affiliates]

I'm glad to see the status was changed. Being featured has been in multiple previous proposals so I wasn't sure why people bought it would be illegal.