Nova Vandalia wrote:Lenlyvit wrote:I'm not involved in XKI anymore.
Did you not just admit to having a nation there, still being on their forums and discord? Is your legacy not tied with theirs? Is writing a commendation for a region not "getting involved" by shoving them into a spotlight you have to defend and fight for? I mean last I checked most uninvolved people don't in fact have access to their forums or discords. Unless things have changes in which case I would like 1 access please.
And you really didn't stutter when you said ""If a member of a region writes a commendation for the region they're in, then that would be considered a self-commendation." to others. But obviously we should build in an exception for you?
But you know you're right it's "my" logic that is flawed.
Anyone researching a resolution for a region should have access to said regions forum and Discord to seek information, otherwise they won't find what they are looking for and need.
The Notorious Mad Jack wrote:Lenlyvit wrote:I would argue that the fact two other very successful regions modeled their government off of XKI, that they've extensively worked against feeder coups (including in TNP, where you are), that they've had a hand in multiple anti-fascist operations, and that they've continued protecting innocent regions for almost 18 years is warranting a second commendation.
And I would counter that XKI's long track record of attempting to undermine certain GCRs both publicly and privately, along with their unwarranted invasion of Osiris and the toxicity shown to a player who left XKI are all very good reasons why it might not even deserve one.
The XKI of 10 years ago was 1000 times worse than the XKI of today, and was commended twice. XKI has made leaps and bounds towards betterment of its community since Grub left, yet you're all afraid to admit that because you want to keep XKI as the defender boogeyman. I could argue that TNP has seemed toxic towards and chased out certain players from its community, it's not just one region George. Also, would you enlighten us all to the GCRs XKI has sought to undermine? I haven't heard anything about it, unless you want to discuss the raider and imperialist GCRs that attack innocent regions? Also, we all admit Osi wasn't a smart move on anyone's part, defender or raider or imperialist.
Edit: And no, I'm not calling TNP toxic. It's far from that.