[DRAFT] Condemn ANTIFA

[Kuriko]

This has gone from zero to one hundred really fast. It might be a good idea if some of you stepped away from the computers and/or phones for awhile >·>

[Kavagrad]

"No reason found" isn't the same as no reason existing. Have you considered asking someone involved what the justification for that raid was? May I suggest not making unproven claims until you actually have a shred of evidence for them?

sir, that's why this is in the forums. I want someone to tell me the story of those regions

You are making baseless claims with zero justification, and expecting Antifa organisers to respond to you? Sounds like a waste of time to me. If I were them, I wouldn't bother, and clearly they think the same way.

[WayNeacTia]

"No reason found" isn't the same as no reason existing. Have you considered asking someone involved what the justification for that raid was? May I suggest not making unproven claims until you actually have a shred of evidence for them?

sir, that's why this is in the forums. I want someone to tell me the story of those regions

So instead of asking, you write what is being charitably called a condemnation? The cart is so far out in front of the horse on this one, the horse will never catch up at this rate. I strenuously suggest you drop this and ask for a lock, lest this goes places you really don't want it to go.

[Israeli Empiratic Commonwealth]

This has gone from zero to one hundred really fast. It might be a good idea if some of you stepped away from the computers and/or phones for awhile >·>

I always support breaks from Forum debates, now is no different

[Israeli Empiratic Commonwealth]

sir, that's why this is in the forums. I want someone to tell me the story of those regions

So instead of asking, you write what is being charitably called a condemnation? The cart is so far out in front of the horse on this one, the horse will never catch up at this rate. I strenuously suggest you drop this and ask for a lock, lest this goes places you really don't want it to go.

Nope, sorry

[Marxist Germany]

OOC:This thread has been derailed a lot, I suggest everyone involved take a 10 minute break before posting again to avoid modly wrath

[Courelli]

I’d just like to point out that, in every operation, Antifa posts an RMB message explaining the justification for the raid. If you say that there is “no explanation,” it’s obvious you’re not even taking the time to check.

[Xoriet]

"you guys" I don't support what he did. And I do not align with him.

There viewtopic.php?f=12&t=467110&hilit=Antifa+fascist+pact
I hope i get your attention now

Lol, The Wolf Clan? Antifa? Yeah right.

[Israeli Empiratic Commonwealth]

I’d just like to point out that, in every operation, Antifa posts an RMB message explaining the justification for the raid. If you say that there is “no explanation,” it’s obvious you’re not even taking the time to check.

I looked.
"- Fascist Tag.
Embassies with:
- Farkasfalka
- The New Weimar Republic
- The Holy Reich of Bunicken"
Absolutely great justification there.

"Northern Redland held alliances with known Nazi/Fascist regions:
- region=the_coalition_of_fascist_nations
- region=confederation_of_corrupt_dictators
- region=9cord_anarcho_fascist_state
- region=the_augusto_pinochet_vengeance_force
- region=nazi_europa
- region=kaiserreich
- region=the_greater_nazi_empire
- region=the_union_of_the_axis_powers
- region=nationstates_white_genocide_memorial
- region=the_reich
Nations within Northern Redland have been mixed up with and even had nations deleted for creating and promoting Nazi Dispatches: page=rmb/postid=33682823
Concerning nation themes:
- nation=nationalist_german_fourth_reich
- nation=kekistanialand (Alt right)
- nation=nationalist_spanish_inquisition
Concerning RMB posts:
- page=rmb/postid=33553116
- page=rmb/postid=33434718
- page=rmb/postid=33327363"
Oh thats even better.
There is absolutely no justification for MAGA or Dakia

[Ransium]

Okay, stop right there. When you start saying stuff like that, that’s why people have a problem with you and others like you. Why would you say something like that?

Did I misunderstand what you said or did you misunderstand what I said?
When I was in exile in Farkasfalka there was 1 (yes only one, singular.) person, Kustonia, that I don't think believed Jews were human but eh. He denied it. Why would I? Because there is a serious increase of flamebaiting occurring and I am finding humor in it

At the risk of reinvigorating the conversation after it has swirled by, as others have said you can either bring it up in moderation or not at all, you don’t get to talk about it in the thread. Let’s all keep the thread on track (as much as possible) and not discuss this further, now.

[Israeli Empiratic Commonwealth]

Did I misunderstand what you said or did you misunderstand what I said?
When I was in exile in Farkasfalka there was 1 (yes only one, singular.) person, Kustonia, that I don't think believed Jews were human but eh. He denied it. Why would I? Because there is a serious increase of flamebaiting occurring and I am finding humor in it

At the risk of reinvigorating the conversation after it has swirled by, as others have said you can either bring it up in moderation or not at all, you don’t get to talk about it in the thread. Let’s all keep the thread on track (as much as possible) and not discuss this further, now.

With all due respect moderator, I was asked a question. I answered it to my truth. My apologies, it won't happen again.

[Israeli Empiratic Commonwealth]

I will be off nationstates for the rest of the day, save all responses until tomorrow.

[Courelli]

I’d just like to point out that, in every operation, Antifa posts an RMB message explaining the justification for the raid. If you say that there is “no explanation,” it’s obvious you’re not even taking the time to check.

*snip*
There is absolutely no justification for MAGA or Dakia

MAGA was not secured by Antifa, but by the MT Army — Antifa wasn’t involved.

Dakia’s RMB was wiped when Antifa refounded it — that’s standard game mechanics. Prior to the refound, there was a public RMB justification post, as is standard in Antifa operations.

[Wallenburg]

Raiding fascist regions is dehumanizing fascists now. Very cool comparing everyday R/D to real life genocide.

I agree, it is not dehumanizing. Fascists are not dehumanized per se on this site. More so, swept under the rug. Ignored, laughed at, attacked constantly, etc.

You can't simultaneously ignore something and attack it.

[Aclion]

OOC:That's not what I meant, the problem is that people are encouraging others to attack and destroy fascist regions, without even getting condemned because its seen as a heroic action.

That's a fair point. In old Nationstates, back when I was Klegspart you raid a lot and you will be condemned.

>Founded: 333 days ago
>Old Nationstates

[Bhang Bhang Duc]

At the risk of repeating points made by Armaros, Praeceps and Lord Dominator, here's my take on your attempt.

The Security Council;
Recognizing the extreme wrongdoing a region or nation must commit to receive condemnation;
Acknowledging that one region has such qualities of wrongdoing, Antifa;

Reasonable enough preamble.

Noting that Antifa is not a region on it's own, but an alliance of regions, including but not limited to: The Leftist Assembly, The Red Fleet, The Communist Bloc, and The MT Army;

However, you are trying to Condemn the region of Antifa, you've said so in the preamble and in the final operative clause. This clause, therefore, is irrelevant. Also I hate it when authors use "it's" when they should be using "its".

Proof of their intentions to destroy fascism is implanted everywhere and is well known.

Really? Actually if true then maybe you should be Commending them.

Understanding that this is not the worst part of Antifa, as the worst part is unjust raids against NON fascist regions

Badly constructed clause.

Appalled at Antifa for raiding, and provoking regions that are NOT fascist just for their affiliation or the belief in freedom of speech, including:

a. The Free Commonwealth A new region, raided due to their "Fascist" tag. They were absolutely not fascist.
b. Northern Redlands Libertarian-Right of Center region, raided for "concerning RMB posts".
c. Make America Great Again Conservative region, presumably raided for the wrong assumption that they are fascist.
d. League of the United Tribes of Dakia Not fascist, and no justification cited for raiding at all.

So in point a. a region flying the Fascist tag is definitely not fascist? Bit of stretch that. As for the other raids you've mentioned, no real detail just your assumptions.

Highlighting that these regions did nothing wrong to deserve a raid, other than disagree with principles of ANTIFA

And you know this how?

Noticing that Antifa openly or discreetly attacks ALL rightist regions as to fit the leftist and communist agenda of Antifa

All rightist regions? They must be very busy people.

Hereby condemns Antifa, a threat to peace in NationStates

A lot of poorly written rhetoric but not much detail.

Just a note about your claims to have evidence of hacking and doxxing. Any attempt to include those directly in this Condemnation would immediately make it illegal - see Rule 2.

[Kaboomlandia]

Author literally founded a region tagged as Fascist. Not suspicious motives at all.

[Dawtania]

Yet another poorly written WA proposal by a triggered fascist.

[Ransium]

At the risk of repeating points made by Armaros, Praeceps and Lord Dominator, here's my take on your attempt.

The Security Council;
Recognizing the extreme wrongdoing a region or nation must commit to receive condemnation;
Acknowledging that one region has such qualities of wrongdoing, Antifa;

Reasonable enough preamble.

Noting that Antifa is not a region on it's own, but an alliance of regions, including but not limited to: The Leftist Assembly, The Red Fleet, The Communist Bloc, and The MT Army;

However, you are trying to Condemn the region of Antifa, you've said so in the preamble and in the final operative clause. This clause, therefore, is irrelevant. Also I hate it when authors use "it's" when they should be using "its".

Proof of their intentions to destroy fascism is implanted everywhere and is well known.

Really? Actually if true then maybe you should be Commending them.

Understanding that this is not the worst part of Antifa, as the worst part is unjust raids against NON fascist regions

Badly constructed clause.

Appalled at Antifa for raiding, and provoking regions that are NOT fascist just for their affiliation or the belief in freedom of speech, including:

a. The Free Commonwealth A new region, raided due to their "Fascist" tag. They were absolutely not fascist.
b. Northern Redlands Libertarian-Right of Center region, raided for "concerning RMB posts".
c. Make America Great Again Conservative region, presumably raided for the wrong assumption that they are fascist.
d. League of the United Tribes of Dakia Not fascist, and no justification cited for raiding at all.

So in point a. a region flying the Fascist tag is definitely not fascist? Bit of stretch that. As for the other raids you've mentioned, no real detail just your assumptions.

Highlighting that these regions did nothing wrong to deserve a raid, other than disagree with principles of ANTIFA

And you know this how?

Noticing that Antifa openly or discreetly attacks ALL rightist regions as to fit the leftist and communist agenda of Antifa

All rightist regions? They must be very busy people.

Hereby condemns Antifa, a threat to peace in NationStates

A lot of poorly written rhetoric but not much detail.

Just a note about your claims to have evidence of hacking and doxxing. Any attempt to include those directly in this Condemnation would immediately make it illegal - see Rule 2.

Just confirming that this would be a rule 2 violation.

[Israeli Empiratic Commonwealth]

At the risk of repeating points made by Armaros, Praeceps and Lord Dominator, here's my take on your attempt.

The Security Council;
Recognizing the extreme wrongdoing a region or nation must commit to receive condemnation;
Acknowledging that one region has such qualities of wrongdoing, Antifa;

Reasonable enough preamble.

Noting that Antifa is not a region on it's own, but an alliance of regions, including but not limited to: The Leftist Assembly, The Red Fleet, The Communist Bloc, and The MT Army;

However, you are trying to Condemn the region of Antifa, you've said so in the preamble and in the final operative clause. This clause, therefore, is irrelevant. Also I hate it when authors use "it's" when they should be using "its".

Proof of their intentions to destroy fascism is implanted everywhere and is well known.

Really? Actually if true then maybe you should be Commending them.

Understanding that this is not the worst part of Antifa, as the worst part is unjust raids against NON fascist regions

Badly constructed clause.

Appalled at Antifa for raiding, and provoking regions that are NOT fascist just for their affiliation or the belief in freedom of speech, including:

a. The Free Commonwealth A new region, raided due to their "Fascist" tag. They were absolutely not fascist.
b. Northern Redlands Libertarian-Right of Center region, raided for "concerning RMB posts".
c. Make America Great Again Conservative region, presumably raided for the wrong assumption that they are fascist.
d. League of the United Tribes of Dakia Not fascist, and no justification cited for raiding at all.

So in point a. a region flying the Fascist tag is definitely not fascist? Bit of stretch that. As for the other raids you've mentioned, no real detail just your assumptions.

Highlighting that these regions did nothing wrong to deserve a raid, other than disagree with principles of ANTIFA

And you know this how?

Noticing that Antifa openly or discreetly attacks ALL rightist regions as to fit the leftist and communist agenda of Antifa

All rightist regions? They must be very busy people.

Hereby condemns Antifa, a threat to peace in NationStates

A lot of poorly written rhetoric but not much detail.

Just a note about your claims to have evidence of hacking and doxxing. Any attempt to include those directly in this Condemnation would immediately make it illegal - see Rule 2.

Thank you, I will make some things more clear and better the wording on others

[Israeli Empiratic Commonwealth]

Author literally founded a region tagged as Fascist. Not suspicious motives at all.

Actually funny enough it was to try and test Antifa. The Free Commonwealth was created by someone who was openly Jewish, me, someone who openly disliked fascism, me, had a constitution that was more libertarian than the American one, https://www.nationstates.net/page=dispatch/id=1219620 (still being tweaked in government so don't lecture me on how it sucks it is the barebones), but we had embassies with Farkasfalka because I am personally friends with Vungar. Add a little fascist tag that I put on (notice democratic right next to it but oh well) and it gets raided. Seems legit

[Israeli Empiratic Commonwealth]

Yet another poorly written WA proposal by a triggered fascist.

"Fascist" hahahahahahahaaha communists are more fascist than me. Maybe....ehh maybe not. Spooky scary self hating Jew here

[The Blackcat Isles]

At the risk of repeating points made by Armaros, Praeceps and Lord Dominator, here's my take on your attempt.

Reasonable enough preamble.


However, you are trying to Condemn the region of Antifa, you've said so in the preamble and in the final operative clause. This clause, therefore, is irrelevant. Also I hate it when authors use "it's" when they should be using "its".


Really? Actually if true then maybe you should be Commending them.


Badly constructed clause.


So in point a. a region flying the Fascist tag is definitely not fascist? Bit of stretch that. As for the other raids you've mentioned, no real detail just your assumptions.


And you know this how?


All rightist regions? They must be very busy people.



A lot of poorly written rhetoric but not much detail.

Just a note about your claims to have evidence of hacking and doxxing. Any attempt to include those directly in this Condemnation would immediately make it illegal - see Rule 2.

Thank you, I will make some things more clear and better the wording on others

Friend, after the backlash you have received yesterday I strongly urge you to put this draft to rest. Not only do you provide no proof, several people have already pointed out that - by submitting this draft - you will be lying to the Security Council and trust me, you don't want the Security Council accuse your nation of lying to them.

Also, with how you have responded (or failed to respond constructively to the feedback of posters) in this thread, I can assure you that you have antagonized enough people that they'll do everything in their power to have this draft not even come to vote. The best thing you can do now is admit that this proposal is absolutely not going to work or have any merit (because there is no diabolical masterplan at work here like you suggested earlier) and let it rest.

[The Blackcat Isles]

Yet another poorly written WA proposal by a triggered fascist.

"Fascist" hahahahahahahaaha communists are more fascist than me. Maybe....ehh maybe not. Spooky scary self hating Jew here

This is what I mean by you antagonizing people. This is exactly the kind of behaviour that won't get you much support.

[Israeli Empiratic Commonwealth]

"Fascist" hahahahahahahaaha communists are more fascist than me. Maybe....ehh maybe not. Spooky scary self hating Jew here

This is what I mean by you antagonizing people. This is exactly the kind of behaviour that won't get you much support.

Oh and calling me fascist isn't antagonizing? See that's hypocrisy. I have only countered and intentionally tried to tick people off when they do the same to me. Notice how to you, because what you are saying is constructive, I am not. If he said something constructive rather than plainly call me fascist we wouldn't have a problem.