[Temporally Scrapped] Repeal: Condemn Macedon

[Germanic Tribes]

Temporally Scrapped

Current Draft

Security Council Resolution # 1 Condemn Macedon shall be struck out and be rendered Null and Void
The Security Council,
Understands The actions Macedon did to deserve this condemnation

Noting that this repeal does not wash away or pardon their actions in any way.

Also Understanding the historical precedent that this resolution has made

Is Confused That a minuscule region still has an outdated condemnation from 8 years ago

Considering That Macedon's Leaders and prominent raiders are either no longer around or have given up raiding from this region

Certain That Macedon no longer poses any threat to world peace or any other regions

The Security Council hereby Repeals Condemn Macedon

Note: You do not have to speak in character in this thread, it just kinda convoultes everything for some people such as me. You may speak in charterer, but don't expect everyone too.

Previous Drafts

Draft 1

Understands The actions Macedon did to deserve this condemnation

Is Confused That a minuscule region still has a outdated condemnation from 8 years ago

Considering That Macedon's Leaders and prominent raiders are either no longer around or have given up raiding from this region

Certain That Macedon no longer poses any threat to world peace or any other regions

The Security Council hereby Repeals Condemn Macedon

[Consular]

If you have a glance at the below search you'll see just how many times people have attempted this.

search.php?keywords=repeal+condemn+macedon&terms=all&author=&sc=1&sf=titleonly&sr=posts&sk=t&sd=d&st=0&ch=300&t=0&submit=Search

The short of it is this is considered an important historical resolution and it is not going to be the nice easy repeal lots of folks seem to think it is.

[Germanic Tribes]

If you have a glance at the below search you'll see just how many times people have attempted this.

search.php?keywords=repeal+condemn+macedon&terms=all&author=&sc=1&sf=titleonly&sr=posts&sk=t&sd=d&st=0&ch=300&t=0&submit=Search

The short of it is this is considered an important historical resolution and it is not going to be the nice easy repeal lots of folks seem to think it is.

If I expected it to be easy I would have just proposed it without making this thread first. I don't expect it to be a easy repeal, all repeals should be hard to get through imo. I also agree that it's significance of this resolution makes it hard to repeal

[Kylia Quilor]

At least try as well as the last people to try it.

[Germanic Tribes]

At least try as well as the last people to try it.

Sorta confused by that wording, you are saying "It's good to try even if you fail." I am correct?

[Wrapper]

More like, try harder, because this isn't going to get it done.

[Germanic Tribes]

More like, try harder, because this isn't going to get it done.

Yeah, Ill add more to it later, as I'm half working half checking these forums (With that said I now focus on work)

[The Noble Thatcherites]

You’ll need a beefier argument if you want this to get close to quorum

[Willania Imperium]

I fail to see the importance of this. Improve your argument.

[The Gipper]

Macedon was a big deal back in the day. Their password grief of Belgium caused pandemonium in the community and changed raid / defense forever. Their actions are the major reason we have Liberation proposals, and Liberation proposals may have been the driving force behind bringing us the Security Council in the first place. So even though they are gone, the effects of what they did and who they were really are not.

But even beyond that, ALL players will quit eventually. Just because they are no longer active today doesn’t take away from what happened all that long ago. The premise that we should take away badges just because the player or group stops playing is silly, and has routinely been rejected. They (and any other nominee) were not recognized because they were expected to be a significant villain for the rest of time. They were recognized because in their period, they were significant.

[Germanic Tribes]

I have updated the draft.

[Consular]

I'm going to be tad blunter than my first post then. This isn't repealable. It's not just a matter of your draft, it's that NS doesn't want to repeal that resolution.

[Lata Eden 2]

You’ll need a beefier argument if you want this to get close to quorum

I agree with him. The proposal needs a better argument

[Kylia Quilor]

At least try as well as the last people to try it.

Sorta confused by that wording, you are saying "It's good to try even if you fail." I am correct?

No. I'm saying that your effort needs to at least be as good as the last ones, because this is just an awful effort.

[Aclion]

Macedon was a big deal back in the day. Their password grief of Belgium caused pandemonium in the community and changed raid / defense forever. Their actions are the major reason we have Liberation proposals, and Liberation proposals may have been the driving force behind bringing us the Security Council in the first place. So even though they are gone, the effects of what they did and who they were really are not.

But even beyond that, ALL players will quit eventually. Just because they are no longer active today doesn’t take away from what happened all that long ago. The premise that we should take away badges just because the player or group stops playing is silly, and has routinely been rejected. They (and any other nominee) were not recognized because they were expected to be a significant villain for the rest of time. They were recognized because in their period, they were significant.

We kind of abandoned that precedent with Repeal: Commend Texas.

[Fauxia]

Macedon was a big deal back in the day. Their password grief of Belgium caused pandemonium in the community and changed raid / defense forever. Their actions are the major reason we have Liberation proposals, and Liberation proposals may have been the driving force behind bringing us the Security Council in the first place. So even though they are gone, the effects of what they did and who they were really are not.

But even beyond that, ALL players will quit eventually. Just because they are no longer active today doesn’t take away from what happened all that long ago. The premise that we should take away badges just because the player or group stops playing is silly, and has routinely been rejected. They (and any other nominee) were not recognized because they were expected to be a significant villain for the rest of time. They were recognized because in their period, they were significant.

We kind of abandoned that precedent with Repeal: Commend Texas.

Incorrect. This is (assuming y'all are telling the truth) a region that revolutionized r/d, besides being, ya know, the first SC resolution ever. Texas didn't revolutionize a major aspect of the game, and was repealed largely because it was basically just a second commendation of NewTexas

[Drasnia]

Macedon was a big deal back in the day. Their password grief of Belgium caused pandemonium in the community and changed raid / defense forever. Their actions are the major reason we have Liberation proposals, and Liberation proposals may have been the driving force behind bringing us the Security Council in the first place. So even though they are gone, the effects of what they did and who they were really are not.

But even beyond that, ALL players will quit eventually. Just because they are no longer active today doesn’t take away from what happened all that long ago. The premise that we should take away badges just because the player or group stops playing is silly, and has routinely been rejected. They (and any other nominee) were not recognized because they were expected to be a significant villain for the rest of time. They were recognized because in their period, they were significant.

We kind of abandoned that precedent with Repeal: Commend Texas.

Some of us would like to return to that precedent.

[Germanic Tribes]

Scrapping this for time being while I work on a different draft

[Consular]

Temporally scrapped?? Have you thrown it backwards in time to prevent the resolution ever passing in the first place?

[Germanic Tribes]

Temporally scrapped?? Have you thrown it backwards in time to prevent the resolution ever passing in the first place?

No, I just threw this draft into the firey pits of hell, then I'll bring it out in a later date all burned up

[The Noble Thatcherites]

Temporally scrapped?? Have you thrown it backwards in time to prevent the resolution ever passing in the first place?

No, I just threw this draft into the firey pits of hell, then I'll bring it out in a later date all burned up

If thats the case then why don't you just abandon the thread?

[Consular]

Temporally scrapped?? Have you thrown it backwards in time to prevent the resolution ever passing in the first place?

No, I just threw this draft into the firey pits of hell, then I'll bring it out in a later date all burned up

The joke was that you misspelled temporarily in the thread title.

[Germanic Tribes]

No, I just threw this draft into the firey pits of hell, then I'll bring it out in a later date all burned up

If thats the case then why don't you just abandon the thread?

I'm a lazy c**t. Plain and simple

[The Noble Thatcherites]

If thats the case then why don't you just abandon the thread?

I'm a lazy c**t. Plain and simple

You had enough time to rename the thread to "Temporarily Scrapped", you could've used that time to rename it to "Abandoned"

[Germanic Tribes]

I'm a lazy c**t. Plain and simple

You had enough time to rename the thread to "Temporarily Scrapped", you could've used that time to rename it to "Abandoned"

I've been found out! Time to CTE