[IDEAS] Ideas for SC Resolutions

[Team Leo]

Possibly controversial, but I think someone should finally condemn Tinhampton. She is a menace and must be stopped at all costs !!!

Like Auralia, but for different reasons, Tinhampton should never be badged, either a Commend or Condemn.

Why not? Hasn't she contributed to the WA?

[Fachumonn]

Possibly controversial, but I think someone should finally condemn Tinhampton. She is a menace and must be stopped at all costs !!!

Like Auralia, but for different reasons, Tinhampton should never be badged, either a Commend or Condemn.

Just cause she is possibly conservative? Or that you don't like her? I don't care if they took forever and a ton of attempts to get it done. A resolution is a resolution.

[Bormiar]

Like Auralia, but for different reasons, Tinhampton should never be badged, either a Commend or Condemn.

Just cause she is possibly conservative? Or that you don't like her? I don't care if they took forever and a ton of attempts to get it done. A resolution is a resolution.

Who cares if she wrote a resolution? I don't think tin would even want a commendation if all it is is a laundry list of resolutions authored like commend Skydip or Abacathea.

[Bhang Bhang Duc]

Like Auralia, but for different reasons, Tinhampton should never be badged, either a Commend or Condemn.

Just cause she is possibly conservative? Or that you don't like her? I don't care if they took forever and a ton of attempts to get it done. A resolution is a resolution.

I just know their history around here - you don’t.

[Outer Sparta]

Like Auralia, but for different reasons, Tinhampton should never be badged, either a Commend or Condemn.

Just cause she is possibly conservative? Or that you don't like her? I don't care if they took forever and a ton of attempts to get it done. A resolution is a resolution.

Ideological affiliation is irrelevant. Why did you insert that in there for no apparent reason?

[WayNeacTia]

Possibly controversial, but I think someone should finally condemn Tinhampton. She is a menace and must be stopped at all costs !!!

Like Auralia, but for different reasons, Tinhampton should never be badged, either a Commend or Condemn.

I tend to agree. Authorship is hardly commendable.

[Bormiar]

Like Auralia, but for different reasons, Tinhampton should never be badged, either a Commend or Condemn.

I tend to agree. Authorship is hardly commendable.

It's not commendable if the player just tries to bust out resolution after resolution. If they seem to genuinely be trying and believe in their drafts, I'd like to commend them for their play style and how they've contributed to the "entertaining-ness" and respectability of the WA, even if resolutions don't ultimately make much of an "impact". I admire Thousand Branches, for example, far more than players who have written twice as many resolutions.

This means that I don't find writing liberations* or repeals of liberations commendable at all. Nor do I find repeals for OOC actions commendable (e.g. Kaboom's stuff). There's simply nothing interesting nor difficult in passing it. I find it disappointing whenever an author simply lists out "player X wrote Y many resolutions", as I don't know whether they were thoroughly researched commendations or a liberation passed because there happened to be a raid going on and that author got there first.

If I were to list out Tinhampton's SC resolutions which seem commendable to me:

• Commend Nephara
• Commend Cassadaigua
• Commend Alasdair I Frosticus

That being said, Tin's written some nicely researched and written drafts I think are even better (e.g. commend TNP had some real promise), but did not pass. The problem is that while Tinhampton's writing is good, it gives off the wrong... mystique. Players may find it bizarre or too long due to Tinhampton's lack of political tact, her excess detail**, and her genuinely odd personality. I mean that in the best possible way.

A commendation of Tinhampton may benefit from portraying her through my rose-colored glasses. While Tin has a history of doing very politically inadvisable things — often leaving me dumbstruck — she's rather hard to offend or knock down, and for the most part approaches this game in her own way.

In other words, Tinhampton may be the only author crazy enough or tactless enough to attempt to commend Tinhampton.

* Maybe in rare circumstances.
** She's a very meticulous person who puts a lot of needless parentheticals (like this one) in her proposals.

[Unibot III]

Tin commending Tin has strong “Glenn Gould interviews Glenn Gould” vibes.

[Emodea]

I wonder if United Calanworie (and Aav’s collective nations) could be a good addition to this list. I honestly don’t know everywhere they’ve contributed but I know they were one of the main Hartfelden people as well as a Sage in Karma. I know they have some tech contributions as well but I doubt I would be able to understand them even if I knew what they were Pretty sure there’s more that I can’t think of off the top of my head as well.

Edit: I also think the formatting on Koth’s line is jacked up?

Edit 2: Actually Istillian might be a good nominee as well.

Added, fixed and added.

Possibly controversial, but I think someone should finally condemn Tinhampton. She is a menace and must be stopped at all costs !!!

That would be...interesting. Added.

[Hulldom]

Two things:

1. You can remove Electrum thanks to SC#397

2. Constaniana is listed twice…

[Emodea]

Two things:

1. You can remove Electrum thanks to SC#397

2. Constaniana is listed twice…

Donenzo.

[Nominicia]

It’s not on this list but do Tuscagora. Here’s why! ( it won’t be in format so whoever post's it can do that)

1.Elections. They are for all admin and there’s one going on right now
2.we are honoring someone in the region who got injured (or worse) in a tornado
3.we are having future events
4. We are anti fascist
5.we got tons of embassy’s
6. We have a news paper

[Fachumonn]

It’s not on this list but do Tuscagora. Here’s why! ( it won’t be in format so whoever post's it can do that)

1.Elections. They are for all admin and there’s one going on right now
2.we are honoring someone in the region who got injured (or worse) in a tornado
3.we are having future events
4. We are anti fascist
5.we got tons of embassy’s
6. We have a news paper

I'm sorry this is like every region I can think of, not commendable.

[Wymondham]

Commend MadJack would be a cool resolution

[Bormiar]

Commend MadJack would be a cool resolution

He doesn't particularly want it.

Edit: He's fine with it.

[Fachumonn]

Commend MadJack would be a cool resolution

He doesn't particularly want it.

Edit: He's fine with it.

I feel like going around and commending every GCR delegate kinda rips the meaningfulness behind a WA commendation. Sure, he's probably done a few commendable things, but he's hardly the most notable GCR delegate we haven't commended.

[Bormiar]

He doesn't particularly want it.

Edit: He's fine with it.

I feel like going around and commending every GCR delegate kinda rips the meaningfulness behind a WA commendation. Sure, he's probably done a few commendable things, but he's hardly the most notable GCR delegate we haven't commended.

You don't know what you're talking about.

[Fachumonn]

I feel like going around and commending every GCR delegate kinda rips the meaningfulness behind a WA commendation. Sure, he's probably done a few commendable things, but he's hardly the most notable GCR delegate we haven't commended.

You don't know what you're talking about.

A completely feasible possibility.

[Thousand Branches]

He doesn't particularly want it.

Edit: He's fine with it.

I feel like going around and commending every GCR delegate kinda rips the meaningfulness behind a WA commendation. Sure, he's probably done a few commendable things, but he's hardly the most notable GCR delegate we haven't commended.

Do name which ones you think are more c/cable

[Emodea]

Commend MadJack would be a cool resolution

It would be, will add to the list when I get to my PC.

[Emodea]

Added Madjack.

[Fachumonn]

I feel like going around and commending every GCR delegate kinda rips the meaningfulness behind a WA commendation. Sure, he's probably done a few commendable things, but he's hardly the most notable GCR delegate we haven't commended.

Do name which ones you think are more c/cable

Amerion most definitely.

[Thousand Branches]

Do name which ones you think are more c/cable

Amerion most definitely.

Amerion’s been on the list for ages.

[Fachumonn]

Amerion most definitely.

Amerion’s been on the list for ages.

Ik, I said ones that we haven't commended yet, not put on the list. I would like to see a Amerion proposal before I see a Madjack proposal.

[Thousand Branches]

Amerion’s been on the list for ages.

Ik, I said ones that we haven't commended yet, not put on the list. I would like to see a Amerion proposal before I see a Madjack proposal.

So one person’s commendability does not dictate somebody elses. There’s not just one commendable GCR delegate, and several can be put on the list. I do not understand your argument even a little bit.