Yet Another Clarification Needed

[SuperHappySmileyWorld]

Yello, with my digging through various facets of NS in lue of the 10th anniversary and all, a question has once more risen… How exactly are Commendations and Condemnations chosen?

I mean I understand the idea of them: An RP way of saying ‘Yay Good guy’ or ‘Boo Mean guy’, it not inherently effecting the game or what not, but it has none the less caused me some curiosity

I mean, Raider Regions get condemned because of raiding, clearly, but raiding in of itself is not enough to get you condemned. Meanwhile some Commendation is based in varying motives, as seen by browsing this thread for even this period of time

So all I ask is that… can someone possibly better versed in this as I explain this so I can understand?

Thank you kindly for your time

[Skyrim Diplomacy]

It's very subjective and, ultimately, based on what the WA members as a whole agree on. For example, TBR was basically condemned simply for raiding, but that wouldn't work for new, start-up. Ideally, many factors should be included in both Commendations and Condemnations, and it's very difficult to pass either y focusing solely on one or even a few attributes or actions.

[Dagguerro]

Possibly best summarised as:
1. Do a lot of good or bad things over a long period of time.
Or:
2. Do one (or a handful of) good or bad thing(s) really, really, really well over a long period of time.

They tend to be the general ideas behind most of them.

[Strawberrry Fields]

Also you need to be well-known by the NS community, if you do alot of good or alot of bad, but most people don't know you, it's unlikely to pass.

Ah to be one of the popular people, briefly be commended or condemned, until someone more popular doesn't like you and repeals it.

[SuperHappySmileyWorld]

It's very subjective and, ultimately, based on what the WA members as a whole agree on. For example, TBR was basically condemned simply for raiding, but that wouldn't work for new, start-up. Ideally, many factors should be included in both Commendations and Condemnations, and it's very difficult to pass either y focusing solely on one or even a few attributes or actions.

Possibly best summarised as:
1. Do a lot of good or bad things over a long period of time.
Or:
2. Do one (or a handful of) good or bad thing(s) really, really, really well over a long period of time.

They tend to be the general ideas behind most of them.

Also you need to be well-known by the NS community, if you do alot of good or alot of bad, but most people don't know you, it's unlikely to pass.

Ah to be one of the popular people, briefly be commended or condemned, until someone more popular doesn't like you and repeals it.

*bow* Thank you muchly for allowing me to see the light, I have no ambition to pursue either, but it is always nice to know what is going on in this chaotic and insane land that is NS