Illegal SC proposals - post them here

[East Meranopirus]

Security Council Proposal
ID: trivian_1565763089

Commend India

A resolution to recognize outstanding contribution by a nation or region.

Category: Commendation

Nominee: India

Proposed by: Trivian

Recognizing to the fact that the Region of India has massively , uniformly and structurally contributed to the Regional Peace Inference from the time of it's very
Formation.

Pointing to the very fact that the Regional Government at various times spans has taken different Initiative's in order to uplift the Democratic and Social Harmony values within it's Member Nation's.

Observing that the Region of India has also helped in Liberating and Performed various embassy oriented Diplomatic and Security Engagement Assertions whenever the time Bounded them to act so.

Proved and Provided that from the Time of it's very Establishment the Region has never tried to violate or tried to socialize Disharmony and had acted every now and then within the Bounded Limits of the Nation States Rules Governance and Matrix.

To be Recorded that the Region of India has Initiated various cultural reforms in order to educate the Real Life Values , Cultures and Custom's of the Country India.

Provided that the Region India has clutched to the Values of Harmony , Fraternity and Justice to each and every Member Nation

HENCE COMMEND INDIA .

R4(a).

https://www.nationstates.net/page=UN_vi ... 1565763089

Why on Earth did Jakker mark this legal?

[Ransium]

Security Council Proposal
ID: trivian_1565763089

Commend India

A resolution to recognize outstanding contribution by a nation or region.

Category: Commendation

Nominee: India

Proposed by: Trivian

Recognizing to the fact that the Region of India has massively , uniformly and structurally contributed to the Regional Peace Inference from the time of it's very
Formation.

Pointing to the very fact that the Regional Government at various times spans has taken different Initiative's in order to uplift the Democratic and Social Harmony values within it's Member Nation's.

Observing that the Region of India has also helped in Liberating and Performed various embassy oriented Diplomatic and Security Engagement Assertions whenever the time Bounded them to act so.

Proved and Provided that from the Time of it's very Establishment the Region has never tried to violate or tried to socialize Disharmony and had acted every now and then within the Bounded Limits of the Nation States Rules Governance and Matrix.

To be Recorded that the Region of India has Initiated various cultural reforms in order to educate the Real Life Values , Cultures and Custom's of the Country India.

Provided that the Region India has clutched to the Values of Harmony , Fraternity and Justice to each and every Member Nation

HENCE COMMEND INDIA .

R4(a).

https://www.nationstates.net/page=UN_vi ... 1565763089

I think an R4(c) illegality argument could be made as well because of this line:

Nation States Rules Governance and Matrix.

I marked it illegal for R4a/c I guess Fris was only convinced of a.

Why on Earth did Jakker mark this legal?

As I made clear four posts ago, this thread isn't for commentary:

If you don’t have anything of substance don’t post in this thread.

Take an unofficial warning for spamming. I've also updated the OP of this thread to make clear the commentary unrelated to the legality of a proposal will get you warned for spamming.

[Kuriko]

Security Council Proposal
ID: tanzanique_1565870314

Commend The Bar On The Corner Of Every Region
A resolution to recognize outstanding contribution by a nation or region.

Category: Commendation

Nominee: The Bar on the corner of every region

Proposed by: Tanzanique

Acknowledging Past attempts to Commend The Bar on the Corner of Every Region.

Recognizing The Regions influence, and It's place as a hub for nations of all Regions to come together in unity.

Noticing How the region brings raiders and defenders together through Embassies.

Seeing how many activities the Region has to offer to keep it active and to attract new nations, such as the following:

•The Regions ever active RP community, role-playing everyday things that occur in the bar, as well as other things that include Sorcery and Magic.

•The Regions regular Polls, that normally includes some sort of wacky or odd type of shenanigans.

•The Regions Unique Weekly poetry contest that has gone on for over a year, that the let's the Region and it's Embassies residents show their Creativity through different types of poetry that are chosen by the winner of the previous weeks contest.

Believing, that these reasons are capable of commending a region, and that other Regions in the past have been commended under these circumstances.
Hereby Commends The Bar on the corner of every region.

This is an edited version of another proposal submitted by Tanzanique.

https://www.nationstates.net/page=UN_vi ... 1565870314

R4(b) for mentioning RP. I always have trouble deciding which it is, but i lean R4(b) because people RP and not nations.

[Ransium]

Security Council Proposal
ID: tanzanique_1565870314

Commend The Bar On The Corner Of Every Region
A resolution to recognize outstanding contribution by a nation or region.

Category: Commendation

Nominee: The Bar on the corner of every region

Proposed by: Tanzanique

Acknowledging Past attempts to Commend The Bar on the Corner of Every Region.

Recognizing The Regions influence, and It's place as a hub for nations of all Regions to come together in unity.

Noticing How the region brings raiders and defenders together through Embassies.

Seeing how many activities the Region has to offer to keep it active and to attract new nations, such as the following:

•The Regions ever active RP community, role-playing everyday things that occur in the bar, as well as other things that include Sorcery and Magic.

•The Regions regular Polls, that normally includes some sort of wacky or odd type of shenanigans.

•The Regions Unique Weekly poetry contest that has gone on for over a year, that the let's the Region and it's Embassies residents show their Creativity through different types of poetry that are chosen by the winner of the previous weeks contest.

Believing, that these reasons are capable of commending a region, and that other Regions in the past have been commended under these circumstances.
Hereby Commends The Bar on the corner of every region.

This is an edited version of another proposal submitted by Tanzanique.

https://www.nationstates.net/page=UN_vi ... 1565870314

R4(b) for mentioning RP. I always have trouble deciding which it is, but i lean R4(b) because people RP and not nations.

I think it’s R4(c) but it’s academic. I also feel the final line breaks the WA’s perspective.

[Bhang Bhang Duc]

Security Council Proposal
ID: the_hanzanburg_union_1566623329

Commend The Hanzanburg Union

A resolution to recognize outstanding contribution by a nation or region.

Category: Commendation

Nominee: The Hanzanburg Union

Proposed by: The Hanzanburg Union

RECOGNIZING the Nation of The Hanzanburg Union as a leader of the embassy of NationStates for international peace.

OBSERVING The Hanzanburg Union efforts in maintaining order, stability, and leadership for the embassy region and the world.

VIEWING The Hanzanburg Union knowledge, teaching, and leadership in NationStates roleplay for other nations in NationState.

NOTING that The Hanzanburg Union struggle to develop the embassy by keeping the region safe from raiders to keep the relationship between the embassy and 4000 other embassies strong and peace, to make the world peace.

HEREBY commends The Hanzanburg Union in the form of an official commendation by the World Assembly.

https://www.nationstates.net/page=UN_vi ... 1566623329

R4 - use of “roleplay”

[Ransium]

Got it thanks!

[Cormactopia Prime]

Security Council Proposal
ID: the_celtic_dragon_1566689099

Repeal: “Condemn The New Inquisition”
A resolution to repeal previously passed legislation.

Category: Repeal

Resolution: SC#285

Proposed by: The Celtic Dragon

Security Council Resolution #285 “Condemn The New Inquisition” shall be struck out and rendered null and void.

This is rubbish, theyre dormant,
Should we bother a region that is currently inactive? No

https://www.nationstates.net/page=UN_vi ... 1566689099

Probably a lot of things, but R3, no operative clause.

[Marxist Germany]

2d and possibly 4d as well

[Eumaeus]

Condemn The Pacific
A resolution to express shock and dismay at a nation or region.

Category: Condemnation

Nominee: the Pacific

Proposed by: Amaabj

As a facist regime The Pacific is a threat to International peace and prosperity. As a fasist region they are initiating raids to conquer regions and turn them facist. We must stand against this atrocity together or fall into facism. In the words of Benjamin Franklin "We must hang together or surely we shall all hang separately", and so we stand together and give this proclamation.

WE HEREBY CONDEMN THE PACIFIC FOR HARMING INTERNATIONAL PEACE AND PREYING ON WEAKER REGIONS, WE STAND TOGETHER IN DEFENCE OF DEMOCRACY AND THE PROTECTION OF OUR LIBERTY

Rule 4a. Link.

[Eumaeus]

Repeal: “Condemn North East Somerset”
A resolution to repeal previously passed legislation.

Category: Repeal

Resolution: SC#286

Proposed by: Pakistan Sub-continent

Security Council Resolution #286 “Condemn North East Somerset” shall be struck out and rendered null and void.

Thi kingdom has done no good and harm only I Condemn North East Somerset

• The unseating of Founderless Regions Alliance member Northern Chittowa as Delegate of Lazarus in April of 2008, a raid executed with the intention of pursuing plans to later take control of Lazarus itself.
• The infamous raid of Belgium in early 2012, which was on its own yet another an act of aggression against uninvolved natives.
• The coup of The Rejected Realms on February 2, 2012, through the raid of Belgium, which propelled the military forces of The New Inquisition into the Delegacy of The Rejected Realms. These actions were committed while the nation was a key member of a signatory region of the Pan Sinker Security Pact, displaying their lack of respect for fellow signatories of non-aggression treaties.

Link. Rule 2a (the bulleted sections are copied directly from SC #286), Rule 3 (the operative clause seems to be saying that this proposal is Condemning NES, not repealing the condemnation), and Rule 4d ("I Condemn").

Edit: Rule 2d as well I guess.

[Eumaeus]

Condemn Jihadi Mulk
A resolution to express shock and dismay at a nation or region.

Category: Condemnation

Nominee: Jihadi Mulk

Proposed by: Jambudveep

The Security Council,

Observing that Jihadi Mulk has spread hateful messages on the Regional Message Boards of India and United Empire of Islam,

Also observing that Jihadi Mulk has spread a lot of hate among the above two regions and turn them against each other when they were friendly,

Noticing that Jihadi Mulk has been banned by India and ejected by United Empire of Islam quite a number of times for its ignorance,

Rendered speechless by Jihadi Mulk’s complete disregard for human rights and the environment,

Revealing that Jihadi Mulk had a big hand in the recent attack on India and Bharat by a number of troller nations,

Appalled that it is openly proclaiming pro-terrorist ideals through its name and motto,

Hereby condemns Jihadi Mulk.

Link. A whole lot of Rule 2c, and the use of the term "Regional Message Boards" is a Rule 4c violation as well.

Edit: Oops, looks like Ransium ninja modded me.

[Eumaeus]

Repeal: “Condemn Koem Kab”
A resolution to repeal previously passed legislation.

Category: Repeal

Resolution: SC#287

Proposed by: Confederate Wastelands of America

Security Council Resolution #287 “Condemn Koem Kab” shall be struck out and rendered null and void.

I see no reason to condemn a nation for possessing a great deal of artistic work.

Link. Rule 2d, Rule 3, and Rule 4d.

[Eumaeus]

Repeal: “Condemn Koem Kab”
A resolution to repeal previously passed legislation.

Category: Repeal

Resolution: SC#287

Proposed by: Talonio

Security Council Resolution #287 “Condemn Koem Kab” shall be struck out and rendered null and void.

You can't get a condemnent over having a lot of paintings you dumbass

Link. Rule 2d, Rule 3, and I'm pretty sure that's flaming.

[Ransium]

Repeal: “Condemn Koem Kab”
A resolution to repeal previously passed legislation.

Category: Repeal

Resolution: SC#287

Proposed by: Talonio

Security Council Resolution #287 “Condemn Koem Kab” shall be struck out and rendered null and void.

You can't get a condemnent over having a lot of paintings you dumbass

Link. Rule 2d, Rule 3, and I'm pretty sure that's flaming.

Disappeared.

[Bormiar]

https://www.nationstates.net/page=UN_vi ... 1569260014

In perspective of author as shown by "THESE actions are seen as a crime in The Peoples Libertarian Union. The nation has shown no regret whatsoever to their actions."

Also doesn't have operative clauses.

https://www.nationstates.net/page=UN_vi ... 1569260037
https://www.nationstates.net/page=UN_vi ... 1569262145
Obviously against the rules.

[Ransium]

https://www.nationstates.net/page=UN_view_proposal/id=western_spilebo_1569260014

In perspective of author as shown by "THESE actions are seen as a crime in The Peoples Libertarian Union. The nation has shown no regret whatsoever to their actions."

Also doesn't have operative clauses.

https://www.nationstates.net/page=UN_vi ... 1569260037
https://www.nationstates.net/page=UN_vi ... 1569262145
Obviously against the rules.

Handled. Disagree about R4d "The People Liberatarian Union" is the region the target resides. He/She appears to be saying they violated the laws of their own region.

[Eumaeus]

Condemn The Free Peoples Democratic Republic
A resolution to express shock and dismay at a nation or region.

Category: Condemnation

Nominee: The Free Peoples Democratic Republic

Proposed by: Philipastan

The Free Peoples Democratic Republic should be condemned for its crime against the land.

ON the 23 of September, the year 2019, The Free Peoples Democratic Republic chose to mine their vast natural resources in return for nuclear power.

THESE actions are seen as a crime in The Peoples Libertarian Union. The nation has shown no regret whatsoever to their actions.

WE, The World Assembly, hereby request to condemn the Oppressed People of The Free Peoples Democratic Republic for its crimes against the land. Everyone who agrees has a big penis.

Link. Ignoring that last bit, all they really did to try to make it R3 compliant was italicizing "condemned" and repeating "for its crimes against the land", which continue to be a suggestion and a request respectively, as opposed to a legal operative clause.

[Ransium]

Condemn The Free Peoples Democratic Republic
A resolution to express shock and dismay at a nation or region.

Category: Condemnation

Nominee: The Free Peoples Democratic Republic

Proposed by: Philipastan

The Free Peoples Democratic Republic should be condemned for its crime against the land.

ON the 23 of September, the year 2019, The Free Peoples Democratic Republic chose to mine their vast natural resources in return for nuclear power.

THESE actions are seen as a crime in The Peoples Libertarian Union. The nation has shown no regret whatsoever to their actions.

WE, The World Assembly, hereby request to condemn the Oppressed People of The Free Peoples Democratic Republic for its crimes against the land. Everyone who agrees has a big penis.

Link. Ignoring that last bit, all they really did to try to make it R3 compliant was italicizing "condemned" and repeating "for its crimes against the land", which continue to be a suggestion and a request respectively, as opposed to a legal operative clause.

I did not ignore the last bit. Let us know if it continues. If the proposal is obviously OSRS breaking or attention seeking spam, I’d prefer just a link without quotes. There’s not much in the way of SC scholarly information to be ascertained from that stuff.

[Eumaeus]

Condemn The Anti PLU Pact
A resolution to express shock and dismay at a nation or region.

Category: Condemnation

Nominee: The Anti PLU Pact

Proposed by: Western Spilebo

HEARING the Anti PLU Pact's opinion on the creation of this region, The Peoples Libertarian Union has found this foundation absurd.

KNOWING that the Anti PLU Pact was created in spite of the Peoples Libertarian Union, they have requested to condemn this region. The Anti PLU Pact has created everything, including its name, in an attempt to belittle the Peoples Libertarian Union.

PERCIEVING the Anti PLU Pact's name consists of slander toward The Peoples Libertarian Union, in their name, "PLU" stands for Peoples Libertarian Union. This is a clear attack toward the people of that region.

UNDERSTANDING that the Anti PLU Pact was founded from ex-members of the Peoples Libertarian Union helps the World Assembly understand why the region was created. In the Peoples Libertarian Union, each country is given the founder's trust as they join. The founder of the Peoples Libertarian Union, Philipistan, gave the Anti PLU Pact their trust. The members of the Anti PLU Pact took advantage of this trust and tried to abuse the power they were given. A member of the Anti PLU Pact, The Free Peoples Democratic Republic, abused their border control power by attempting to kick Western Spilibo out of the Peoples Libertarian Union.

HAVING all of this information, it is undeniable that the Anti PLU Pact should be condemned, upon request of the World Assembly. This condemnation of the Anti PLU Pact will save future states from joining a region consisting of lying accommodationists. The World Assembly will attempt to protect any state from falling into the hands of traitors.

Link. Rule 3 and while it seems slightly more Rule 4d compliant than the version from earlier today I still think the "hearing" clause is a violation.

[Ransium]

Condemn The Anti PLU Pact
A resolution to express shock and dismay at a nation or region.

Category: Condemnation

Nominee: The Anti PLU Pact

Proposed by: Western Spilebo

HEARING the Anti PLU Pact's opinion on the creation of this region, The Peoples Libertarian Union has found this foundation absurd.

KNOWING that the Anti PLU Pact was created in spite of the Peoples Libertarian Union, they have requested to condemn this region. The Anti PLU Pact has created everything, including its name, in an attempt to belittle the Peoples Libertarian Union.

PERCIEVING the Anti PLU Pact's name consists of slander toward The Peoples Libertarian Union, in their name, "PLU" stands for Peoples Libertarian Union. This is a clear attack toward the people of that region.

UNDERSTANDING that the Anti PLU Pact was founded from ex-members of the Peoples Libertarian Union helps the World Assembly understand why the region was created. In the Peoples Libertarian Union, each country is given the founder's trust as they join. The founder of the Peoples Libertarian Union, Philipistan, gave the Anti PLU Pact their trust. The members of the Anti PLU Pact took advantage of this trust and tried to abuse the power they were given. A member of the Anti PLU Pact, The Free Peoples Democratic Republic, abused their border control power by attempting to kick Western Spilibo out of the Peoples Libertarian Union.

HAVING all of this information, it is undeniable that the Anti PLU Pact should be condemned, upon request of the World Assembly. This condemnation of the Anti PLU Pact will save future states from joining a region consisting of lying accommodationists. The World Assembly will attempt to protect any state from falling into the hands of traitors.

Link. Rule 3 and while it seems slightly more Rule 4d compliant than the version from earlier today I still think the "hearing" clause is a violation.

Yep.

[Bhang Bhang Duc]

Security Council Proposal
ID: patriarchate_of_the_vatican_1569946412

Condemn Separatist Peoples

A resolution to express shock and dismay at a nation or region.

Category: Condemnation

Nominee: Separatist Peoples

Proposed by: Patriarchate of the Vatican

Understanding that the role of the Secreriat of the General Assembly is to facilitate in the determination of the worthiness and legality of the proposals submitted to the said assembly,

Concerned that one of the members of the Secretariat, the respondent of this condemnation, invokes too much technicality in labelling a Resolution to Repeal "Freedom of Religion" as illegal without full understanding of the proposal to repeal.

Clearly, the Proposal to Repeal cited section 6 of the Freedom of Religion as the basis why the said law should be repealed. The respondent of this condemnation, who happened to be a member of the secretariat misunderstood the citation and concluded that the repeal only targets section 6 and not the entire law. Indeed, the Proposal to Repeal is intended for the entire law and not of the specific section only which was used as the basis for the proposal.

Condemning the Respondent, for dishonesty in rendering his function as a member of the Secretariat of the General Assembly.

Rule 1, R4(b) and probably tit-for-tat.

https://www.nationstates.net/page=UN_vi ... 1569946412

[Ransium]

Security Council Proposal
ID: patriarchate_of_the_vatican_1569946412

Condemn Separatist Peoples

A resolution to express shock and dismay at a nation or region.

Category: Condemnation

Nominee: Separatist Peoples

Proposed by: Patriarchate of the Vatican

Understanding that the role of the Secreriat of the General Assembly is to facilitate in the determination of the worthiness and legality of the proposals submitted to the said assembly,

Concerned that one of the members of the Secretariat, the respondent of this condemnation, invokes too much technicality in labelling a Resolution to Repeal "Freedom of Religion" as illegal without full understanding of the proposal to repeal.

Clearly, the Proposal to Repeal cited section 6 of the Freedom of Religion as the basis why the said law should be repealed. The respondent of this condemnation, who happened to be a member of the secretariat misunderstood the citation and concluded that the repeal only targets section 6 and not the entire law. Indeed, the Proposal to Repeal is intended for the entire law and not of the specific section only which was used as the basis for the proposal.

Condemning the Respondent, for dishonesty in rendering his function as a member of the Secretariat of the General Assembly.

Rule 1, R4(b) and probably tit-for-tat.

https://www.nationstates.net/page=UN_vi ... 1569946412

Got it.

[Bormiar]

https://www.nationstates.net/page=UN_vi ... 1570208912

Security Council Resolution #224 “Commend Drasnia” shall be struck out and rendered null and void.

The World assembly,

To begin
The resolution SC#224 commends Drasnia by proposing issues which kind of collides with rule 1: you can't commend members of Staff.
Ransium as proposing the resolution obviously should not be able to approve it, as approving its own resolution would be plain out corruption.

Acknowledging
Drasnia is not an issue editor but it is collaborating by proposing issues and thus bing commended by that.

If & if
If Drasnia's commendation stands every member of the site Staff should be commended for their duty as site Staff which clearly violates rule 1

Thus repeals Drasnia's commendation

Obviously Ransium will discard this proposal which further proves my point

Rule 4(c), usage of "staff".

Edit: Just read the ending. Obvious spam and perhaps baiting.

[Marxist Germany]

Looks like 2d as well

[Borovan entered the region as he]

RECOGNIZING the player of Kandarin as a leader in various aspects of NationStates.

OBSERVING his tireless efforts in maintaining order, stability, and leadership in a "collecting" region without means of ejecting or banning the competition.

VIEWING his knowledge, teaching, and leadership in NationStates roleplay, in both in character and out of character aspects, for off-site and on-site forums.

OFFICALLY praises the player behind the nation of Kandarin and recognizes his achievements with a commendation from the World Assembly.

https://www.nationstates.net/page=UN_vi ... 1571438098
Saying his and player, and roleplay
Plagiarism of Todd mcloud
https://www.nationstates.net/page=WA_pa ... /council=2
Words look copied