Tule wrote:I've been wondering. Who would win in an unarmed fight: an average street cop or an average foot soldier?
I'm leaning towards the cop as they have to fight unarmed a lot more, but I'm not certain.
I'd argue military - policemen on the beat are generally trained with two assumptions in mind; fight to disable, and the fact that they're in an easily reinforced environment (which encourages fairly conservative, defensive combat). A hand-to-hand-combat trained soldier will generally be aiming to dispatch the enemy quickly and lethally, and with that sort of training and mentality in mind the average policeman is probably going to have a fair bit of trouble engaging the soldier on equal terms.
E: Worth noting that this is a generalisation; remember, some police forces are geared towards military action (i.e. Gendarmerie Nationale during the Cold War) and some militaries are geared towards police action (i.e. the IDF), so you'll obviously see force-specific quirks acting in different directions if you actually start comparing real world examples.




I'm really, really rusty, having been away from this all for a good year and then some, so it'll be a bit shabby here and there. I'll try to patch it up.