Posted: Thu Jul 15, 2010 12:45 am
Dagnia wrote:I think you are hilarious. Humor was your intent wasn't it?
On a more serious note, I think there may be some truth to that. As an atheist myself, I have had major problems with relationships. A big part of it I think is that good relationships are based on common values. There are many different types of atheism, from Ayn Rand's Objectivism (my own greatest intellectual influence), various types of Existentialism, a number of communist, socialist and anarchist philosophies that go beyond mere politics, Buddhism (technically an atheistic religion) and too many other philosophies to count. There are so few of us and so many types of atheism that finding a partner with both your value system as well as the more shallow things (looks, personal habits) is almost impossible. Christianity, whether it is Catholic, a hundred different Protestant denominations, a hundred different Eastern Orthodox denominations, Mormon, is all basically the same philosophy and value system. Christians have their values prefabricated for them, while atheists, thinking for themselves (for the most part, though I do know some people who follow the words of Marx, Nietzsche and even Ayn Rand with the same blind religious zeal as a Christian or Muslim), may not come to the same conclusion about some pretty fundamental things in life, even when they believe in the same basic philosophy.
But its precisely that pre-fabrication that I think warrants caution. Even within stringently well-defined doctrines, reasonable minds can differ. (Due to the contemplative nature of your response, I'll omit my four paragraph bitch-fest rant on how wives are not reasonable).
Atheists, on the other hand, must work out a common set of values and expectations that are specific to them. While I think you make a sound point that a common religion (or any other overlapping mentality) can and often do serve to support the relationship and allow for common ground, it is still externally developed.
Or, as DeVito once said, "Dog people should marry dog people and cat people should marry cat people". Seriously, though, I can see your point.