NATION

PASSWORD

Christianity and mental illness

For discussion and debate about anything. (Not a roleplay related forum; out-of-character commentary only.)

Advertisement

Remove ads

User avatar
Dyakovo
Post Kaiser
 
Posts: 83162
Founded: Nov 13, 2007
Ex-Nation

Re: Christianity and mental illness

Postby Dyakovo » Mon Jun 29, 2009 11:42 am

Chetssaland wrote:
Aelosia wrote:I am a catholic, do I count as christian or not?


Yeah. You count, you have the same basic beleifs that Christians have. Some beliefs differ though, like Purgatory.

The same basic beliefs?
Catholics are christians, period.
Don't take life so serious... It isn't permanent...
Freedom from religion is an integral part of Freedom of religion
Married to Koshka
USMC veteran MOS 0331/8152
Grave_n_Idle: Maybe that's why the bible is so anti-other-gods, the other gods do exist, but they diss on Jehovah all the time for his shitty work.
Ifreann: Odds are you're secretly a zebra with a very special keyboard.
Ostro: I think women need to be trained
Margno, Llamalandia, Tarsonis Survivors, Bachmann's America, Internationalist Bastard B'awwwww! You're mean!

User avatar
Mad hatters in jeans
Post Marshal
 
Posts: 19119
Founded: Nov 14, 2007
Ex-Nation

Re: Christianity and mental illness

Postby Mad hatters in jeans » Mon Jun 29, 2009 12:01 pm

The Cat-Tribe wrote:I need help convincing someone that believes in Christianity that mental illness is real and is not just something made up by the Devil.

I know this is a weird topic. I have a new, close friend who is bi-polar and a substance abuser. She has important figures in her life that, although they accept she should get treatment for the substance abuse, say that her diagnoses of mental illness are just lies the Devil has convinced her of and she needs no help for those issues other than prayer.

She won't listen to me because I am not a Christian, so I just don't know.

Obviously any information or links that might be persuasive would be appreciated, but I'm also curious as to what debate this might stir on NSG.

I suppose being there for when she feels bad, and being sociable with her would help.
Does she have any other friends or relatives who are aware of what she's like? perhaps they could try helping her out.

User avatar
Chetssaland
Senator
 
Posts: 4669
Founded: May 15, 2009
Ex-Nation

Re: Christianity and mental illness

Postby Chetssaland » Mon Jun 29, 2009 12:07 pm

You guys are acting like she's phsyco or something. Next you'll suggest shooting her with a tranqualizer gun and giving her the pill while she's out. You gotta actually talk and listen to her, not "tell her that pills are wafers"

User avatar
Treznor
Negotiator
 
Posts: 7343
Founded: Antiquity
Democratic Socialists

Re: Christianity and mental illness

Postby Treznor » Mon Jun 29, 2009 12:14 pm

Chetssaland wrote:You guys are acting like she's phsyco or something. Next you'll suggest shooting her with a tranqualizer gun and giving her the pill while she's out. You gotta actually talk and listen to her, not "tell her that pills are wafers"

When someone isn't getting essential medical care because of their belief system, it's hard to figure out how to get around it. The individual in question is more interested in her religious beliefs than in actually getting better. She's been taught that if she can't get better through God's grace, then the problem lies with her faith instead of a legitimate medical reason. We're brainstorming for ways to either circumvent her faith or use it to convince her to get help, and if some of those ideas seem a bit much consider the irrationality of the person in question.

User avatar
Dyakovo
Post Kaiser
 
Posts: 83162
Founded: Nov 13, 2007
Ex-Nation

Re: Christianity and mental illness

Postby Dyakovo » Mon Jun 29, 2009 12:15 pm

Chetssaland wrote:You guys are acting like she's phsyco or something.

She's certainly delusional...
Chetssaland wrote:Next you'll suggest shooting her with a tranqualizer gun and giving her the pill while she's out.

Good suggestion...
Chetssaland wrote:You gotta actually talk and listen to her,

Yeah, that's really going to work...
Chetssaland wrote:not "tell her that pills are wafers"

true on this part, your suggestion is much more likely to work.
Don't take life so serious... It isn't permanent...
Freedom from religion is an integral part of Freedom of religion
Married to Koshka
USMC veteran MOS 0331/8152
Grave_n_Idle: Maybe that's why the bible is so anti-other-gods, the other gods do exist, but they diss on Jehovah all the time for his shitty work.
Ifreann: Odds are you're secretly a zebra with a very special keyboard.
Ostro: I think women need to be trained
Margno, Llamalandia, Tarsonis Survivors, Bachmann's America, Internationalist Bastard B'awwwww! You're mean!

User avatar
Elite Cows
Civil Servant
 
Posts: 8
Founded: Apr 24, 2009
Ex-Nation

Re: Christianity and mental illness

Postby Elite Cows » Mon Jun 29, 2009 12:46 pm

In my opinion, they are the same thing.
My name is Edward. If one more f****** Twilighter says 'As in Cullen?' then I'll drink their blood and cover myself in glitter. DAMN IT! Gave my secret away...

*Stephanie Meyers: YOU RUINED MY NAME!*

User avatar
Maineiacs
Negotiator
 
Posts: 7316
Founded: May 26, 2005
Left-wing Utopia

Re: Christianity and mental illness

Postby Maineiacs » Mon Jun 29, 2009 12:56 pm

Aelosia wrote:I am a catholic, do I count as christian or not?



Not to most (but not all) evangelicals.
Economic:-8.12 Social:-7.59 Moral Rules:5 Moral Order:-5
Muravyets: Maineiacs, you are brilliant, too! I stand in delighted awe.
Sane Outcasts:When your best case scenario is five kilometers of nuclear contamination, you know someone fucked up.
Geniasis: Christian values are incompatible with Conservative ideals. I cannot both follow the teachings of Christ and be a Republican. Therefore, I choose to not be a Republican.
Galloism: If someone will build a wall around Donald Trump, I'll pay for it.
Bottle tells it like it is
add 6,928 to post count

User avatar
UnhealthyTruthseeker
Postmaster-General
 
Posts: 11988
Founded: Aug 16, 2008
Ex-Nation

Re: Christianity and mental illness

Postby UnhealthyTruthseeker » Mon Jun 29, 2009 1:06 pm

Maineiacs wrote:
Aelosia wrote:I am a catholic, do I count as christian or not?



Not to most (but not all) evangelicals.


The Earth is 6000 years old to most of them, though. I don't have much trust in their ability to recognize reality.
A little homework for you!

What part of L(f(t)) = Int(exp(-s*t)*f(t),t,0,inf) don't you understand?

User avatar
Ashmoria
Post Czar
 
Posts: 46718
Founded: Mar 19, 2004
Left-Leaning College State

Re: Christianity and mental illness

Postby Ashmoria » Mon Jun 29, 2009 1:16 pm

Rolling Dead wrote:
Chetssaland wrote:
Aelosia wrote:I am a catholic, do I count as christian or not?


Yeah. You count, you have the same basic beleifs that Christians have. Some beliefs differ though, like Purgatory.


Meh, my old History teacher would have raised a shitstorm if you said this in her class.


Dunno why though, guess she thinks only Protestants are Christians.

Has anyone mentioned Exorcist?

what school did you go to?
whatever

User avatar
German Nightmare
Diplomat
 
Posts: 630
Founded: Dec 06, 2004
Inoffensive Centrist Democracy

Re: Christianity and mental illness

Postby German Nightmare » Mon Jun 29, 2009 1:17 pm

I wonder if those people take aspirin when they have a headache - or whether they simply "pray to remove the demon"?

They sure sound like the latter - although should they ever take pain relieving medicine, that might be an angle from which to get at them.



I've done some research on the topic of mental illness when I myself was taking anti-depressants. Just out of curiosity, I was wondering what the Bible or Jesus would have to say on the matter. I've found many passages which were not helpful as they dealt with how physicians and doctors cannot help when the spirit is in need. Or, even worse, when mentally ill people were indeed harboring demons. That doesn't help in this instance - like, at all!

However, mental illnesses like chemical imbalances of the brain have - in my humble opinion - nothing to do with the spirit, but with the structure in which said spirit resides. Just like a broken bone or torn muscle, it's a physical problem, not a spiritual one.

So, according to my logic, a doctor who is able to help with brain chemistry does definitely not interfere with the spiritual well-being of a person. Not directly, anyway. He's helping the body actively, the mind passively, yet the spirit remains out of the equation. (Same goes for therapy during which the mind is helped actively.)

Besides, even Jesus does believe that there is a place for doctors, otherwise he wouldn't have chosen them in this example:

On hearing this, Jesus said, "It is not the healthy who need a doctor, but the sick.
But go and learn what this means: 'I desire mercy, not sacrifice.' For I have not come to call the righteous, but sinners."
(Matthew 9 12/13)

I command you for your interest in a friend's well-being. From what it sounds like, though, it's quite a tough undertaking when dealing with close-minded people. So remember:

Do not answer a fool according to his folly, or you will be like him yourself.
Answer a fool according to his folly, or he will be wise in his own eyes.

(Proverbs 26 4/5)

Edit: Does your friend share the same beliefs as her parents? Are you trying to convince her? Or is she willing to get help but her parents consider that evil? I'd appreciate it if you clarified that. Thanks.
Last edited by German Nightmare on Mon Jun 29, 2009 1:19 pm, edited 1 time in total.
Greetings from Europe!

Whatever you do, we did it first - and better!

GNM - Master of a gazillion smileys and ever-changing avatars. +9118 posts.

User avatar
The Alma Mater
Postmaster of the Fleet
 
Posts: 25619
Founded: May 23, 2004
Ex-Nation

Re: Christianity and mental illness

Postby The Alma Mater » Mon Jun 29, 2009 1:20 pm

Maineiacs wrote:
Aelosia wrote:I am a catholic, do I count as christian or not?

Not to most (but not all) evangelicals.


Catholics outnumber all other denominations of Christianity combined. Viva democracy - the majority has spoken and Catholics are hereby Christian ;)

As for the problem in the OP: would she accept that someone with brain *damage* can have impaired physical functions ? Can she then accept that damaging other parts of the brain will lead to things like memory loss etc ?

Or does she believe that all those old people with dementia or Alzheimers are "faking it" / sinners that have worshipped the devil too much ?
Last edited by The Alma Mater on Mon Jun 29, 2009 1:22 pm, edited 2 times in total.
Getting an education was a bit like a communicable sexual disease.
It made you unsuitable for a lot of jobs and then you had the urge to pass it on.
- Terry Pratchett, Hogfather

User avatar
DMistan
Chargé d'Affaires
 
Posts: 416
Founded: May 26, 2009
Ex-Nation

Re: Christianity and mental illness

Postby DMistan » Mon Jun 29, 2009 1:36 pm

The Cat-Tribe wrote:I need help convincing someone that believes in Christianity that mental illness is real and is not just something made up by the Devil.

I know this is a weird topic. I have a new, close friend who is bi-polar and a substance abuser. She has important figures in her life that, although they accept she should get treatment for the substance abuse, say that her diagnoses of mental illness are just lies the Devil has convinced her of and she needs no help for those issues other than prayer.

She won't listen to me because I am not a Christian, so I just don't know.

Obviously any information or links that might be persuasive would be appreciated, but I'm also curious as to what debate this might stir on NSG.


"someone that believes in Christianity"
Lots of people "believe in Christianity." Christians represent one third of the world's population.

It would help me help you if you could narrow down this "belief" to a particular denomination.

If this person belongs to one of the "mainstream" denominations, I can easily point them to respected medical doctors who are practitioners of that denomination.

Outside of the "mainstream" we have Restorationists, Baptists and Pentecostals. My personal experience is that it gets tough to convince this crowd of anything.

Then you have your non-denominational freelance "I feel the spirit but never studied divinity per se" crowd. Good Luck with that bunch.

User avatar
South Lorenya
Senator
 
Posts: 3925
Founded: Feb 14, 2007
Ex-Nation

Re: Christianity and mental illness

Postby South Lorenya » Mon Jun 29, 2009 3:48 pm

Unfortunately, abrahamics usually refuse to accept that believing there's an invisible guy in sky who can do anything is a mental illness.
-- King DragonAtma of the Dragon Kingdom of South Lorenya.

Nagas on a plane! ^_^

User avatar
Altergo
Diplomat
 
Posts: 721
Founded: May 25, 2009
Ex-Nation

Re: Christianity and mental illness

Postby Altergo » Mon Jun 29, 2009 3:59 pm

I'm a Christian and people who do not believe in mental illnesses are, to me, Mental retards

User avatar
Canuck Utopia
Spokesperson
 
Posts: 185
Founded: Feb 27, 2008
Ex-Nation

Re: Christianity and mental illness

Postby Canuck Utopia » Mon Jun 29, 2009 4:10 pm

Treznor wrote:I think the key here is her substance abuse. She needs to get that treated, the faster the better. Professionals who deal with substance abuse are generally pretty good at using belief systems to reinforce the need to recover. They also tend to identify behaviors that support substance abuse and address them, so if you focus on that and downplay the rest of her problems, it should all come together in a neat package.

Well lo and behold.....something that I can entirely agree with you on. :)

User avatar
Treznor
Negotiator
 
Posts: 7343
Founded: Antiquity
Democratic Socialists

Re: Christianity and mental illness

Postby Treznor » Mon Jun 29, 2009 4:15 pm

Canuck Utopia wrote:
Treznor wrote:I think the key here is her substance abuse. She needs to get that treated, the faster the better. Professionals who deal with substance abuse are generally pretty good at using belief systems to reinforce the need to recover. They also tend to identify behaviors that support substance abuse and address them, so if you focus on that and downplay the rest of her problems, it should all come together in a neat package.

Well lo and behold.....something that I can entirely agree with you on. :)

Uh oh. I must be wrong about something. ;)

User avatar
Straughn
Senator
 
Posts: 3530
Founded: Apr 11, 2004
Inoffensive Centrist Democracy

Re: Christianity and mental illness

Postby Straughn » Tue Jun 30, 2009 1:17 am

Rejistania wrote:Maybe one way to explain them the issue is to correlate it with physical illness. They will go to the doctor if they have a broken leg, so why not accept help against a 'broken' brain chemistry?

(If they don't search medical help even for these issues, you cannot help them, I guess)

Like the Four Humours?
http://ancienthistory.about.com/cs/hipp ... icmeds.htm

User avatar
Straughn
Senator
 
Posts: 3530
Founded: Apr 11, 2004
Inoffensive Centrist Democracy

Re: Christianity and mental illness

Postby Straughn » Tue Jun 30, 2009 1:19 am

Smunkeeville wrote:
The Cat-Tribe wrote:
Chetssaland wrote:I'm a Christian and I know that mental illness is real. I'm pretty sure thats not taught anywhere that the devill created mentel illness.


Do you know of any examples in the Bible of someone being mentally ill?

Nebuchadnezzar went crazy about the 4th chapter of Daniel, it wasn't demon possessed or a lie of the devil, he just went crazy... it was implied heavily that it was punishment from God for being arrogant and generally disrespecting the Jewish religion.

I'm not sure that example would be very helpful though, because after wandering around insane for a while, he eventually recovered miraculously.
Coulda been syphilis.

User avatar
Kikimo
Lobbyist
 
Posts: 17
Founded: Jun 17, 2009
Ex-Nation

Re: Christianity and mental illness

Postby Kikimo » Tue Jun 30, 2009 1:22 am

Smunkeeville wrote:Many Christians avoid help for their mental health problems because they view the profession of psychiatry as threatening to their worldview. .


If I didn't know better, I would have thought you were talking about Scientologists! :eek:

User avatar
Straughn
Senator
 
Posts: 3530
Founded: Apr 11, 2004
Inoffensive Centrist Democracy

Re: Christianity and mental illness

Postby Straughn » Tue Jun 30, 2009 1:28 am

UnhealthyTruthseeker wrote:
The Pumkin wrote:Hmmm. my mommy owner is both a licensed psychologist and a baptized christian. she says that the reason you don't hear about mental illness in the bible is because, so many years ago, the mental illness concept did not exist yet. they did refer however to evil spirits that would cause illness. the catholic church still sees possession as a cause of some types of so called mental illness. my mommy though thinks mental illness is a product of bum biology whose effects can be modified by modern day medications and psychological work. by the way, she thinks christianity can assist mental health because you are taught to take responsibility for your actions and you are taught to stop being your own manager, letting god lead you instead.

me on the other hand, i think tuna takes care of every ill.


The Catholic church also only recently pardoned Galileo.

Argh.
http://www.cbsnews.com/stories/2003/08/ ... 7365.shtml
:(

User avatar
Darkvora
Lobbyist
 
Posts: 22
Founded: Jun 30, 2009
Ex-Nation

Re: Christianity and mental illness

Postby Darkvora » Tue Jun 30, 2009 1:33 am

Catholicism is Christian to my church of baptist

User avatar
Triniteras
Diplomat
 
Posts: 667
Founded: Jan 02, 2007
Ex-Nation

Re: Christianity and mental illness

Postby Triniteras » Tue Jun 30, 2009 1:40 am

I once thought there might be a god. I left open the possibility until I had read and considered enough, I really did.
I distinctly recall the sensation of insanity.

User avatar
Heinleinites
Ambassador
 
Posts: 1075
Founded: Apr 10, 2008
Ex-Nation

Re: Christianity and mental illness

Postby Heinleinites » Tue Jun 30, 2009 2:39 am

South Lorenya wrote:Unfortunately, abrahamics usually refuse to accept that believing there's an invisible guy in sky who can do anything is a mental illness.


Aren't you the one who thinks they're a dragon? You might not be the best spoke-person for what is/is not a mental illness.

I'm surprised it took three pages for this particular sentiment to make an appearance, NSG must be mellowing.
Last edited by Heinleinites on Tue Jun 30, 2009 2:40 am, edited 1 time in total.
You will never see a man who would kiss a wench or cut a throat as readily as I, but the wench must be willing, and the man must be standing up against me, else by God! either were safe enough from me." - Samkin Aylward The White Company

Heinleinite's First Rule of Comedy: "It doesn't matter if you don't think I'm funny, just so long as I think I'm funny."

User avatar
South Lorenya
Senator
 
Posts: 3925
Founded: Feb 14, 2007
Ex-Nation

Re: Christianity and mental illness

Postby South Lorenya » Tue Jun 30, 2009 10:36 am

Heinleinites wrote:
South Lorenya wrote:Unfortunately, abrahamics usually refuse to accept that believing there's an invisible guy in sky who can do anything is a mental illness.


Aren't you the one who thinks they're a dragon? You might not be the best spoke-person for what is/is not a mental illness.

I'm surprised it took three pages for this particular sentiment to make an appearance, NSG must be mellowing.


Except I know full well that I'm not 100% sane -- whereas I'm pretty sure every cardinal* (and the pope, to boot!) is (1) suffering from the delusion I mentioned and (2) completely unwilling to admit that they could use professional help.

* Small red birds not included.
-- King DragonAtma of the Dragon Kingdom of South Lorenya.

Nagas on a plane! ^_^

User avatar
German Nightmare
Diplomat
 
Posts: 630
Founded: Dec 06, 2004
Inoffensive Centrist Democracy

Re: Christianity and mental illness

Postby German Nightmare » Wed Jul 01, 2009 6:53 pm

So, any progress?
Greetings from Europe!

Whatever you do, we did it first - and better!

GNM - Master of a gazillion smileys and ever-changing avatars. +9118 posts.

PreviousNext

Advertisement

Remove ads

Return to General

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: Aggicificicerous, American Legionaries, Armeattla, Betoni, Elejamie, Emotional Support Crocodile, Floofybit, Habsburg Mexico, Ifreann, Narland, Port Caverton, Siikalinna, The Grand Duchy of Muscovy, Umeria, Vassenor

Advertisement

Remove ads