Ifreann wrote:SD_Film Artists wrote:
Honest about what? It's not that I disagree (though I probably do too), it's that you don't really give a position to talk on. For the past few months you've largely just twisted people's words, jumped to conlusions and generally failed to stick to the questions at hand; I would have given up responding to you but I try to have some faith in that you're a veteran member. In the landlord and police threads you either stuck to borderline strawmen or just lead with 'but we could give people free stuff'; which while still a valid position to have, it is basically just turning the thread into a 'but what if socialism' thread rather than actually discussing what landlords/policeman could do differently inside this current society.
I'll repeat that if I'm not making the arguments that you want me to make then you can just stop involving me.
And I'll repeat that you don't have any arguments to make.
But those are different threads; as for this thread, when people remove statues based on one political objection, how is not not as I described? Remember that they themselves have been saying that, not just me projecting it onto them.
Who are these people saying that historical figures should have had the foresight to abide by modern values? I can't recall anyone ever saying anything of the sort in this thread or any like it.
You know exactly who they are. What else would they be objecting on? That the statue should have been brass rather than stone? That the colours aren't nice? Again please stick to the topic.
Yes, I know that it's not the one thing that you believe it is because it is different things.
SD_Film Artists wrote:What else would they be objecting on? That the statue should have been brass rather than stone? That the colours aren't nice? Again please stick to the topic.
No one is talking about a hive mind of the left, but you are talking the modus operadi of "these people".
Yes and you can start to address that any time you want. I've already self-quoted it multiple times.










