Is cereal soup?

[Risottia]

Cereals are seeds/grains of grasses. Putting grains into milk doesn’t make soup.

This.

[New haven america]

Cereals are seeds/grains of grasses. Putting grains into milk doesn’t make soup.

Soup is a liquid dish that can contain a verity of food matter including meat, vegetables, and grain.

Hence, it is a soup.

[Novos Romanos]

No

[Tierra Fuego]

I read that the word "soup" is for broth. In cereal I think the milk (or water) just activates the cereal, so probably not. But there are some sad cereals where the milk becomes better than the cereal, these can be soups, but I won't be eating them.

[New haven america]

I read that the word "soup" is for broth. In cereal I think the milk (or water) just activates the cereal, so probably not. But there are some sad cereals where the milk becomes better than the cereal, these can be soups, but I won't be eating them.

The milk is the broth.

[Esternial]

I read that the word "soup" is for broth. In cereal I think the milk (or water) just activates the cereal, so probably not. But there are some sad cereals where the milk becomes better than the cereal, these can be soups, but I won't be eating them.

The milk is the broth.

By the same logic a dolphin is a fish.

[Tierra Fuego]

The milk is the broth.

How did this happen?

[New haven america]

The milk is the broth.

By the same logic a dolphin is a fish.

No, dolphins are mammals because they possess mammary glands, breath air, and have horizontal tails instead of vertical tails.

[Esternial]

By the same logic a dolphin is a fish.

No, dolphins are mammals because they possess mammary glands, breath air, and have horizontal tails instead of vertical tails.

Indeed, I was being deliberately reductionist.

Dolphin is not a fish.
Milk is not a broth.

[New haven america]

No, dolphins are mammals because they possess mammary glands, breath air, and have horizontal tails instead of vertical tails.

Indeed, I was being deliberately reductionist.

Dolphin is not a fish.
Milk is not a broth.

Milk is a broth in the context of soup.

[Esternial]

Indeed, I was being deliberately reductionist.

Dolphin is not a fish.
Milk is not a broth.

Milk is a broth in the context of soup.

Dolphins are fish in the context of the ocean.

[Esheaun Stroakuss]

Lol why are we talking about dolphins?

[Esternial]

Lol why are we talking about dolphins?

Just...just hold on I'm still trying to figure out where I'm going with this.

[New haven america]

Milk is a broth in the context of soup.

Dolphins are fish in the context of the ocean.

False, as dolphins do not possess the quality to be a fish.

But milk possess the qualities to be a broth.

[Esternial]

Dolphins are fish in the context of the ocean.

False, as dolphins do not possess the quality to be a fish.

But milk possess the qualities to be a broth.

Milk can be a component to a broth, but is by itself not a broth. It's not infused with aromas and flavors from vegetables or meat.

Otherwise plain water can be a broth. Heck, coca-cola can be a broth. Might even be more a broth than milk, given it's been infused with...something.

This is utter madness and you surely know it.

[East British Indian Company]

My word, this forum proves itself in its worth and mirth

[New haven america]

False, as dolphins do not possess the quality to be a fish.

But milk possess the qualities to be a broth.

Milk can be a component to a broth, but is by itself not a broth. It's not infused with aromas and flavors from vegetables or meat.

Otherwise plain water can be a broth. Heck, coca-cola can be a broth. Might even be more a broth than milk, given it's been infused with...something.

This is utter madness and you surely know it.

That is correct.

Some soups have broths made only of water, with the main components coming from the bits in the soup.

[The Three Palins]

Lol why are we talking about dolphins?

Apparently if you boil them in milk it makes them into fish.

Ordering the dolphin broth? Legal. Your defense is that you didn't expect it to really be dolphin.
Boiling a dolphin in milk? Most places, this is illegal. But what happens in the kitchen ...
Eating the dolphin broth you ordered? Legal. It doesn't taste much like fish, but apparently it is.

[Old Zealand Founder]

Soup = solids and broth.
Broth = water infused with the flavor of fruit, vegetables and/or meat (including fish). does NOT include finely mixed solids like milkshakes.

Milk = not soup. Water with ice = not soup. Protein shakes = not soup.

can we sleep noiw

[The Three Palins]

Milk can be a component to a broth, but is by itself not a broth. It's not infused with aromas and flavors from vegetables or meat.

Otherwise plain water can be a broth. Heck, coca-cola can be a broth. Might even be more a broth than milk, given it's been infused with...something.

This is utter madness and you surely know it.

That is correct.

Some soups have broths made only of water, with the main components coming from the bits in the soup.

Unless it's made by a woman. All men can make broth, but no women can ... brother.

[Esternial]

Milk can be a component to a broth, but is by itself not a broth. It's not infused with aromas and flavors from vegetables or meat.

Otherwise plain water can be a broth. Heck, coca-cola can be a broth. Might even be more a broth than milk, given it's been infused with...something.

This is utter madness and you surely know it.

That is correct.

Some soups have broths made only of water, with the main components coming from the bits in the soup.

What?!

I need an example.

[Imperium Latine]

Nope. Never seen a restaurant having cereals with milk as the soup of the day.

[New haven america]

That is correct.

Some soups have broths made only of water, with the main components coming from the bits in the soup.

What?!

I need an example.

Miso Soup is only Water+Miso Paste.

The miso paste does not dissolve with the water, so if you let it cool and leave it alone for long enough the water and miso will split into 2 different sections. But we're not calling miso soup a cereal now, are we?

Hence, the hot water acts as a broth for the miso.

[Old Zealand Founder]

What?!

I need an example.

Miso Soup is only Water+Miso Paste.

The miso paste does not dissolve with the water, so if you let it cool and leave it alone for long enough the water and miso will split into 2 different sections.

Hence, the hot water acts as a broth for the miso.

Basically anything suspended in water will separate from it given enough time.

What you have described is a broth.

[New haven america]

Miso Soup is only Water+Miso Paste.

The miso paste does not dissolve with the water, so if you let it cool and leave it alone for long enough the water and miso will split into 2 different sections.

Hence, the hot water acts as a broth for the miso.

Basically anything suspended in water will separate from it given enough time.

What you have described is a broth.

Yes, because water can be a broth.